Like you, I feel absolutely "therapy-resistant." I'm a college kid, too, and I'm usually so tired after classes that I don't want to go all the way across campus to Counseling Services. At the beginning, I really liked my therapist...but after a few visits, she started to rub me the wrong way -- and now I don't really feel like I'd be gaining anything by going to her anymore. I know a combined treatment of medication and therapy is what both my old psychologist and my psychiatrist want, but...I know what you mean by the "fake" vibes, and I'm not sure what to do about it all.
For the moment, I'm taking a few weeks off from therapy and seeing how I handle it. If I feel like it was really helping me, I plan on going back. If not, I think I may look for another counselor...or look into optional routes (like keeping a therapy journal and going over it with someone I love and trust).
Good luck, honey -- best of wishes, and let us know how things go!