EPE via biopsy?

In another thread, Sheepguy (I hope he's not Welsh) asked a question that has also been vexing me... Maybe we're both dumb but I wanted to pluck the question from that thread and seek clarification from y'all...

"How exactly is EPE diagnosed from a biopsy?"

As an aside is there ever internal 'ache' associated with PC or is my mind playing tricks on me...

Paul
7/6/14 PSA: 1.07
7/6/15 PSA: 4.3 DRE: Negative (PCP)
7/17/15 PSA: 2.56
8/10/15 PSA 8.41
8/14/15 PSA: 8.5 PHI 47.5 DRE: Enlarged but no nodule (URO)
9/18/15 3TMRI: 1xPIRADS 3/5 9mm lesion
Next: 11/10/15 UroNav Fusion biopsy (Hopkins)
Travel assistance - www.healingwell.com/community/default.aspx?f=35&m=3514920
On further review I find I have conflated the pathology reporting for biopsies and post-operative examination. What I said is right for post-op but appears to be inaccurate for biopsies where probable EPE is inferred from a number of factors. PeterDA

If the pathologist sees prostate cancer cells surrounded by prostate tissues then that cancer is contained but if he sees prostate cancer cells surrounded by some other tissues, then he knows it has grown outside the organ. Diagnosing EPE from a biopsy sample is a hit-or-miss proposition -- the sample needle has to enter the organ at a location where the cancer has grown beyond the prostate -- but it does happen and is reported.

Generally an achy prostate is caused by inflammation -- infection, calcification, urine backing up into the ducts -- and seldom, if ever, by cancer. Of course one can have both.
62 Slow PSA rise 2007-2012: 1.4=>8
4 bxs 2010-2012: 1&2 neg, 3 pos 1/14 6(3+3) 3-4% (2nd opn. 7(3+4)), 4 neg
DaVinci 6/14/12. "some" nerve sparing on left
Path: pT3a pN0 R1 GS9(4+5) Pos margins on rt
24 mo ADT3 7/12 - 7/14
Adj IMRT 66.6 Gy 10/17/12-12/13/12
8/2012-3/2015: Incont., Trimix, VED, PSA<0.015.
AUS & IPP installed 3/5/2015
Forum Moderator - Not a medical professional

Post Edited (PeterDisAbelard.) : 11/2/2015 1:29:35 PM (GMT-7)

If biopsy finds PNI , it indicates potential adverse pathology including EPE. Otherwise biopsy can't find EPE, which is by definition outside the prostate.
Cancer pain comes from mets to bones otherwise there is no pain.
Bob
Thanks Bob! There are definitely no bones in my ass, so that's a relief... uh oh that came out wrong... so did that... wink
7/6/14 PSA: 1.07
7/6/15 PSA: 4.3 DRE: Negative (PCP)
7/17/15 PSA: 2.56
8/10/15 PSA 8.41
8/14/15 PSA: 8.5 PHI 47.5 DRE: Enlarged but no nodule (URO)
9/18/15 3TMRI: 1xPIRADS 3/5 9mm lesion
Next: 11/10/15 UroNav Fusion biopsy (Hopkins)
Travel assistance - www.healingwell.com/community/default.aspx?f=35&m=3514920
The biopsy report say EPE...not possible EPE due to PNI.

I still don't see how a biopsy can show EPE. The needle is inserted into the prostate and the "trigger" is pulled after positioning...you would have to have the needle outside the prostate when the sample is taken. I presume most uros doing a biopsy try to position the needle to sample only prosate tissue.
sheepguy... reread my analysis on the other thread. Its all there and all correct.
Logo, Sure , I understand,my question is the mechanics of identification and sampling to determine EPE.not what you think the definitions are, right or wrong.
Sheep guy
I'd ask the doc who did the biopsy how he determined that EPE existed. Do you doubt the dx?
Bob
DOB January 1944 (now age 71)
8/12 PSA 2.7
5/13 PSA 6.6
7/13 Bx 4+5=9, 2 of 6 cores, 10%, 40%
9/13 ORRP, Gl9, pt3b, SVI+,margin+, EPE, Nodes clear
11/13 to 5/14 PSA .1,.2,.3
6&7/14 IMRT 68.2 gy. to Prostate bed, ADT 6 mos. Lupron
9/14 to 8/15 PSA <.1,<.1,.1,.3,.7,1.2
9/15 to 10/16 ADT3, metformin
9/15 to 12/15 IMRT/D.A.R.T. 75 gy to pelvic nodes, 50 fracti
Bob,
Well, yeah, I guess. The implications of EPE can alter treatment options so profoundly the pathologist/urologist better be right and it better make sense. If I was the patient I would ask the doc too. I have no idea how subjective the evaluation of EPE in a biopsy is.
This is one case where I would surely ask for more opinions..Bostwick or no.
Rest assured, that question will be asked of and answered by more than 1 doc to our satisfaction before any treatment is planned.
Dx age: 67
PSA: 7.0
Initial reading:
L side: clean
R side: 2 cores GS 3+3=6
4 cores GS 3+4=7
Bostwick 2nd opinion results:
LLM: high-grade prostatic intraepithelial neoplasia - ugh.

RLB: cancer (GS 3+4=7) involving 50% of the specimen. Gleason pattern 4 comprises 20% of the cancer. Extraprostratic extension - OMG.
RLM: cancer (GS 3+4=7) involving 80% of the specimen. Gleason pattern 4 comprises 20% of the cancer. Perineural invasion.
RLA: cancer (GS 3+4=7) involving 80% of the specimen. Gleason pattern 4 comprises 20% of the cancer. Perineural invasion.
RB: cancer (GS 3+4=7) involving 20% of the specimen. Gleason pattern 4 comprises 10% of the cancer.
RM: cancer (GS 3+4=7) involving 50% of the specimen. Gleason pattern 4 comprises 20% of the cancer.
RA: cancer (GS 3+4=7) involving 70% of the specimen. Gleason pattern 4 comprises 20% of the cancer. Perineural invasion.

CT scan clean
Bone scan clean
Chat,
Cool...be sure to let the group know what they say...
I've heard of guys being informed they had EPE after MRI guided biopsy. I found out after RP. Ugh! And ur right it is a whole different ball of wax. I'll be fighting for the rest of my shortened life. There is no cure for that.
Bob
DOB January 1944 (now age 71)
8/12 PSA 2.7
5/13 PSA 6.6
7/13 Bx 4+5=9, 2 of 6 cores, 10%, 40%
9/13 ORRP, Gl9, pt3b, SVI+,margin+, EPE, Nodes clear
11/13 to 5/14 PSA .1,.2,.3
6&7/14 IMRT 68.2 gy. to Prostate bed, ADT 6 mos. Lupron
9/14 to 8/15 PSA <.1,<.1,.1,.3,.7,1.2
9/15 to 10/16 ADT3, metformin
9/15 to 12/15 IMRT/D.A.R.T. 75 gy to pelvic nodes, 50 fracti
sheepguy

Thanks for asking the EPE via biopsy question . I have also been trying to find the answer to that question. Did you ever find an acceptable answer? Can you point me to that thread?


turn
As I understand it...the pathologist sees cells other than prostate surrounding the cancer cells generally adipose tissue..I think. Presumably insertion of the biopsy needle before sampling is not thought to gather any extraprostetic cells or at least not enough to matter. I think.
Of course that explanation implies that the "other" cells are inside the prostate, not outside...so maybe, as someone said , it is inferred by other factors such as PNI.. the importance of which is linked closely to percentage cancer in the biopsy cores according to to JH. So, hell, I don't know. :)
Somebody said...
As an aside is there ever internal 'ache' associated with PC or is my mind playing tricks on me..


Pre-treatment, I had a constant dull ache in my pelvis area. Post-treatment it is no longer there.
Age at Dx: 53,
pre-treatment PSA 14.35
4/14 PCA-3 = 12 (negative)
7/14 CDUS Biopsy GS 3+4, Prolaris Score -0.8
10/14 3T mpMRI "suspected ext. to base of left SV"
10/14 HDR brachy (mono-therapy) at UCLA
Post-treatment PSA:
3 mo =4.37
6 mo =2.85
9 mo = 2.35
12 mo =1.51
Dr Google wrote about EPE and biopsy: "Tumor admixed with periprostatic fat is the most easily recognized manifestation of extraprostatic extension. Tumor in fat is almost always a feature of extraprostatic extension by prostate cancer."
But it looks like that a biopsy as an unwanted rare SE also can cause EPE! However "seeding of prostate cancer along a needle biopsy track is a rare complication."
www.urologycasereports.com/article/S2214-4420(15)00012-1/fulltext. Have anyone heard about such a risk?