Illusory Superiority and Medical Decision-Making

Illusory superiority is the bias that most of us, including myself, have about our abilities or thinking capabilities. Study after study has proven this. In the ficitional Lake Wobegon, for example, all the children are above average. The majority of students in nearly all studies of intellect think they are above average; in one study 25% of students thought themselves in the top 1%.

I began to wonder how this affects our medical decision-making. Do we make stupid or ill-informed decisions about our health because we think we know more than we do? I personally think that forums like this PCa forum can be exceedingly useful in providing a collective counterweight to our own biases.

I recently encountered an example of this regarding a financial decision about when to take Social Security. I thought I knew a lot, but my illusory superiority kept me from learning additional information important to the decision.

We have all faced this when we were told we had prostate cancer. And the initial kick to the gut that the news brings, with the resulting fear of the unknown, can skew our rational, decision-making capability.

As for me, I'm not among the 25% who think themselves in the top 1%, but I'm definitely above average.
Age 66, Diagnosed G6 at age 57
Prostatectomy 2006
PSA's <0.03
It may be alarming, but half of all doctors are below average.
55@Dx 4/16/13
Bx: 6 of 12 pos, G9=5+4 (80%, 60%), 4+5 (2 at 100%, 80%, 10%), PNI+
cT3a (3T MRI: Bilateral EPE, NVB+, SV-, LN-)

Pre:
Date PSA fPSA
9/12 4.1 15%
3/13 5.2 12% PCA3=31
4/13 9.7

Tx:
IGRT by IMRT, 44 done 8/28/13: 50.4 Gy pelvic nodes, 79.2 Gy prostate
ADT2 3 yrs: Lupron/Casodex 5/1/13

Post: (age now 57)
<0.1 PSA (w/ADT2): 8/13, 11/13, 2/14, 5/14, 10/14, 11/14, 3/15
Yes, but below average of what? Below average on intellectual ability of the general populace..I doubt it.
I'd venture the active posters on this forum think of themselves in the top 0.1% of the general populace and the top 1% of MDs...which they are not. I think someone recently posted that he knew so much that his urologist felt threatened..he'd better get another one.
Not me!...tee hee!
One of the most difficult things any person can do is admit ignorance. Especially when the reality is that not only are there many things we don't know because we haven't figured them out, there are many things we don't know because it never occurs to us that we could know them...that we haven't even figured out what the question should be.

Illusory superiority is only one problem we suffer from. Confirmation bias is another one--which in my definition is the tendency to only listen to those who tell us things we can agree with..or to only look for answers that confirm what we already believe to be true. Data that does not support the hypothesis is to be discarded.

In short, we all suffer from cranial-rectal inversion to some degree.
Age at Diagnosis: 56
Biopsy: 3 of 12, G3+3, all on LT side, 20%, 5%, 3%
Clinical Stage T1C
Bone Scan, CT scan negative for spread
RALP on 2/17/15, BJC St. Louis, Dr. Figenshau
No EPE, 20% organ involvement, g3+4 final
PSA 3/10/15: 0.10
5/18/15: <.04
My Story: www.healingwell.com/community/default.aspx?f=35&m=3300024
halbert said...
One of the most difficult things any person can do is admit ignorance. Especially when the reality is that not only are there many things we don't know because we haven't figured them out, there are many things we don't know because it never occurs to us that we could know them...that we haven't even figured out what the question should be.

Illusory superiority is only one problem we suffer from. Confirmation bias is another one--which in my definition is the tendency to only listen to those who tell us things we can agree with..or to only look for answers that confirm what we already believe to be true. Data that does not support the hypothesis is to be discarded.

In short, we all suffer from cranial-rectal inversion to some degree.


Confirmation bias certainly plays into our decision-making. Something else that has occurred because of Internet access to medical information is that we may think that excavating for information on the Internet makes us better decision-makers than our doctors. While a medical decision is at-best a shared decision, we can tend think that our extensive research has made us more knowledgeable and thus ignore or deprecate our doctor's opinion based on many years of medical training and experience.
Age 66, Diagnosed G6 at age 57
Prostatectomy 2006
PSA's <0.03
The only person that really knows your BODY is YOU and the final DECISION always RESTS with YOU!

Don't believe every doctor's prognosis. There is this little video doing the rounds about ARTHUR never giving up /www.youtube.com/watch?v=qX9FSZJu448

Have fun!

.
Pre-op:DX 9/13 Age 58-- G9(5+4) 1/16cores-- PriorPSA 3.7 08/13;2.4 03/12;1.9 12/10;1.6 12/09;0.8 03/04
RRP:10/13, LNerve spared pT2aN0M0
Post-op:PSA < 0.01 11/13, 01/14, 02/14, 04/14, 05/14, 09/14, 10/14, 03/15, 04/15-- ED: PDE5i & TRIMIX (0.1cc) 05/14-- Continent: 02/2014
Extra:Nebido
Story:www.healingwell.com/community/default.aspx?f=35&m=3215183
PSA,

I really liked the video. Thanks!
Ditto to PSA3DOT7's video being a good video....
Thanks for the video. Many times, when a doctor, or other professional, tells us that we're in a hopeless condition they're really saying that they are out of answers. They don't like to admit ignorance any more than the rest of us do, the problems come when they tell us that there aren't any answers out there.

The best ones...and they are rare...are willing to admit that they've taken us as far as they can. And that should be OK.

This is a valuable thread and conversation to have.
Age at Diagnosis: 56
Biopsy: 3 of 12, G3+3, all on LT side, 20%, 5%, 3%
Clinical Stage T1C
Bone Scan, CT scan negative for spread
RALP on 2/17/15, BJC St. Louis, Dr. Figenshau
No EPE, 20% organ involvement, g3+4 final
PSA 3/10/15: 0.10
5/18/15: <.04
My Story: www.healingwell.com/community/default.aspx?f=35&m=3300024
Redwing57 said...
It may be alarming, but half of all doctors are below average.


sheepguy said...
Yes, but below average of what? Below average on intellectual ability of the general populace..I doubt it.


HA! Yes, that's a terrifying fact(I took it as a jest) but totally true! By definition, 1/2 of our doctors are below average, when compared to other doctors! However, no doubt we have all used our Illusory superiority and confirmation biases to make sure our doctors are all well above average, compared to all the other doctors. I know I have!
Great video, gave me chills when I saw Arthur run.

This thread is interesting and it made me think of a comment I've made to a Dr here and there, to the effect of "I should have been an engineer, I'm a data junkie". It sounds Sort of like making an excuse, and apologizing for knowing way more than most of their patients. Which we shouldn't do.

But it also makes me think, should our job as patients, as our own advocates, be to just find highly skilled and cutting edge doctors, that we feel comfortable trusting, and let them take it from there, so we can just focus on healing? Sometimes I think that's the case. But there is probably a balance between being trusting of our Drs and being informed.

The biases discussed here do make a case for us not making our own decisions, on some level. I'm not advocating that, completely. But as I said, there is probably a balance, somewhere
Age 64 (in 2014), Father had PCa, PSA Feb 2006 - Nov 2014, PSA rose from .7 to 4.3
Nov 2012 - Biopsy - 14 cores all negative for PCa, 1 showed Hi Grade PIN
Nov 2014 BX 3 of 12 cores positive original pathology G6 10%, G6 20%, G8 (3+5), 70%.
Johns Hopkins second opinion, G3+5=8 downgraded to 3+3=6 @80%
Bone scan and CT Scan negative
Surgery with Dr Ash Tewari Jan 6, 2015
Post surgical pathology – G7 (3+4), ECE, Margins, LN, SV all negative
PSA @ 6 weeks 2/15, .<02, 4/15 <.02
My Story: http://www.healingwell.com/community/default.aspx?f=35&m=3297053
Glad you enjoyed Arthur's Video!

My Endocrinologist got a bit "toey" with me last week, because I didn't follow her advice. She wanted me to buy Vitamin D and take 5000Ui (or is IUs) per day ( this was her PhD thesis). I didn't, instead I went back to eating at least two salmon meals a week and my vitamin D returned to normal. Then she got upset because I refused to take Metformin (Diabex) to manage my diabetes. I told her that my HB1Ac was 6.2 and that I manage it quite well using a few shots of rapid insulin. Lastly, I refused to take Cholesterol tablets because I'm allergic to statins. I think what annoyed her most was my blood work, which was really good without me adhering to her advice. She said that since I was doing so well, perhaps we should not meet anymore; she was not happy!

I always thought that doctors should treat patients so that they, the doctors, are no longer needed. The nice thing about the encounter was, she did not charge me any extra money for the consultation, apparently Medicare was sufficient.

My motto is "MY BODY KNOWS BEST!"
.
Pre-op:DX 9/13 Age 58-- G9(5+4) 1/16cores-- PriorPSA 3.7 08/13;2.4 03/12;1.9 12/10;1.6 12/09;0.8 03/04
RRP:10/13, LNerve spared pT2aN0M0
Post-op:PSA < 0.01 11/13, 01/14, 02/14, 04/14, 05/14, 09/14, 10/14, 03/15, 04/15-- ED: PDE5i & TRIMIX (0.1cc) 05/14-- Continent: 02/2014
Extra:Nebido
Story:www.healingwell.com/community/default.aspx?f=35&m=3215183
I always approach my doctor with a question for clarification of what I think I understand vs what he knows. The better ones will say they do not know it that is the case. My most recent question was to a research doc on why my PSA would drop 97% yet the scan would only indicate a 10% reduction in tumor size. If PSA expression is a measure of tumor burden then why is there not a corresponding drop unless the med is only suppressing the tumors ability to produce PSA. Got an answer but not sure I fully signed on to it.

I also find the young doctors to be less inclined to admit ignorance than the older ones. But they do have the latest information in many cases even if they have not seen many cases.

The video was inspiring. Thanks for the link.

Don
Diagnosed 04/10/08 Age 58
Gleason 4 + 3 DRE palpable tumor on left side
100% of 12 cores positive for PCa range 35% to 85% Bone scan and chest x ray clear CT scan shows potential lymph node involvement in pelvic region
IGRT/IMRT with adjuvant HT (lupron) 2yrs
PSA:
02/08 21.5 at diagnosis
07/10 0.10 nadir
06/11 3.47 HT (Lupron started again in late July)
09/11 0.70
superiority…Whats wrong with everyone thinking "superior" thoughts? I would submit they are better than inferior thoughts. Oh... if they don't match reality…think harder… No one is better than anyone else…conversely…everyone is as good as the other one. Now don't confuse me with facts…Im talking about what is true...
don826 said...
.............My most recent question was to a research doc on why my PSA would drop 97% yet the scan would only indicate a 10% reduction in tumor size. If PSA expression is a measure of tumor burden then why is there not a corresponding drop unless the med is only suppressing the tumors ability to produce PSA. Got an answer but not sure I fully signed on to it.

I also find the young doctors to be less inclined to admit ignorance than the older ones. ................


What was the answer?

Just before my discharge after my RP, one of the younger URO residents came in to check me out and asked if I had any questions. I asked him: "Do G6s someday grow up to be G9s, or are G9s born a G9?". I think I literally ruined his day. He had no clue what the answer was, it was clear he had never heard the question discussed before. He seemed very embarrassed that he did not know, or maybe that a patient could ask a question related to PC of which he would be totally ignorant. I felt bad for him.
PSA 10.9 ~112013
Bx on 112013 at age 64 yrs 11 months, with 5 of 12 pos with one G9(5+4), 1 PNI, T2B.
RALP with lymph nodes at Vanderbilt 021914. (nodes clear, but SV+, still G9 but down graded to 4+5, cut wide, but 1 tiny foci right at the edge of margin ) Pros. 106.7 gms!
At 15 months, not wearing a pad most days, mostly dry
PSA <.1 on 4/7,
PSA <.01 on 6/11, 8/20/14 and 3/4/15
Don, for the youth vs experience point....to the young freshly trained doctor, everything is known or knowable. As age and experience appear, that certainty fades. That's part of being human.

I think the most formidable people in any profession are those who have enough experience to realize they aren't ever going to know everything and still have enough energy and curiosity to keep digging. In our little PCa world, I found it very comforting before the fact to know that my chosen surgeon not only had over 1000 DaVinci surgeries, he also had that many or more open surgeries before DaVinci came online. He'd been there and done that and seen an awful lot.

Don't ever stop learning. And always be willing to admit that there is, in fact, more to learn.
Age at Diagnosis: 56
Biopsy: 3 of 12, G3+3, all on LT side, 20%, 5%, 3%
Clinical Stage T1C
Bone Scan, CT scan negative for spread
RALP on 2/17/15, BJC St. Louis, Dr. Figenshau
No EPE, 20% organ involvement, g3+4 final
PSA 3/10/15: 0.10
5/18/15: <.04
My Story: www.healingwell.com/community/default.aspx?f=35&m=3300024
BillyBob,
The essence of the answer was that the drugs are being developed as alternatives to chemo that have less debilitating effects than chemo and are at least as good as chemo for treatment. Mostly palliative while conserving quality of life a bit longer. I found it odd that cure was not mentioned and did not want to be argumentative.

On another note regarding curative intent I read an article some time ago that said over 1700 new drugs had been approved in the previous ten years and not one had curative intent. They were all designed to turn the malady they treated into a "manageable chronic disease". I read this as "ATM" for the docs and big pharma. Sorry, I am being rude.

Don
A very interesting topic, IMHO. I think illusory superiority and confirmation bias are both real. But so are complacency, laziness and over-compliance with whatever a doctor says. The trick is to find the balance - a never ending battle for me.

I also find it interesting about the doctors who are embarrassed if they don't know it all or, worse yet, make it up. I have a very good friend who is now retired but was a well known endocrinologist. Early in his career one of his patients came to him with an insect bite that she feared was from a Brown Recluse Spider. As a young doctor who "knew it all" he examined the bite and assured her that it was not. Shortly thereafter her husband (an entomologist) appeared with the spider in a bottle -- with expert assurances that it was indeed a Brown Recluse. As my friend tells it, from that moment on, he was never afraid to admit that he didn't know something but always said he would find out the answer and get back to the patient. I have no doubt that he was an outstanding physician.

Jim
Forum Moderator-Prostate Cancer. Age 62 (69 now), G 3 + 4 = 7, T1C, PSA 4.2, 2/16 cancerous, 27cc. Brachytherapy 12/9/08. 73 Iodine-125 seeds. Everything continues to function normally. PSA: 6 mo: 1.4, 1 yr: 1.0, 2 yr: .8, 3 yr: .5, 4/5 yr: .2, 6 yr: .1, 7 yr: .1. My docs are "delighted"! My journey:
http://www.healingwell.com/community/default.aspx?f=35&m=1305643&g=1305643#m1