study: antidepressant and talk therapy no better than placebo

New Topic Post Reply Printable Version
[ << Previous Thread | Next Thread >> ]

Veteran Member

Date Joined Oct 2009
Total Posts : 4970
   Posted 12/30/2011 11:37 AM (GMT -6)   
"Neither antidepressants nor 'talk therapy' were able to outperform placebo pills in a new clinical trial on depression treatment ... "
But there's more to the study in the article, and the study was a very small one.  Read the link to the Reuters article before just believing, or disbelieving, the title.  Not all forms of psychotherapy were studied, and only two types of antidepressants were tried.
I'm posting this to see if anyone has had experience, good or bad.  I hope some will post their opinions.

It's Genetic
Veteran Member

Date Joined Mar 2010
Total Posts : 1540
   Posted 12/30/2011 12:27 PM (GMT -6)   
Tests of that type don't examine the long-range value of talk therapy, in my view, and I suspect that more value lies there than in medications in some instances.

Medications are really required where there is a chemical imbalance involved, and bipolar illness is caused by a chemical imbalance and depression may be caused by a chemical imbalance, as well.

I'm glad you posted the negative side of the study: "not all forms of psychotherapy were studied, and only two types of antidepressants were tried." Those alone are enough to make me have strong faith in talk therapy and APPROPRIATE dosage of proper medications.

In addition, the study doesn't reveal what types of depression were examined in the study: were they severely depressed or mildly depressed patients?

That's my opinion, as you called for.

Have a Happy New Year.


Post Edited (It's Genetic) : 12/30/2011 11:33:32 AM (GMT-7)

getting by
Forum Moderator

Date Joined Sep 2007
Total Posts : 42209
   Posted 12/30/2011 1:30 PM (GMT -6)   
I have done very well with antidepressants and talk therapy. I highly recommend a person tries both. Not all depressed people need meds, especially if it is situational depression. But many do.

That is just my two pennies worth.

Hugs, Karen
Moderator-Depression and fibromyalgia

fibromyalgia, Chronic fatigue, depression, allergies

Veteran Member

Date Joined Jul 2009
Total Posts : 2042
   Posted 12/30/2011 4:15 PM (GMT -6)   
One thing I learned a long time ago when it comes to talk therapy is that the patient and the therapist have to really click for it to have any chance of helping, and also the patient has to really try and cooperate with the process.

Another thing I know when it comes to medication is that it is a matter of the right medication at the right time and properly dosed for it to do any good.
2 confirmed herniated lumbar discs. Spinal Arthritis. Spinal Stenosis, diabetic peripheral nueropathy.
Moderator Depression Forum.

Elite Member

Date Joined Mar 2009
Total Posts : 20119
   Posted 12/30/2011 4:49 PM (GMT -6)   
a massive advocate of talk therapy. jamie


New Topic Post Reply Printable Version
Forum Information
Currently it is Friday, March 23, 2018 3:38 AM (GMT -6)
There are a total of 2,943,037 posts in 322,915 threads.
View Active Threads

Who's Online
This forum has 161292 registered members. Please welcome our newest member, chen4250150.
206 Guest(s), 2 Registered Member(s) are currently online.  Details
73monte, MooseSafari