Conundrum on PSA

Ok, it has been two years since my robotic surgery. The first PSA was <0.1 and then it has been 0.1 for the following two years, until three weeks ago it was 0.2. So I started my salvage radiotherapy. Right before I started the radiotherapy I got an ultra-sensitive PSA and go the results today, it is 0.12, which is below the threshold of 0.2 for radiotherapy. Both were Quest Labs tests. My oncology urologist said I should continue the radiotherapy.

I am leaning towards continuing based on positive surgical margins.

Any thoughts out there?
Age 60, mpMRI 8/18/13 negative
biopsy 9/5/13, PSA 6.2, 13 core of which 6 are postive
pT2pNO
left laterial base 10% G6(3+3)
left laterial apex 10% G6(3+3)
right base 15% G7(3+4)
right laterial base 15% G6(3+3)
right laterial mid 60% G6(3+3)
right lateral apex 20% G6(3+3)
daVinci 11/11/13
path T2c N0 Stage IIB
12/13 <.01, 4/14 0.1, 8/14 0.1, 12/14 0.1, 3/15 0.1, 7/15 0.1, 10/14 0.2
Many think the new starting point should be .03. .12 would certainly be past that threshold.
PSA looks to be increasing slowly which is a great sign . Some say the sooner the better for adjuvant SRT, but there is no consensus.
Bob
DOB January 1944 (now age 71)
8/12 PSA 2.7
5/13 PSA 6.6
7/13 Bx 4+5=9, 2 of 6 cores, 10%, 40%
9/13 ORRP, Gl9, pt3b, SVI+,margin+, EPE, Nodes clear
11/13 to 5/14 PSA .1,.2,.3
6&7/14 IMRT 68.2 gy. to Prostate bed, ADT 6 mos. Lupron
9/14 to 8/15 PSA <.1,<.1,.1,.3,.7,1.2
9/15 to 10/16 ADT3, metformin
9/15 to 12/15 IMRT/D.A.R.T. 75 gy to pelvic nodes, 50 fracti
Newer research says, .03 for SRT, so I'm with your docs - get it done.

Andrew
I'll be in the shop.
Age 55, 52 at DX
PSA 4.2 10/11, 1.9 6/12, 1.2 12/12, 1.0 5/13, .6 11/13, .7 5/14, .5 10/14, .5 4/15, .3 10/15
G 3+4
Stage T1C
2 out of 14 cores positive
Treatment IGRT - 2/2012
My latest blog post
It sounds like you have become a slave to a number.. But with positive margins and the fact that you have begun treatment, things could get confusing if you stopped now...
Age now 73 . Diagnosed G-9 6/2010
RALP Sept 3 2010, pos margin, one pos vesicle nodes neg. Post Op PSA 0.9 SRT, HT. 2-15-'11 PSA <0.1 10/'11, <0.1 2/12, <0.1, 4/12 <0.1, 9/12, 0.8 3/13, 0.5 6/13, 1.1, back on HT
Eligard + Casodex PSA 0.04 10/2013 PSA 0.32 on 1/14.On 6/14 PSA 0.4, "T" 5. On 10/14 PSA 0.6, "T"-11 1/2015, PSA 0.1, 4/15 0.4, 9/15 1.4
i THINK that by considering the positive margins in your decision making process, you are proving yourself to be very wise.
Dx Age 64 Nov 2014, 4.3
BX 3 of 12 cores positive original pathologyG6, G6, G8 (3+5)
downgraded to 3+3=6 by Dr Epstein, JH
RALP with Dr Ash Tewari Jan 6, 2015
Post surgical pathology – G7 (3+4), ECE, Margins, LN, SV all negative
PSA @ 6 weeks 2/15, .<02, 4/15 <.02 7/15 <.02, 10/15 0.00 (new lab)
My Story: tinyurl.com/oo9x4aq
Yes, i am leaning to continue the radiotherapy. I will meet this Monday with the radiation oncology doctor to answer my concerns.

My concerns even though they are low includes future problems such as potential incontinence, ED, rectal problems, future secondary cancers caused by radiotherapy, and possible problems of abdominal surgery or hip replacement years from now if need.
Age 60, mpMRI 8/18/13 negative
biopsy 9/5/13, PSA 6.2, 13 core of which 6 are postive
pT2pNO
left laterial base 10% G6(3+3)
left laterial apex 10% G6(3+3)
right base 15% G7(3+4)
right laterial base 15% G6(3+3)
right laterial mid 60% G6(3+3)
right lateral apex 20% G6(3+3)
daVinci 11/11/13
path T2c N0 Stage IIB
12/13 <.01, 4/14 0.1, 8/14 0.1, 12/14 0.1, 3/15 0.1, 7/15 0.1, 10/14 0.2
I know it is a difficult decision to make. I pulled the trigger at .03 and I did not have postive margins. Hopefully if you go forward, it will be a faint memory in a few months with ver y few side effects. Take care and keep us posted.
Age 48 at diagnosis (55 now)
PSA increased from 2.6 to 3.5 in one year
biopsy March 2008 - cancer present 6 out of 12 cores; gleason 7
Robotic Surgery May 9, 2008 - Houston, TX (Methodist Hospital)
Pathology report -gleason 8, clear margins
PSA 2008 - 2013 <.04; 2013<.01; 2014 .02; 2015 .03
SRT 06/30/15 - 08/21/15 - 39 sessions; PSA 10/6/15 .01
With all the specifics in your case,even a positive margin of a cancer that is known to rarely survive out side the womb, a definite no on the rt. You sense this in your heart. you know my journey...have some faith. Do you honestly think it will make a difference in your mortality if you waited even to double digits. Come on listen to the force Luke
LA, I had a similar issue. We used .1 as the trigger and when I hit that I planned SRT. I got another PSA test on the Friday before our scheduled live start on Monday and that number was .07, which was below our self imposed target. Texted the urologist and the RO and decided to stay the course for a couple of reasons. The first being the recent data on .03 as the new target and after that I just felt that the timing was right and I was mapped and ready to go and PSA was trending up and to the right even though these are small numbers. Oh, I had a microscopic, <1 mm, positive lymph node that significantly increases the risk of bad things.

Best of luck with your decision and look forward to seeing future updates.

Luther
Dx, June 2013, 59 yo, now 61, G4+3, psa 7.01 no symptoms just PSA rise
RP Aug 2013, path G3+4, <1mm focus on 1 lymph node
4 wks .11 6wks .05, 2 mo .04, 3 mo .04, 4 mo .03, 5 mo .05, 6 mo .06, 7 mo .07, 8 mo .06, 10 mo .06, 11 mo .05, 1 year .06, 14 mo .06, 16 mo .08, 18 mo .08, 19 mo .1
4/24 pre SRT .07
SRT, 39@1.8 started 4/27, 5/22 @21/39 psa .05, 39/39 psa .03
Since I had positive margins and SV involvement I went in for adjuvant radiation 3 months after surgery. The side effects aren't that bad, especially compared to a recurrence.
65 yo, 2012 PSA 11, "bump" with DRE, biopsy 11/12 12/12 cores with acinar adenocarcinoma, Da Vinci RP 12/27/2012. 35 gram tumor, 2 EC ext., 1 sem. ves. + marg T3b N0 M0, G7(4+3). 2 week post-RP PSA 0.2, started Firmagon ADT, catheter removed. Pads for 3 months, then done. 3 months post-op EBRT prostate bed and interior pelvic lymph nodes ~ 80 Gy/40 ses. Last Eligard 10/14, therapy ended 4/30/2015
My oncology urologist (OU)called me this morning on the results of the MRI that I had to repeat this past Monday. Previous MRI had one sequence that was cut off before it got the prostate. What's a little extra gadolinium in my system without being charged for it! My OU reiterated that I SHOULD continue with the radiotherapy.

My pathology states positive margins on left and right apex is Gleason pattern 3 &4, and extensive surgical margin on left lateral lobe and is estimated at no more than 5 square millimeters total.

I have a meeting Monday with the RO and I want to address the concerns in the prior post. But based on my OU and pathology report I am still leaning towards radiotherapy.
Age 60, mpMRI 8/18/13 negative
biopsy 9/5/13, PSA 6.2, 13 core of which 6 are postive
pT2pNO
left laterial base 10% G6(3+3)
left laterial apex 10% G6(3+3)
right base 15% G7(3+4)
right laterial base 15% G6(3+3)
right laterial mid 60% G6(3+3)
right lateral apex 20% G6(3+3)
daVinci 11/11/13
path T2c N0 Stage IIB
12/13 <.01, 4/14 0.1, 8/14 0.1, 12/14 0.1, 3/15 0.1, 7/15 0.1, 10/14 0.2

Post Edited (lapilot) : 11/6/2015 4:20:36 PM (GMT-7)

Hey Nick
To me it sounds like you are taking the prudent course of action. Zap it for a best chance of a cure.

Best of luck

Pat
Age 50,
PSA 14.7 06/24/2013
PSA 14.6 08/20/2013

Biopsy 10/1/2013 - 2 out of 12 cores positive
Gleason 3+3

RALP on 11/11/2013.
Catheter out on 11/18/2013

Still a little leaky 01/01/2015

PSA <0.1 12/29/2014
PSA <0.1 07/07/2014
PSA <0.1 01/13/2014


Current very happy member of the 0 Club

(Not a Medical Professional)