I am confused about radiation being a cure for PCa. I have heard that external beam radiation for T2B to prostate a node followed by 1 year Lupron is a cure.
Then I was told by a VA doctor the it was not and as a matter of fact there is not proven data that radiation plus 1 year Lupro has any longer survivial rate that Lupron only.
What do you think?
Prostate cases are complex and cannot be fully described by "T2B," for example. The treatment you described may result in a cure for some men, and may not result in a cure for others. There is no 100% guarnatee...just like there is no 100% guarantee for anything else.
My oncologist tells me that I am 'cured'. I ain't about to argue with him.
Diagnosed in October, 08. One sample of needle biopsy showed Gl 6. Did watchful waiting for 18 months. PSA went fro 4.3 to 6.1. Surgery scared the heck out of me. Had a mapping biopsy where 60 samples are taken. 15 were GL6, 1 was GL7. Had the brachytherapy on Oct. 4, 2010
First PSA post brachy on Jan. 6: 0.24
July 7, 2011: PSA: 0.20
Jan 5, 2012: PSA: 0.25
July 7, 2012: PSA: 0.2
Diagnosed in October, 08. One sample of needle biopsy showed Gl 6. Did watchful waiting for 18 months. PSA went fro 4.3 to 6.1. Surgery scared the heck out of me. Had a mapping biopsy where 60 samples are taken. 15 were GL6, 1 was GL7. Had the brachytherapy on Oct. 4, 2010
First PSA post brachy on Jan. 6: 0.24
July 7, 2011: PSA: 0.20
Jan 5, 2012: PSA: 0.25
July 7, 2012: PSA: 0.2
What do you think?
without knowing anything about your case I think there's a greater possibilty of a cure with radiation plus lupron and almost no chance for a cure with lupron only.
my treatment was radiation (two types) + lupron.
ed
age: 57
12/09 -- PSA 6.8
G7 -- 3+4
HT, BT and IGRT
9/4/12 -- 2-year post treatment PSA 0.2
(PSAs .2, .3, .2, .3, .2)
Friendly fire 2 (deros ). Radiation + lupron is best to prevent recurrence--no guarantees. You had + lymph nodes so you should be t3 like me. Dr had me read nccn guidelines-60% 5 years. Good luck my friend. Hope you get your radiation! Bill
Friendly fire 2 (deros ). Radiation + lupron is best to prevent recurrence--no guarantees. You had + lymph nodes so you should be t3 like me. Dr had me read nccn guidelines-60% 5 years. Good luck my friend. Hope you get your radiation! Bill
Friendly Fire one, this is friendly fire 2 .Over. I am a t2bn. That is 1/2 the prostate involved with a lymph node. That is what the paper work said. I do not know anything with a t3.
They counting my scapula bone a false postive do to ingury. It may not be but next week back to MDAndersonn to repeat bone scan and ABD.ct.. The VA Ratiation oncologist was bad he could not decide what to do. Proving my point that the big CCC centers are the place to go. I packing bags for 2 months of rays but could be disappointed. They want PSA at 0.5 and check early the month was 1.6 and no spread. Looking forward to getting Zapped as you know.
5 years huh,ok thanks
They counting my scapula bone a false postive do to ingury. It may not be but next week back to MDAndersonn to repeat bone scan and ABD.ct.. The VA Ratiation oncologist was bad he could not decide what to do. Proving my point that the big CCC centers are the place to go. I packing bags for 2 months of rays but could be disappointed. They want PSA at 0.5 and check early the month was 1.6 and no spread. Looking forward to getting Zapped as you know.
5 years huh,ok thanks
Deros--that 5 years was me-with proton radiation & lupron you should be good for 10 or 15 years-maybe forever. 1968 was a rough year..friendly fire 1--bill
I was under the impression you had to be in remission for at least 5 years to be considered cured....at least thats what my insurance company told me. Ive read that on other sites as well.
Age:51 Diagnosed: April 2011, Age 50
Original PSA Level 94 ......Gleason: 9
Biopsy results: 10 of 12 tested positive for cancer
Bone scan....negative, CT scans...negative
Treatment: IMRT.... 2 Aug, 2011
Lupron depot 30MG....2 years (started 13 July)
PSA down to .16 with 9 months of Lupron so far
Finished 45 Treatments of IMRT...4 Oct, 2011
HT switched to Eligard
Age:51 Diagnosed: April 2011, Age 50
Original PSA Level 94 ......Gleason: 9
Biopsy results: 10 of 12 tested positive for cancer
Bone scan....negative, CT scans...negative
Treatment: IMRT.... 2 Aug, 2011
Lupron depot 30MG....2 years (started 13 July)
PSA down to .16 with 9 months of Lupron so far
Finished 45 Treatments of IMRT...4 Oct, 2011
HT switched to Eligard
Correct Casper.
Friendly fire 1, 1968-69 were rough years but 2011-12 ain't been real good either. Both start with a C.. Charlie and Cancer. lol
Deros:
What do you think?
From my pursuits so far, it seems like the 'statistically significant' published results can't quite capture all of the variables in individual cases. I've heard of enough success with Radiation and ADT combined that it makes sense. Shrink the tumors, cut off the 'food' supply, radiate them, then continue to starve what's left.
Good luck ... MD Anderson is fantastic, have heard great results from friends of friends there.
For lymph node radiation, one of the best is Dr Roach out of UC-SF. That's his area of research and publications. That's where i'm headed next month after my local top rated CCC told me they couldn't do anything with the lymph nodes behind my abdomen. ... If you need another take on it, i'd encourage that.
Ray
2006 PSA 1.1
6/9/12 PSA 36.3
6/18/12 PSA 31.2
Age at Dx 49
7/2/12 DRE One lobe, large
7/2/12 biopsy G9 12 of 12 plus 2 on SV
7/9/12 Bone scan 0 CT scan 6 nodes T3cN3M0
7/13/12 Lymph node biopsy confirms, started Casodex
7/24/12 PSA 21.3 (down is good) Started Lupron
8/14/12 PSA 0.4 Started Zytiga
What do you think?
From my pursuits so far, it seems like the 'statistically significant' published results can't quite capture all of the variables in individual cases. I've heard of enough success with Radiation and ADT combined that it makes sense. Shrink the tumors, cut off the 'food' supply, radiate them, then continue to starve what's left.
Good luck ... MD Anderson is fantastic, have heard great results from friends of friends there.
For lymph node radiation, one of the best is Dr Roach out of UC-SF. That's his area of research and publications. That's where i'm headed next month after my local top rated CCC told me they couldn't do anything with the lymph nodes behind my abdomen. ... If you need another take on it, i'd encourage that.
Ray
2006 PSA 1.1
6/9/12 PSA 36.3
6/18/12 PSA 31.2
Age at Dx 49
7/2/12 DRE One lobe, large
7/2/12 biopsy G9 12 of 12 plus 2 on SV
7/9/12 Bone scan 0 CT scan 6 nodes T3cN3M0
7/13/12 Lymph node biopsy confirms, started Casodex
7/24/12 PSA 21.3 (down is good) Started Lupron
8/14/12 PSA 0.4 Started Zytiga
My surgeon told me he would consider me cured with 5years of recurrence free. My urologist said 20 years. I don't know and do not think they do either . If they did they would know enough about the disease,…..to cure it!. To me the main point is, a quote, little known to be by A Lincoln, attributed to many.
" It is not how you die, it is how you live " All these simple truths never seem enough to us, be cause in the words of a Union leader when asked what he wants, said " More". To all of us who are saddled with the anxiety of this disease and all the troubles of Life. and again it is a trite and old concept. LIVE each day, sufficient unto the day is the evil thereof. It aint easy, but as the surfer girl who lost her arm from a shark in Kauai said as she started back in the water. I''m not asking for easy, I'm asking for possible.
Diagnosed 8/14/09 psa 8.1 66,now 69
2cores 70%, rest 6-7 < 5%
gleason 3+ 3, up to 3+4 @ the dub
RPP U of Wash,
pathology 4+3, tertiary5, 2 foci
extensive pni, prostate confined,27 nodes removed -, svi - margins -
99%continent@ cath removal. 1% incont@gaspass,sneeze,cough ED penatration at 2 years with cialis/viaga. < .1 at 33 mos " Hypocrisy is vices homage to virtue "
" It is not how you die, it is how you live " All these simple truths never seem enough to us, be cause in the words of a Union leader when asked what he wants, said " More". To all of us who are saddled with the anxiety of this disease and all the troubles of Life. and again it is a trite and old concept. LIVE each day, sufficient unto the day is the evil thereof. It aint easy, but as the surfer girl who lost her arm from a shark in Kauai said as she started back in the water. I''m not asking for easy, I'm asking for possible.
Diagnosed 8/14/09 psa 8.1 66,now 69
2cores 70%, rest 6-7 < 5%
gleason 3+ 3, up to 3+4 @ the dub
RPP U of Wash,
pathology 4+3, tertiary5, 2 foci
extensive pni, prostate confined,27 nodes removed -, svi - margins -
99%continent@ cath removal. 1% incont@gaspass,sneeze,cough ED penatration at 2 years with cialis/viaga. < .1 at 33 mos " Hypocrisy is vices homage to virtue "
Since docs define 'cure' all over the place it is as controversial as psa numbers and most all PCa non-definitives or exceptions-anomolies. Dr. Barken has commented on recurrance (actually likely micro mets that lingered), can occassionally show up in 10-12-15 yr. patients whom looked 'cured' prior. So, the uro-doc whom says 20 yrs., sounds like one of the better uro-docs I have ever heard make claims, alot of them make sales claims 3-5 years and your are cured....it does sound great, just verify anything and question everything in PCa about all the time and you will do just fine. (lol) You may be cured early on, just monitor your psa and and possible other parameters and possible symptoms.
Yet another excellent discussion thread.....
Although I dare use the word "cure", my Brachy team did use the word in describing my treatment. They also used in when convincing me to stay on my HT for at least 12 months.
Age 52, Stage T2c, Gleason grade 8-10
PSA level of 10.6 no symptoms whatsoever.
Ct scan and Bone scan negative
my diagnosis is considered a high risk disease and my treatment EBR + Brachy Seed Implants + HT
50mg of Bicalutamide tablets per day first 30 days
22.5 mg Lupron for 12 months
PSA value: 5.5 May 2011, 0.03 Nov 2011, undectable Feb 2012
T levels 1.66 Nov 2011, 1.?? Feb 2012.
Age 52, Stage T2c, Gleason grade 8-10
PSA level of 10.6 no symptoms whatsoever.
Ct scan and Bone scan negative
my diagnosis is considered a high risk disease and my treatment EBR + Brachy Seed Implants + HT
50mg of Bicalutamide tablets per day first 30 days
22.5 mg Lupron for 12 months
PSA value: 5.5 May 2011, 0.03 Nov 2011, undectable Feb 2012
T levels 1.66 Nov 2011, 1.?? Feb 2012.
I have asked my URO about being cured and he hesitates to use that work until his patients have a minimum of 5 years of undetectable PSA and after 10 years he told me I could consider myself cured. That is why I will be having 6 month PSA testing until year 5 and then annually the rest of my life. We have seen in this forum in the last month or two several guys who had surgery 3 or more years ago with a BCR, which scares to heck out of me. When people ask me if I am cured I tell them I am in remission and think I have a very good possibility of being cured.
Terry
AGE 61 Dx with fam hist of PC
PSA
1.5 5/09
2.5 6/10
3.5 12/10 ref URO
5.25 3/11 DRE Neg
BX 4/13/11 2 of 12 cores diag both sides 15% & 20% GS7(3+4)
RALP nerve-sparing 6/8/11 path G7 pT2C, Marg-Lymph-Sem-Vas-PNI- organ confined 60% tumor involved 69grms 4.3X4X3 cm
100% dry 7/3/11
post PSA
9/11 <0.07
12/11 <0.04
3/12 <0.01
6/11/12 <0.01
TRIMIX injections for 100% ED
AGE 61 Dx with fam hist of PC
PSA
1.5 5/09
2.5 6/10
3.5 12/10 ref URO
5.25 3/11 DRE Neg
BX 4/13/11 2 of 12 cores diag both sides 15% & 20% GS7(3+4)
RALP nerve-sparing 6/8/11 path G7 pT2C, Marg-Lymph-Sem-Vas-PNI- organ confined 60% tumor involved 69grms 4.3X4X3 cm
100% dry 7/3/11
post PSA
9/11 <0.07
12/11 <0.04
3/12 <0.01
6/11/12 <0.01
TRIMIX injections for 100% ED