Interesting report on possible lab contamination of Lyme tests

I found a report in PubMed from April 2014 that may interest you. It appears that some Lyme tests may be contaminated by the lab process and may then yield a false positive.

http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/23946519

http://www.medpagetoday.com/InfectiousDisease/GeneralInfectiousDisease/45318
Yet more double-speak in my opinion.
In the first link: www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/23946519 they say:
"Eighty percent (41/51) of the reported patient-derived pyrG sequences were identical to one of the laboratory strains, and an additional 12% (6/51) differed by only a single nucleotide across a 603-bp region of the pyrG gene. Thus, false positivity due to laboratory contamination of patient samples cannot be ruled out, and further validation of the proposed novel culture method is required."

Yet, if we don't test positive for Bb senso stricto (translates to 'strictest sense', meaning only 1 strain of Lyme), they want to tell us that we don't have Lyme disease - even though there are over 300 strains of Borrelia worldwide.

In the second link:www.medpagetoday.com/InfectiousDisease/GeneralInfectiousDisease/45318
they say "Nearly a decade ago, the agencies warned against the use of "home brew" tests for Borrelia burgdorferi that have been developed and manufactured by individual laboratories, because of the possibility of inaccuracies."

Yet 'the agencies' have not made any steps to develop a better test either.
"CDC currently recommends two-tier testing for Lyme disease utilizing an FDA-approved enzyme immunoassay (ELISA) that can then be confirmed by an approved Western blot test."
We all know how accurate those are! wink

And let's not forget what's at the end of the article:"The authors are employees of CDC and FDA."
Herb only treatment for Lyme & Bart ended Dec. 2011 - no active symptoms
Herb only treatment for Babesia ended Dec. 2012 - no active symptoms
Healed and loving life!

www.healingwell.com/community/default.aspx?f=30&m=2977364

Had Lyme, Bart, Babs, RMSF, Ehrlichia, Myco, Anaplasmosis, EBV

Questions? Please email me!!! Click on blue envelop
The above info is part of a conspiracy to invalidate any test other than the two-tiered tests the CDC/IDSA promote for Lyme testing.

Please see www.elenacook.org/cdc_johnson_buries_lyme_data.html for more info.
-Razzle

Chronic Lyme, Bart., Gluten & Sulfite Sensitivity, Many Food/Inhalant/Medication/Chemical Allergies & Intolerances, Asthma, Gut dysmotility & non-specific inflammation, Lupus, Osteoporosis, etc.; G-Tube; TPN-dependent
Meds: Flagyl, Zofran, Acupuncture, etc.

Post Edited (Razzle) : 5/14/2014 7:07:12 PM (GMT-6)

What I find troubling and the reason why I posted it is that many in the medical profession will quote this article when dismissing Lyme tests and degrade the accuracy of bonafide tests.

I have seen some posts here where people state that their doctors have dismissed their Igenix tests because of too many false positives. I am pretty sure that this article is what they have in mind because Igenix is one of the few that doesn't follow strict CDC guidelines (a good thing).

Perhaps if more people read this article, they could argue their doctor's statement by saying "yes, but the article also says that....."
wink Well, I guess we just helped them find their responses if their doc tries to use that line on them! smilewinkgrin

I think the bigger problem is that doctors are believing this because it's "safer". They don't risk losing everything if they hide behind the IDSA and CDC.

What people should be doing - in my opinion - if their doc says those types of things about Igenex is walk away - go find a doc that will recognize that this lab is fully licensed and has to pass inspections like every other lab out there.

From Igenex site: www.igenex.com/Website/ Click on "statements of principles"

"QUALITY TESTING

IGeneX places special emphasis on quality. We strive to offer the most sensitive and specific tests available to the Lyme community. Our laboratory is regularly inspected and recertified to perform high complexity testing. To further monitor our effectiveness, we have frequent inspections by outside consultants who were former state and federal laboratory inspectors or laboratory directors."

But thank you for pointing this out, Healing!
Herb only treatment for Lyme & Bart ended Dec. 2011 - no active symptoms
Herb only treatment for Babesia ended Dec. 2012 - no active symptoms
Healed and loving life!

www.healingwell.com/community/default.aspx?f=30&m=2977364

Had Lyme, Bart, Babs, RMSF, Ehrlichia, Myco, Anaplasmosis, EBV

Questions? Please email me!!! Click on blue envelop
The CDC paper accusing Dr Sapi's test of being invalid due to "contamination" is fraudulent.

1. Unbeknown to Dr Barbara Johnson when she embarked on this libel, the alleged contaminating lab control strains were housed in Dr Sapi's lab in New Haven, Ct, whilst the alleged target of "contamination", the patient's cultures, were in Pennsylvania, 200 miles away.

2. The CDC paper contained the following sentence:

"Accordingly, we determined the relevant portion of the pyrG
114 DNA sequences of the other laboratory strains and deposited them in GenBank [KF170280
115 (strain BO23); KF170281 (strain 297); and KF170282 (strain Fuji P1)
"

At the time the paper was published, these strains were NOT in Genbank at all. CDC hastily put them in after Dr Alan MacDonald, the distinguished Lyme pathologist, flagged up this error. The fact that the CDC gene sequences were not available in Genbank when the pa0per went to press means no proper peer review could have taken place, as the peer reviewers had no way of checking the allegations.

3. Once in Genbank, the CDC strains became available for public scrutiny. I invite any of you to put these strains in BLAST and see what you get. You will find SIGNIFICANT discrepancies between what the CDC papers says, and what BLAST, the premier tool used by scientists the world over for comparing gene sequences to the existing body of knowledge, says.

4. A small section of this single gene, the pyrG gene, does show similarity with the control strains. What CDC have failed to tell you is that SO DO OTHER BORRELIA STRAINS which have nothing to do with Dr Sapi's experiments. They have also failed to mention the recent work by Dr Elena Gomez Diaz, who surveyed Borrelia strains from all over the globe, and found identical pyrG gene sequences in some strains from countries oceans apart, and from different ecological niches (seabirds vs land animal ticks etc)

Bottom line: even if all of Dr Sapi's strains isolated from patients were identical to all the control strains (which they are not), it still would not have great significance

5. CDC claimed the results were invalid on the grounds that Borrelia garinii could not be in US. B. garinii is in Mexico - it's hard to see why migrating birds would come to a screeching halt at the border.

There are many other pieces of evidence indicating garinii is in USA - and even CDC's Johnson said this herself in a patent shortly before the publication of her paper!

6. I hope my post is not tampered with, as it was at the forum MDJunction. The moderators there have assured me they were not responsible for removing my data. So who did? And why?
Elena Cook