For those that have had an inguinal hernia after RALP, how was it found? I suspect that I have one based on where the burning and pain are. I had a CT scan but it was negative for hernia. I am 4 months out from surgery and have done well up until this started around Christmas.
Should I seek an ultrasound or MRI?
Thanks in advance for any advice.
Rich - I have been down the same road and precede you by a few years, although around the same time of year. Some post-op comments in the thread below:
https://www.healingwell.com/community/default.aspx?f=35&m=4093972&g=4095084
I discussed continued burning and pain issues (lower left side) with my urologist after a couple of months and had a CT scan which was negative. At three months, he examined me and could find no evidence of hernia. about a year a later, I mentioned continued nagging issues in lower left side to my PCP who could not feel anything and had an ultrasound done which was negative.
Less than a year later, I was on a long walk and developed an ache on my lower right side which slowed me down. I noticed some swelling when I got home. Kept happening the next times I walked so checked in with my PCP who said looks like inguinal hernia on right side and noted that it goes away when I lay down which was good, nothing dangerous. He referred me to surgeon who said I had an inguinal hernia on right side and would get a CT scan to see if showed anything. The CT scan was negative and my surgeon that is not unusual as you are laying down for the test and it is really hard to make it show up when they tell you to strain. He said it is obvious when standing and could be felt.
Rocket ahead another year and I am doing better than after the robot assisted hernia surgery. I swear that all the dissection work the surgeon did to get at the inguinal hernia corrected some adhesions and scar tissue from my RALP surgery. He also checked the left side where the original pain and burning tended to be and everything was fine. I will never know for sure what was going on.
My experience was that the CT and ultrasound were not helpful for my inguinal hernia. Other types of hernias may show up better or will be of significant size that imaging may show them. You might try seeing a hernia surgeon who does these surgeries a lot and examines a lot of men for an evaluation. I highly recommend the robot assisted hernia surgery but it is a bit of a gamble that the surgeon will be able to successfully navigate the minefield left behind from surgery and ART in my case. My surgeon says to takes almost twice as long as a typical repair due to the dissection involved to get at the site.
7/2018 (66yr), PSA 4.1->5.1
8/2018-MRI PI-RADS 5, MRI guided biopsy, 8/14 cores, G7(4+3)
9/2018-CT/Bone scans clear
11/6/18-RALP Surgery
11/2018-Post-Op Path G7(4+3) 5% Tert Gr 5, pT3a pN0 Gr 3, SM, EPE, <3mm
11/2018-Decipher 0.47, Ave Risk
1/2019-Epstein-G9(4+5) Gr5, pT2x, margin vs. incision not clear
4-6/2019 ART 37 days
PSA<0.10: 2/19, 5/19, 8/19, 11/19, 2/20, 6/20, 9/20, 3/21, 10/21
https://www.healingwell.com/community/default.aspx?f=35&m=4093972&g=4095084
I discussed continued burning and pain issues (lower left side) with my urologist after a couple of months and had a CT scan which was negative. At three months, he examined me and could find no evidence of hernia. about a year a later, I mentioned continued nagging issues in lower left side to my PCP who could not feel anything and had an ultrasound done which was negative.
Less than a year later, I was on a long walk and developed an ache on my lower right side which slowed me down. I noticed some swelling when I got home. Kept happening the next times I walked so checked in with my PCP who said looks like inguinal hernia on right side and noted that it goes away when I lay down which was good, nothing dangerous. He referred me to surgeon who said I had an inguinal hernia on right side and would get a CT scan to see if showed anything. The CT scan was negative and my surgeon that is not unusual as you are laying down for the test and it is really hard to make it show up when they tell you to strain. He said it is obvious when standing and could be felt.
Rocket ahead another year and I am doing better than after the robot assisted hernia surgery. I swear that all the dissection work the surgeon did to get at the inguinal hernia corrected some adhesions and scar tissue from my RALP surgery. He also checked the left side where the original pain and burning tended to be and everything was fine. I will never know for sure what was going on.
My experience was that the CT and ultrasound were not helpful for my inguinal hernia. Other types of hernias may show up better or will be of significant size that imaging may show them. You might try seeing a hernia surgeon who does these surgeries a lot and examines a lot of men for an evaluation. I highly recommend the robot assisted hernia surgery but it is a bit of a gamble that the surgeon will be able to successfully navigate the minefield left behind from surgery and ART in my case. My surgeon says to takes almost twice as long as a typical repair due to the dissection involved to get at the site.
7/2018 (66yr), PSA 4.1->5.1
8/2018-MRI PI-RADS 5, MRI guided biopsy, 8/14 cores, G7(4+3)
9/2018-CT/Bone scans clear
11/6/18-RALP Surgery
11/2018-Post-Op Path G7(4+3) 5% Tert Gr 5, pT3a pN0 Gr 3, SM, EPE, <3mm
11/2018-Decipher 0.47, Ave Risk
1/2019-Epstein-G9(4+5) Gr5, pT2x, margin vs. incision not clear
4-6/2019 ART 37 days
PSA<0.10: 2/19, 5/19, 8/19, 11/19, 2/20, 6/20, 9/20, 3/21, 10/21
Mumbo,
Thank you for taking the time to respond to my question and provide such detailed information. I am going to keep moving forward to see about a more definitive test. It seems that they looked at the CT and decided "nothing to see here" but my lower-right side is in disagreement with them. The Motrin that was recommended has done little, if anything to ease it.
Thank you again for sharing your experience! It is much appreciated.
Thank you for taking the time to respond to my question and provide such detailed information. I am going to keep moving forward to see about a more definitive test. It seems that they looked at the CT and decided "nothing to see here" but my lower-right side is in disagreement with them. The Motrin that was recommended has done little, if anything to ease it.
Thank you again for sharing your experience! It is much appreciated.
I had inguinal hernia surgery (both sides) several years after treating my PCa with RP and RT. It was a long time coming and clearly pre-dated my prostate difficulties. My primary care doc detected a "weakness" at least 10 years before, and he said I needed to be on the lookout for a hernia. A year ago I knew that the hernia had arrived because it hurt and I could see a bulge on the right side of my lower abdomen. When I met with the surgeon, he had seen the CT scan done after my PCa biopsy; he said the developing hernia could be seen in the CT scan from four years before. It's interesting that Mumbo's hernia was not detected by a CT scan. I had open surgery last February. Went home the same day. I found a hernia belt very helpful prior to the surgery.
Age: 65
Diagnosed in July 2016 with G7 (4+3) & PNI
Surgery at Lenox Hill Hospital in NYC, 9/12/2016
Post-surgery pathology: G7 (3+4), with +SVI, +PSM, +EPE, and -LNI
Post-surgery PSA, 10/16: <.008; 12/16: 0.01; 6/17: 0.05
IMRT begun: July 18, 2017 (35 fractions)
Post-SRT PSA, 11/17: <.008; 1/18: <.008; 07/18: <.008; 11/18: <.01; 4/19: <.008; 8/19: <.008; 11/19: <.01; 6/20: <.008; 11/20: <.014
Age: 65
Diagnosed in July 2016 with G7 (4+3) & PNI
Surgery at Lenox Hill Hospital in NYC, 9/12/2016
Post-surgery pathology: G7 (3+4), with +SVI, +PSM, +EPE, and -LNI
Post-surgery PSA, 10/16: <.008; 12/16: 0.01; 6/17: 0.05
IMRT begun: July 18, 2017 (35 fractions)
Post-SRT PSA, 11/17: <.008; 1/18: <.008; 07/18: <.008; 11/18: <.01; 4/19: <.008; 8/19: <.008; 11/19: <.01; 6/20: <.008; 11/20: <.014
Fiddlecanoe,
Thank you for your response and the information.
I really appreciate it.
Thank you for your response and the information.
I really appreciate it.
ps: there are two type of inguinal hernias, indirect and direct. Mine was an indirect hernia which means that a defect existed since birth that took 68 years and RALP to unleash. Direct hernia is a weakening in the muscles over time. Also had an umbilical hernia repair which is another defect from birth.
fiddlecanoe - Can’t explain the imaging not showing any hernia but had a CT before surgery, after surgery and later by the surgeon which did not indicate a hernia even when reviewing previous imaging. Also had an ultrasound that was inconclusive. The last two were looking for a hernia and did not find anything. My surgeon said “Yet, you have a hernia which is obvious by examination.” I suspect that a well developed hernia will get picked up most of the time but mine did not and the surgeon said it happens so Rich should be aware of false negative with scans and look after it.
7/2018 (66yr), PSA 4.1->5.1
8/2018-MRI PI-RADS 5, MRI guided biopsy, 8/14 cores, G7(4+3)
9/2018-CT/Bone scans clear
11/6/18-RALP Surgery
11/2018-Post-Op Path G7(4+3) 5% Tert Gr 5, pT3a pN0 Gr 3, SM, EPE, <3mm
11/2018-Decipher 0.47, Ave Risk
1/2019-Epstein-G9(4+5) Gr5, pT2x, margin vs. incision not clear
4-6/2019 ART 37 days
PSA<0.10: 2/19, 5/19, 8/19, 11/19, 2/20, 6/20, 9/20, 3/21, 10/21
fiddlecanoe - Can’t explain the imaging not showing any hernia but had a CT before surgery, after surgery and later by the surgeon which did not indicate a hernia even when reviewing previous imaging. Also had an ultrasound that was inconclusive. The last two were looking for a hernia and did not find anything. My surgeon said “Yet, you have a hernia which is obvious by examination.” I suspect that a well developed hernia will get picked up most of the time but mine did not and the surgeon said it happens so Rich should be aware of false negative with scans and look after it.
7/2018 (66yr), PSA 4.1->5.1
8/2018-MRI PI-RADS 5, MRI guided biopsy, 8/14 cores, G7(4+3)
9/2018-CT/Bone scans clear
11/6/18-RALP Surgery
11/2018-Post-Op Path G7(4+3) 5% Tert Gr 5, pT3a pN0 Gr 3, SM, EPE, <3mm
11/2018-Decipher 0.47, Ave Risk
1/2019-Epstein-G9(4+5) Gr5, pT2x, margin vs. incision not clear
4-6/2019 ART 37 days
PSA<0.10: 2/19, 5/19, 8/19, 11/19, 2/20, 6/20, 9/20, 3/21, 10/21