Can my Lyme serology negative test result be wrong?

Hello everyone,
I recently posted a post on the Chronic Fatigue forum, describing my symptoms and asking for ideas of what people think might be wrong with me. You can read the post here: http://www.healingwell.com/community/default.aspx?f=15&m=3028382 One person suggested that it could be Lyme Disease.
I've heard that false negatives come back a lot with Lyme. But I got a Lyme serology test, which I've heard is very accurate for diagnosing late-stage Lyme, and it came back negative.
What should I do-- should I get another test or see a Lyme-literate doctor? How would I find one of those in Canada, anyway?
If you have time, I would be very grateful if you could read through my post and give me any other ideas as to what might be the problem.
Thank you very much!
Did you have a western blot with it or just the titer? What lab did it go through? Test are often negative it doesn't mean you don't have lyme. See an LLMD if you think it's lyme.
Excuse typos and or spelling and grammatical errors. I try to proofread, it's hard right now. Believed to be infected at least 28 yrs, dx 2012. Kiddos with congenital lyme. I am a nurse but a sick stay at home mom currently.
I would get checked for PANDAS TOO!!!!!
Excuse typos and or spelling and grammatical errors. I try to proofread, it's hard right now. Believed to be infected at least 28 yrs, dx 2012. Kiddos with congenital lyme. I am a nurse but a sick stay at home mom currently.
If you enable your email I can send you a list of Canadian drs you can call to start. Are your parents helping you?
Excuse typos and or spelling and grammatical errors. I try to proofread, it's hard right now. Believed to be infected at least 28 yrs, dx 2012. Kiddos with congenital lyme. I am a nurse but a sick stay at home mom currently.
Hi, I'm not sure what tests are serology tests. I can tell you the Western blot/elisa tests my son had (2x) were negative although he had multiple expanding bullseye rashes.
My experience with the Lyme serology test leads me to believe it's basically a waste. I had mine through IGeneX which came out barely equivocal so it was leaning towards negative while my Western Blot through them was positive.

Like others have mentioned you need to find an LLMD who will probably do a WB through IGeneX as they are the most trusted lab.
Hello again,
I have not posted on this thread for a while, but I'm still confused about whether or not I should get further testing. (I've been pursuing other health treatments and tests over the past few months.) To clarify, the test I got was an IgG serology test. Is this the same as a Western Blot test, or could it be a different kind? If it was a Western Blot test that I got, could it still be wrong?
When I look it up on Google, the search results are very confusing, aren't they?
Thanks.
Mangaka
No it's a different test than the Western Blot. I had both the WB and the Lyme serology done through IGeneX Labs. The serology was just barely equivocal yet the WB showed many bands so it was positive. The serology test is not an accurate test because it produces so many false negatives or equivocals. I would seek out an LLMD and do the WB but only through IGeneX as they have the best WB.

Post Edited (ToddPaul) : 6/25/2014 1:14:18 PM (GMT-6)

where in Canada are you from?

If it's BC, or you are close to BC and can travel - there is a LLND in Richmond. 80% of his business is Lyme disease...so he is very knowledgeable and experienced in treating.
Someone on this forum sees him and says he is good.
Symptoms started Sept, 2013 (maybe sooner?)...still undiagnosed. Started Buhner's protocol May 15, 2014
Waiting for Igenex test results.
I read an article about PANDAS. If step not treated, it may carry into adulthood. The step infection passes the blood brain barrier and causes OCD, and terrets syndrome. Google it.
Serology means detection of antibodies to an infectious agent. IgM class antibodies are the first to be produced in response to an infection followed by IgG weeks later as the long term, protective antibodies. These are detected by two methods, ELISA (enzyme linked immunosorbent assay) which is the initial/screening test. If positive, then results are generally confirmed by a Western blot, which is really just an ELISA in a different format that identifies the antibodies to the varied proteins of an infectious agent. Positive IgM means a recent infection; IgG an older and perhaps former/resolved infection. These results must be evaluated in light of your other clinical symptoms and exposure history including the bullseye rash, erythema migrans, in the case of Lyme disease.

Laboratories, like IGeneX, can make their own tests, or modify the procedure (and interpretation) of FDA-approved tests, and their claims are not always evaluated against rigorous scientific review. LLMDs are also not always in it for the right reasons either and have perpetuated a lot of myths and repeated visits and sometimes dangerous antibiotics. Blaming many symptoms on one organism doesn't scientific sense and allows unscrupulous entities to create unproven tests/therapies that reward them with $$$.
Tube- You must work for the CDC or are part of IDSA. You are very misinformed when it comes to Lyme. A positive IgM does not mean a recent infection when it comes to Lyme but rather an active infection. I have many positive IgM bands but was bit years ago and the same goes for many on this forum. Most of us have had symptoms for years and have more positive IgM bands than IgG.

IGeneX is superior to other labs for several reasons. They use two Lyme strains as controls instead of one which helps lessen false negatives. They also use a stronger acid gel for better separation of bands and don't throw out bands 31 and 34 like other labs do because of a vaccine that almost nobody has had. ILADS recognizes them as being the best lab for the WB but you obviously come from the other camp that doesn't recognize Chronic Lyme as a disease.
Tube you are mistaken in many of your points. You are propagating false or at minimum outdated information.

Igenex testing has been through rigorous evaluation and verification. If memory serves FDA doesnt require the existing test meet certain standards (dont get me started on the corrupted FDA, separate issue). Igenex tests for more borellia specific bands than any other labs currently. This has been a long reported falsehood about igenex testing, you are just a robot repeating lies. Most of us have had to use our precious limited energies to chase this falsehood to reassure ourselves and find the truth.

You are likely correct about IgM and IgG in some cases EXCEPT when it comes to lyme you IgM IgG statement is Inn correct.

As far as llmd's being less than trustworthy my ten year experience trying to get conventional doctors to correctly diagnose me, which they did not, I spent thousands on these non llmd doctors, lost my 20 year career trying to get help, lost my health the longer I went undiagnosed, misdiagnosed, lost relationships. They had absolutely no sense of urgency, at times were abusive and dismissive or condescending. Ran a boatload of tests and half the time coud not interpret the results. I was told repeatedly what I had could not be lyme since my multiple ELISA tests were negative. As of this year they were all wrong. It is a travesty bordering on criminal what conventional doctors are getting away with, I would not trust any of them to apply a bandaid.

Your comments sound like you just graduated medical school and are parroting what you heard or cut and pasted from wikipedka. Your comments reflect someone who has drank the coventional medical coolaid but has not used to research and verify the things you are trying to convey as truth.

If this seems harsh you just have no clue what people with lyme and coinfections and bewildered by what is happening to them and desperate for answers. I would guess 90% of conventional doctors have no clue how to dx lyme, dont realize the failure rate of 'accepted' lyme tests and dont understand jow to treat it.

go verify your statements then come back and appologize to this forum and the people you might have mislead with your oudated misinformation.
Started anaplasma and mycoplasma treatment 03/2014. Tens years sick. Hoping to see consistent improvement this year.
Tube, stop trolling here. It's very disrespectful to those of us who are suffering from this terrible disease. Go away!


Mangaka, I was tested a few months ago. Totally negative. I was just like you. confused as to what I should do. I almost did not get tested a second time. Then, I decided I had to go for it. I used IgeneX. $260 test: CDC positive.

The lab is much more advanced than the regular labs. I would highly recommend it. I wish I could have done this years ago. Good Luck!
CDC positive for Lyme. Starting my healing journey.
Hello again,
Thanks for all your replies. Let everyone be respectful of each other.
I've just found out that the test I got a while ago was, indeed, the ELISA test. Don't worry-- I'm going to get Western Blot testing done ASAP!
:-)
Mangaka - and make sure you get the WB through Igenex.
Symptoms started Sept, 2013 (maybe sooner?)...still undiagnosed. Started Buhner's protocol May 15, 2014
Waiting for Igenex test results.
No offense to any in here!!! I have a chronic auto-immune illness and have been a laboratory scientist for 30 years. I focus on proven (by properly designed studies) effective clinical diagnostic tests. No entity or agency is perfect, and intent is hard to prove. I don't work for CDC and I have not copied/pasted from Wikipedia. IGeneX is not the worst, they are trying to be helpful, but who has rigorously evaluated all IGeneX procedures? What happened to their LUAT test? Why aren't they CAP accredited? Labs certified by federal CLIA offer tests that are clinically unproven because CLIA doesn't have the resources to evaluate clinical validity (sensitivity/specificity). I feel for everyone with pain and some disease/disorder, but I am reviled even more by those who benefit financially from preying on you, esp if repeatedly gaining from unproven test/treatments incl those that are harmful. I do not imply your suffering is baseless, just that not every wide-ranging symptom can be blamed on Bb. I agree this is a serious issue and debate, but keep you eye on the science, proof, and don't forget to follow the money and connections to bad players. Never forget that health care providers and laboratories are businesses.

Is there proven by science helpful info here? http://goodbyelyme.com/ Do they sell stuff?

Good health and peace to all.
Tube, appreciate your additional perspective. Yesterday was a bad day and colored my response to your comments. Although I do not agree with all your comments I need to be more gracious to those who dont share my perspective just to insure I dont develop blinders as a result of my experience.

I agree we need to draw conclusions based on good science and testing. Sadly experience has procen to me that our testing and science has been corupted ovef time such that I use to trust drs, tests, studies n6t have too many of them turned out to be incorrect. I only have my experience and the experiences of others going through similar troubles to help give me direction in a medical environment that abandons patients to their own devices if the situation presented is not easily understood or resolved with pharmacology.

I appologize for my inappropriate comments, I just want eveyone to be able to get answers to help them on their health journey. Some comments just feel misleading at times.
Started anaplasma and mycoplasma treatment 03/2014. Tens years sick. Hoping to see consistent improvement this year.
For perspective on the accuracy and effectiveness of the IgG and IgM - my son had both, twice, and twice was negative. However, the CDC has specific reporting standards for Lyme disease. If a person gets the erythema migrans (expanding bullseye rash) in an area known to have Lyme disease carrying ticks then THAT IS A CONFIRMED CASE. If a person gets the rash in an area not known to have Bb infected ticks it is a PRESUMED case. The rash is diagnostic, even in cases of negative serology! (Yes, by area I mean county or..., not armpit or...!)
 
However, even with that information and government sourced documents showing confirmed Bb infected ticks in the area, seven different doctors refused to diagnose Lyme disease. (We don't have it out here...) (Of course not - as long as no one diagnoses it, we will continue not to have it.)
 
Is it any wonder that we go to doctors who at least believe that, if it is in our heads, treatment will kill it and get it out? There is a big potential for predators in the treatment world and we all have to try to make the right choices, with careful study, but also with gut feelings about how much we can trust the people we speak with.
 
I have had conventional doctors and other medical personel make life threatening mistakes in my treatments, and those of my family, in several situations, not linked to Lyme or any other controversy. There are plenty of lousy doctors in the world. And, even very open minded, sympathetic medical personnel out here were quite behind in their knowledge of Lyme. That's regarding the uncontroversial information - stuff that both major Lyme perspectives agree on!
 
There are drs who just don't know much, but don't realize how inadequate their info is. I had one dr say he felt the name LLMD was offensive because it implied other mds were not Lyme literate. Well, uh, yeah!
 
As for the weird range of symptoms, it does make it harder to convince people it's real. But, I saw antibiotic treatment work and resolve a series of very odd symptoms when other things had not, and many people report good results with many different treatments. Try this one on - antibiotics as a treatment for allergies. Hmm. How about for low body temp?
 
I asked a doc about the range of symptoms and he began offering diagnoses - this for that, this for the other, that for the next one - until I asked him how many different diagnoses would he need to cover all the symptoms when Lyme covered it all? I had already seen a number of other people's lists or I wouldn't have connected it all, but almost everything clearing up as a cluster implies it was all tied together. We do still fight some of the first symptoms, still lingering for lesser flare ups, and temporarily ending treatment has caused recurrence of some symptoms previously bannished.
 
This is not fun stuff. We are here to help each other navigate the murky waters. If a person needs more knowledge (technical or experiences) about any aspect of recovering/ surviving we try to help each other get what we need. Lab expertise could be an asset for us all. Read around and look for places to kindly supportively help.
 Keep in mind also that the spirochete Syphilis causes a wide range of nasty symptoms. (Lunacy and blindness...) Lots of ailments cause many seemingly unrelated symptoms.
 If something can get into the brain/cns there's a lot that can be affected.
 
Also, about alternate therapies - think about fever - fever can be treated by aspirin, Tylenol, or other NSAIDS, it can be brought down by submersion in cold water, it can be fought with antibiotics, it can be reduced by drinking water. It really depends on what is causing the body's temp spike. One antibiotic will kill one bug, another will kill another. Depending on what is being modified by a treatment the method of killing Lyme may vary, but it can still work!
 
Is there danger in not having perfect studies? Absolutely. There are treatments for many things hitting the market after formal testing and approval that are lethal. More testing, more studies, more answers, I think that is some of what we all want.
 
That, and a good night. Good night.