What are they supposed to do? And so they hatch & theoretically live in your intestines? Now if you see no changes at all, good or bad, & stop taking these eggs, do the worms or whatever die off, or do they just stay alive in there? How do you get rid of them if you want to? And these are human worm eggs as opposed to those pig eggs everyone's talking about? Huh.... right now I feel like I'm 100 years old, cause what's going thru my head is "Oh my word, the things people do!".. haha! well good luck, I guess they can't hurt. Can they?diagnosed with UC '02
Good luck with it. It will be interesting to know how things progress for you with this treatment.Rio, 33 year old male. Diagnosed with UC in 2006 100 mg Azathioprine (stopped), 4800 mg Asacol VSL#3 x 3 times a day, Metamucil wafers Vitamin E enema or Asacol enema occasionally Spinach & sunflower seed diet / Juicing spinach and carrots
Eva Lou said... What are they supposed to do? And so they hatch & theoretically live in your intestines? Now if you see no changes at all, good or bad, & stop taking these eggs, do the worms or whatever die off, or do they just stay alive in there? How do you get rid of them if you want to? And these are human worm eggs as opposed to those pig eggs everyone's talking about? Huh.... right now I feel like I'm 100 years old, cause what's going thru my head is "Oh my word, the things people do!".. haha! well good luck, I guess they can't hurt. Can they?
I'm still learning, so I some of the information may change or be inaccurate.
Yes, they develop and live in the large intestine. The whipworms will modulate the immune system to escape detection and destruction. Apparently they work on the interaction between Th-1 and Th-2 receptors.
The idea is that humans and their parasites have co-evolved for millions of year and need each other, and there is a correlation between increased sanitation and increase auto-immune disorders, IBD included.
They live for a couple of years. Some sources say about two years and some say up to five years. If I want to get rid of them I can take a pill to kill them off. The CDC does not recommend treating low-grade infections like the one I am trying to cultivate.
I guess these are cousins to the pig whip worm. The pig whip worm cannot live forever in the human gut, so people who use that method have to continually re-ingest the eggs. These parasites have evolved to live in the human gut.
I'm told there may be an initial reaction as my body gets used to the whip worms, but it should be mild and transient fever, nausea, etc -- nothing I'm not used to at this point. If it works -- and there's reason to believe it will work -- remission is the goal.
I don't think you need to feel 100 years old. Even six months ago, if you had told me I'd be doing this, I'd have thought you were crazy.
very interesting! I hope it does help- imagine the look on your GI's face! Definitely keep us posted. PS- is this like a last resort for you? I forget the meds you're on, and have been on, but I know you've been posting awhile. Will you consider surgery if the worms don't help? So have you tried the typical biologic route, & immune suppressants?
diagnosed with UC '02
Eva Lou said... very interesting! I hope it does help- imagine the look on your GI's face! Definitely keep us posted. PS- is this like a last resort for you? I forget the meds you're on, and have been on, but I know you've been posting awhile. Will you consider surgery if the worms don't help? So have you tried the typical biologic route, & immune suppressants?
I don't know if I'd call it the last resort. I've been in a flare for over two years now, and switched from Asacol to sulphasalzine about a year ago. Big improvement overall. This fall/ winter, the flare became awful and I bowed to pressure and took Imuran. Liver panel went wonky and my GP got nervous. GI was less concerned. I stopped the Imuran. Life was unbearable and I wanted surgery at that point.
The surgeon my GI recommended was a bit hesitant to perform surgery because I wasn't hospitalized at that point -- a real masochist -- and he and the GI conferred and the GI absolutely refused to recommend surgery unless I tried Remicade. Remicade is a complete nonstarter for me. It's not going to happen.
I had a window for May surgery, and back and forth between the two docs messed up my timeline. (Nevermind that I had started the surgery process in January. . . .) The flare has subsided on its own, but I still need to get through the year.
I dumped the GI and my new GI is more surgery friendly, but after spending four or so months negotiating with the previous two jokers, I'm not sure I even have the energy to go through the rigamarole. Enter whipworms.
If the whipworms don't work, I'll probably go back to smoking. I've really had enough of doctors, am no healthier because of them, and I'm ready to walk off the reservation (obviously). I was much healthier when I smoked three or four cigarettes a day and kept the uc under control.
I got them from Autoimmune Therapies. No, they're not cheap, but the upfront costs are mitigated by the length of the treatment.
That is awesome seconder. I really wish the FDA wouldn't ban them anymore. Where did you get them from?Asacol-12 a day 1 Culturelle 1 Canasa 5g Fish oil supplements 1 Vitamin 1 Haldi Drink Gluten-free and lactose-free diet
Good luck seconder! I expect to be joining you in this experiment within a few days- we can compare notes! I am already a veteran of pig whipworms (helped somewhat), hookworms (didn't help and I killed them after 5 months), and fecal infusions (single infusions twice flared me up so I never got around to trying it for longer- it may just be that my girlfriend's stool was not the right mix of bacteria- but kudos that I had such a willing volunteer lol) so this is nothing new to me. For me it is almost certainly this or surgery. It could be 5 months before we see any benefit at all, assuming we get one, and for me that is going to be a very long wait right now unless something else helps. The biologics have done nothing much for me- they worked for a bit but don't even last between doses. I am planning to try vitamn E enemas and phosphotydilcholine (sp., PC) enemas while I wait.Pancolitis >20 years, allergic to all 5ASAs
(To pharma: enough already with the umpteen variants of Asacol!)
Tried everything under the sun (natural and alternative)
Some partial success with TSO but was too expensive to keep up
Remicade Humira, lots of probiotics, entocort, taperingincreasing pred again,
Good luck, but I don't believe that IBD is caused by too much sanitation. (Had relatives who died of cholera in Hungary in 19th century + one who survived typhoid fever-- all caused by lack of sanitation in the water supply.) I do agree that the existing IBD meds are woefully inadequate, if not harmful over time. / Old Hat (30 yrs with left-sided UC ... [etc.])
I think we have a lot of bugaboos we ingest....consider how many people never wash their hands or that food we eat is probably not cleaned properly anyway...what about the elevator button or on fingers when they're licked to turn pages?
seconder....I was under the impression that the worms were to stay in the gut for a certain amount of time and then killed off....is that true or it just depends on how you're feeling and if you go into remission?
q
*Heather* Status: maintenance Asacol 6 daily + Salofalk enemas every 3rd night
~diagnosed January 1989 UC (proctosigmoiditis)
~UC meds: Asacol (3 @ 2x daily); Salofalk enemas nightly for flares & taper to maintenance
Old Hat- the theory behind certain helminths (parasitic worms) and other parasites playing a role in immune modulation is no longer controversial (the mountain of literature available through a simple pubmed search is growing exponentially), even if their value as IBD therapy still is debated. And the theory goes far beyond the idea of sanitation being bad. In any case, the hygiene hypothesis does not throw germ theory out the window- clearly pathogens can and do result in many bad things. Hygiene theory merely updates germ theory with a more nuanced view- just as we now know that antibiotics can wipe out health-promoting probiotic bacteria that keep our guts functioning well and allow the overgrowth of pathogens, we now know that our guts have similarly evolved side by side with many other parasites such as intestinal worms and consequently learned to have symbiotic relations with them as well. See for example this recent analysis of the relationship between ancestral parasite exposure and auto-immune-related genes:
Drug companies are aggressively seeking to derive compounds produced by such worms in order to patent new drugs. However, there are hundreds, possibly even thousands of immune-modulating compounds excreted by the worms to allow them to survive in the gut without its mounting a destructive immune response, and my sense is that isolating one or two compounds will either be less effective and/or have unintended consequences / side effects (as seems the case with every IBD drug out there to date) compared with the worm itself.
I don't think worms are the magic bullet for auto-immunity but I do think they or more likely, their derived compounds (mainly since worms can't be patented) will gradually become key therapies a few decades from now.
Pancolitis >20 years, allergic to all 5ASAs
(To pharma: enough already with the umpteen variants of Asacol!)
Tried everything under the sun (natural and alternative)
Some partial success with TSO but was too expensive to keep up
Remicade Humira, lots of probiotics, entocort, taperingincreasing pred again,
maybe surgery this year soon
Post Edited (Probiotic) : 6/24/2009 7:15:29 AM (GMT-6)
Sorry for the miscommunication, Old Hat. I definitely didn't mean to imply that cholera isn't dangerous or that separating wastewater from supply water isn't a good idea. Part of the evidence in favor of intestinal parasites shows a concommitant rise of autoimmune disease and improved sanitation. Another bit of evidence in favor of them is that areas where flush toilets are less common and where intestinal parasites are more common, diseases like uc are unknown.
I don't have children or asthma, but I notice magazine articles and snippets on the news that discuss a connection between overly clean households and childhood asthma. Similarly, if I'm not mistaken, the lack of childhood pets is seen to be linked to animal allergies.
No, Quincy, from what I understand, I will have to continue to host the whipworms if I want to stay in remission. There are a couple of observational reports showing that removal of whipworms provokes or worsens a flare.
And I guess longterm studies would be needed for that effect. I know you and I have disagreed about this before, but there are studies showing that after two years of remission, 5asas show no added flare-prevention benefit, which is not to say there aren't other reasons to continue the meds. I don't know if the same can be said about whipworms.
mumbles said... That is awesome seconder. I really wish the FDA wouldn't ban them anymore. Where did you get them from?
What's this about the FDA banning whipworm treatments?
I asked my GI a few months ago about whipworm treatments, and he told me that while they were initially very hopeful, there had been later tests done that indicated whipworm treatments weren't quite as promising as they had hoped.
But I hope they do work out for you, seconder! Definitely let us know. :)12 Asacol 100 mg Imuran