The first one contains casein - which might create problems if you have an allergy to it?
The second one, natures plus, seems to have an overload of Vit. A, and I would be concerned about some of the ingredients in the white whole food blend: bananas, potato, pear, oat bran - so it's not gluten free.
That's just my opinion.
As you may know, I am a strong believer of supplementing with good quality whey protein shakes ( I have at least 2 a day) which I make with almond milk and a whole bunch of supplements and liquid minerals and liquid vitamins thrown in as well. I love my Dr. Mercola's Pro-Optimal Whey Protein, because they come from grass-fed cows, no antibiotics, no hormones, and already have digestive enzymes in them - which makes them easily digestible and I find them very soothing to my gut.
Dx - UC 09/2010.Tried various Mesalamine enemas/suppos/pills with Prednisone for several rounds without any help.PaleoDiet of proteins,veggies,salads, fruits, & protein shakes w/almond milk, Liquid Minerals& Vitamins,Maca powder,L-Glutamine 15g, D-Ribose 5g,L-ArgEthylEster,chia seeds,VSL#3,K2,VIt. D3 100,000 IU every 10 days.Transdermal LDN put me remission!