1. Right Mid - G 3+3, 50% (7mm)
2. Right Lateral Mid - G 3+3, 20% (3mm)
3. Right Base - G 3+4, 50% (6mm)
4. Right Lateral Base - G 3+4 (7mm)
Urologist described treatment options as AS, Surgery and Radiation. He gave a brief rundown on the SE's of each. Offered to set me up with a Radiation Oncologist if I had questions about radiation treatment.
I listened to what he was saying but was in a bit fog. I thought he was OK with AS and, at the time, so was I, but the more I read, the less comfortable I am with that course of action.
I am pretty sure I will get a second opinion - not sure from who just yet (my brother went to the Prostate Center at MGH but there is also a good prostate center at Dana Farber). They look like multidisciplinary programs which was attractive to me. Any suggestions or guidance when selecting that second opinion location? It looks like each of those two would do their own review of biopsy slides - any need to send to Dr. Epstein or do you guys think I can be OK with those center's evals? How does insurance work for such second opinions? - I have medicare and tricare.
How quickly do I need to be moving on this decision making? Any other thoughts for this new guy? Age here is 69.
Currently reading "Surviving Prostate Cancer."
I have found a wealth of information on this forum and thank you to all for sharing. Would appreciate any suggestions or comments that you guys might have!!
First Dana Farber probably has a great pathology team. I’m a little OCD so if it were me I’d probably ask at the slide to be sent to Epstein anyway. The second opinion with Epstein won’t be covered, but it’s not that expensive I paid $250 six years ago with might be $300 now
Regarding AS you will probably find differing opinions here. AS is a proven viable option under the right circumstances. However for me if you have 3+4, that’s a disqualifier especially 2 cores at 3+4 and even more especially with one of those scores been 50% cancerous. Grade 4 cells can be ornery. So for me I would not choose a S but that’s again that’s me we are all different
With your pathology I think you’ve got some time to explore all of your options make the right decisions prostate cancer is slow growing especially if you don’t have anything above a G7.
Yes speak with the surgeon and speak with multiple radiation oncologist because there are different types of radiation from SBRT AKA cyber knife, To high-dose radiation Brachytherapy, to external beam radiation. And different radiation oncologist may specialize in different methodologies so speak to an expert in each of those. Reading Dr. Walsh‘s book is a great idea it’s very informative. Walsh is a surgeon, you might also want to read Invasion of the Prostate Snatchers by Mark Scholz, for a different perspective.
Keep getting educated, talk to a lot of experts in their field, talk to a lot of us who have been through this, keeping in mind that none of us are doctors, then make the best decision you can with the facts that you have. This will all work out and I can tell you from experience there’s lots of life after prostate cancer. You will look back on this as a bump in the road
Good luck and keep us posted
I am not a doctor, just a guy without a prostate
Dx Age 64 Nov 2014, PSA 4.3
BX 3 of 12 cores positive original pathology G6
RALP with Dr Ash Tewari Jan 6, 2015
Post surgical pathology G7 (3+4), - ECE, - Margins, -LN, -SV (+ frozen section apex converted to negative)
PSA @ 6 weeks 2/15, .<02, remained <0.02 until January 2017, .02, repeat Feb 2017, still .02. May 2017-.033, August 2017- .033 November .046, March 2018 .060. June 2018 .068, July 2018 - .082, August 2018, .078, August 2018 - .08 Start ADT. Sept 2018 Start SRT
Sept 2018 thru November 2018 – T = 4, PSA = <.05
Decipher test, low risk, .37 score
My story.... https:// tinyurl.com/qgyu3xq
A biopsy samples a tiny amount of prostate tissue. Many men with G7 (3+4) who choose surgery are upgraded to G7 (4+3). After surgery an accurate measure of the percentages of patterns 3 and 4 can be made for samples from the entire prostate. Whether or not the percentage of pattern 4 is above or below 50% is a bit of a crap shoot when going by the biopsy only. Radiation is a perfectly valid primary treatment for G7 disease; just keep in mind that one's biopsy Gleason score (even confirmed by a 2nd opinion) is an approximation and may not reflect the actual pathological picture.
SBRT has had very good BCR results, but not very long term ones yet (as measured in decades and with overall survival stats). If you do discuss SBRT with radiologists, I would make sure they are familiar with this recent study from MSK that found that the standard-of-case total dosage some men are getting may not be high enough for SBRT to achieve the best oncological outcomes.
All the best to you!
Djin
69 yr at Dx, BPH x 20 yr, 9 (!) neg. Bx
2013 TURP for BPH (90-->30 g) no PCa
6-6-17 Nodule (R) + PSA on finasteride: 3.6-->4.3
Bx #10: 2/14 cores: G10 (5+5) 50% RB, G9 (4+5) 3% RLM, nodule neg
Bone scan, CTs: neg, 8-7-17 open RP @Duke, neg frozen sections, nerves spared
SM EPE BNI LVI SVI LNI(16): neg, PNI+, pT2c pN0 R0 MX, G9 (4+5) 5%, 64 g
Decipher 0.37 Low Risk, PSA 0.010 (3m)…0.020 (3y 7m)
Post Edited (DjinTonic) : 4/20/2021 12:54:09 PM (GMT-6)
Rising PSA
11/12 1.98
11/13 1.95
9/15 3.28
10/16 5.94
1/17 3.0
TRUS 1/17
Bx: Three of twelve cores adenocarcinoma Gleason 6 (3+3)
all on left side and <5%, no pni
DOB 7/21/47 good health.
Age 69 @ Dx
Treated with SBRT by Dr. Tendulcar @
Cleveland Clinic 6/23/17
Reduced ejaculate is only side effect. Everything works
PSA’s post SBRT 1.1, 1.1, .9, 1.8, 2.7, 1.0, 0.3, 0.6, 0.8
I can see that I may have been a bit too optimistic about not needing to have treatment. AS is sounding less and less like a good choice to me.
@Pratoman - thanks for the tip on Invasion of the Prostate Snatchers - I like seeing the problem from different perspectives. I appreciated your comment that G4 type cells can be ornery - I should have reminded myself that it is only one step down from the most aggressive type.
@Djin - thanks for the remarks on the biopsy results and the subjectivity in the classification. All the more reason to be thinking more about treatment.
@Terry and @Djin - radiation has been on my mind as a potential choice. I did not know that there were so many choices on the radiation side. Actually, I have not spent enough time comparing the potential treatment paths and I need to start reading about them.
Since my Dr. and the biopsy were done here in the suburbs and because so much depends on the biopsy results, I am strongly considering getting those biopsy slides down to Dr. Epstein to get his view of them.
When you have teaching hospitals like we have here in Boston, there are a couple of potentially good choices. Any suggestions on how best to choose between them?
Thanks,
I too was diagnosed by a Uro in suburban Boston. He was straightforward in recommending I investigate all my options, while making plain his personal preference for surgery -- and recommending a leading open procedure (not robotic) surgeon at MGH. I liked his candor but there was no doubt in my mind that I'd be taking my treatment to Boston.
I called Dana Farber the day I got my biopsy results (there was a bit more urgency in my case given my results) and got appts scheduled with a radiation oncologist, a medical oncologist and a urologist/surgeon. I appreciated that team approach and wanting to make sure you talk to different specialists to get different points of view. I later sought out second opinions, meeting with an RO, MO and Uro at MGH, where they even gave my pathology a fresh read (and graded me G8 whereas Dana Farber had me at G7, but at the hairy edge of G8 territory) -- given those two reads and the particulars of my case, I decided I didn't need to send my slides to Dr. Epstein but I was prepared to do so and would recommend you get his take as well. The bottom line analysis and recommended options from each of Dana Farber and MGH were basically the same.
By the time I made a treatment decision, I think I'd met with 3 Uro surgeons (including the open surgeon at MGH -- he was great and I would've gone with him if surgery could've been scheduled during peak Covid last spring), 2 ROs and 2 MOs, at MGH and Dana Farber/Brigham & Women's.
We do have a lot of great choices in Boston -- and one choice need not foreclose the possibility of soliciting other opinions at different institutions! (I was lucky and my insurance didn't balk at my appts)
Keep asking questions and doing your diligence!
53 @ Dx 1/24/20
PSA: 13.3 12/19, 12.2 10/19 (first ever test)
MpMRI 1/20: Pirads4, EPE/SVI- (not seen), prostate volume 23cc
Biopsy 1/16/20: G4+3, 10/14 cores all left side, up to 100% involvement (with 90% G4), PNI+
Bone/CT Scans 2/20: inconclusive
Axumin PET scan 2/20: clear
RALP 4/20 (~peak Covid)
Post-RP Path: G 4+3 (90% Pattern 4), EPE-, SVI-, margins-, pT2 N0
PSA 5/20:<0.04
PSA 11/20:<0.04
Yes, radiation does come in a lot of flavors if you go that route. And it often means talking to multiple ROs for each type. SBRT and HDR brachy would be good places to start if you're looking to make that decision a bit easier. And for surgery, you obviously want the most experienced surgeon you can find.
Good luck to you--your chances of successful treatment are very good.
Age 60, Diagnosed at 51
PSA 9.6, Gleason: 9 (5+4), three 7s (3+4)
Chose triple play of HDR brachy, IMRT and ADT (Casodex, Lupron and Zytiga)
Completed ADT (18 months) in April 2014
9/20: PSA = 0.03
I never paid for anything (other than some drug copays) in my PCa journey with Medicare and a full coverage Blue Cross Medicare supplement package which included a pre-biopsy MRI, Epstein second opinion, and Decipher genomic testing. Not sure how TriCare works with Medicare so the older Vets will have to help with that.
On the other hand, Medicare Advantage plans are a different story and may have different networks and reimbursement systems. You also to get to deal with insurance companies vs. Medicare. Most do not have a problem with second opinions in concept but can be more difficult if they come from non-network providers and are covered differently.
7/2018-66yr, PSA 4.1->5.1
8/2018-MRI PI-RADS 5, MRI guided biopsy, 8/14 cores, G7(4+3)
9/2018-CT/Bone scans clear
11/6/18-RALP Surgery
11/2018-Post-Op Path G7(4+3)5% Tert Gr 5, pT3a pN0 Gr 3
Marg(SM+), EPE, <3mm, L=0.1mm?
11/2018-Decipher 0.47, Ave Risk
1/2019-Epstein-G9(4+5) Gr5, pT2x, margin vs. incision not clear
4-6/2019 ART 37 day
PSA<0.10: 2/19, 5/19, 8/19, 11/19, 2/20, 6/20, 9/20, 3/21
What's interesting to me is that difference centers have different "feels" to them. It has nothing to do with competence, and everything to do with the so-called soft skills. When I think back, even at the time I felt like one of the most important people on my treatment team when I went through surgery was the staffer who brought food. He apologized in the morning when he brought me cream of wheat and apple juice (he did make sure I had several of those little margarine packets to make it palatable)--and promised me something good for lunch if I was off dietary restrictions (he did).
Kind of a long winded answer to the "how do I choose where to go" question. You'll know you're in the right hand when you meet them. Really.
Age at Diagnosis: 56
RALP on 2/17/15, BJC St. Louis, Dr. Figenshau
58.5g, G3+4, 20%, 4 quadrants involved
PSA Non-Detect since April, 2015
My Story: www.healingwell.com/community/default.aspx?f=35&m=3300024
Diagnosed in February 2011 at 47
Clinical Report: PSA 3.7 Gleason 7, 3+3 and 3+4, T2C, 8 out 12 cores positive
Davinci Robotic Surgery in August 2011
Path Report: pT3a, 4+3,
Negative Lymph Nodes, Margins and Vesicles
Undetectable PSA since at <0.03 until Aug 2018 0.04,
Jan 2019 0.05, April 2019 0.06, July 2019 0.07, Jan 2020 0.09
July 2020 0.11, Sept 2020 0.15,
Dec 2020 .2
Jan 2021 0.18
Post Edited (kwoo64) : 4/21/2021 7:27:06 AM (GMT-6)
"Davinci Robotic Surgery in August 2011" can become "RALP 8/11"
Dates in general can be shortened, e.g. 1/19 0.05, 4/19 0.06...
"Path Report: pT3a, 4+3, no radiation
Negative Lymph Nodes, Margins and Vesicles"
can be shorten to "pT3a N0, SM-, SVI-, EPE+, no RT"
(If it comes after mention of surgery, it will be understood to be the surgery path report. I added "EPE+" assuming you had, but forgot to mention, extraprostatic extension, since your path staging was pT3a.)
Consolidation will leave you space to add new info as you like. Signature shortening is an art form unto itself.
Djin
69 yr at Dx, BPH x 20 yr, 9 (!) neg. Bx
2013 TURP for BPH (90-->30 g) no PCa
6-6-17 Nodule (R) + PSA on finasteride: 3.6-->4.3
Bx #10: 2/14 cores: G10 (5+5) 50% RB, G9 (4+5) 3% RLM, nodule neg
Bone scan, CTs: neg, 8-7-17 open RP @Duke, neg frozen sections, nerves spared
SM EPE BNI LVI SVI LNI(16): neg, PNI+, pT2c pN0 R0 MX, G9 (4+5) 5%, 64 g
Decipher 0.37 Low Risk, PSA 0.010 (3m)…0.020 (3y 7m)
Post Edited (DjinTonic) : 4/21/2021 7:09:02 AM (GMT-6)
Between Mass General and Dana Farber, you have two of the best Prostate Cancer centers in the world, so you can't go wrong. Get on their websites, read everything, and inspect physician's CV's. Talk to surgeons and radiologists. I believe, early on, most of us have a predisposition for which of the two equally successful treatments we prefer. If your gut is telling you radiation, then there is lots more digging and interviews needed to select the best option FOR YOU. The variables can be daunting, but don't let that stop you. As others have said, the fog will clear.
In my opinion, the Walsh's textbook is the bible, since he gives every treatment fair evaluation, and he has had every specialty working for him. "Invasion of the Prostate Snatchers" as the title implies, is far from balanced, and was written by a radiation proponent, who owns a very costly private clinic in Marina Dey Ray. If you want to call and talk to a physician there, it's a minimum of $800, and NOT covered by Medicare or Tricare.
He did publish a somewhat better book, some eight years later, 'The Key to Prostate Cancer', which includes the remarks of many PCa "experts". For me, it stills reads like an infomercial, but is worth reading, and while strongly opinionated, the author does know his stuff.
You do have time, but don't dilly-dally, and best of luck.
Ulcerative Colitis since 1973
TURP 2/16
4 cores; G 3+3, one G3+4
RALP 7/17 G3+4 Organ confined
pT2c pNO pMn/a
PSA .54 4 months post RR
ercMRI & DCFPyL PET Scan @ NIH/NCI
1" tumor at apex,
IMGT 70.2 GY, 2ADT, over 5/18
Radiation proctitis & UC flared
PSA .054 11/18, .070 12/18, .067 2/19, .074 7/19, .081 9/19, .116 11/19, .066 1/20, .074 3/20, .059 6/20, .077 9/20, .099 11/20, .075 1/21, .079 4/21
Post Edited (garyi) : 4/21/2021 9:37:36 AM (GMT-6)
Want to welome you to the forum but sorry that find a need to be here
Since i am on AS cant speak fro experience from other treatment options there are othets here who would be far better than i
Anywsy cause of youre high tumor loading and the presence of pattern 4 i would recommend against AS
You do have time to research and investigate options. Modt mainstream treatments are equally effective so its about sideeffects, recovery, and monitoring
Discuss with others here about their experience. Also really important is the experience of those treating you. Out of curiosity did u get mri and what % is the pattern 4
Age 67, 67 at DX, born 1951
PSA-2/18-4.3,8/18-3.5,9/18-3.7,12/18-3.3,6/19-3.1,9/19-3.5,1/20-3.2,3/20-3.3,5/20-4.2,6/20
biopsy 1/12, G(3+3)6,5%/0.5mm, Apex
MRI(6/18) pirads2,no dom lesion
MRI((1/20) pirads 2 no donin lesion,heterogeneous perif zone
oncotype GPS-31/very low risk/advers path 16%/Higrade disease-10%/non organ confine desease 8%/ Met(10yr)-1%
TX-AS,3 month PSA, annual biopsy/MRI
I agree that "Invasion of the Prostate Snatchers" and "Keys to Prostate Cancer" by Scholz give you the extra balance you need to offset Walsh's book which, while excellent and detailed, has a surgical slant in my opinion.
Good luck. Stick with us and we will help you through this.
Jim
Forum Moderator-Prostate Cancer. Age 62 (74 now), G 3 + 4 = 7, T1C, PSA 4.2, 2/16 cancerous, 27cc. Brachytherapy 12/9/08. 73 Iodine-125 seeds. Everything continues to function normally. PSA: 6 mo: 1.4, 1 yr: 1.0, 2 yr: .8, 3 yr: .5, 4/5 yr: .2, 6-12 yr: <1. My docs are "delighted"! My journey:
http://www.healingwell.com/community/default.aspx?f=35&m=1305643&g=1305643#m1
In terms of sequencing the biopsy reviews (my brother told me that MGH wanted to see the slides to make their own call) but not dallying, do you guys think I am better going to Epstein first or waiting? I would think that his view would be objective - he has no skin in this game whereas the other two do have an interest? I am being paranoid here?
Looks like AS is going the way of the Do-Do bird. I was seeing some light last evening looking at Scholz website but now, I am not so sure - almost sounds too good to be true the ay he talks. Looking at Scholz website, I agree with the commenter that his stuff looks like infomercial type presentation. I will still look at his books just to balance Walsh's views.
As for % G4 in the 3=4 samples - it was not on the biopsy report and there has been no MRI done. Also appreciate the insurance comments.
Thank You All!!
Also, a mild word of defense for Scholz. I've been a patient at Prostate Oncology Specialists for 8+ years, although Scholz is not my doc there. It was by far the best and most helpful part of PC journey. (That said, I was only so-so on his book.)
Age 60, Diagnosed at 51
PSA 9.6, Gleason: 9 (5+4), three 7s (3+4)
Chose triple play of HDR brachy, IMRT and ADT (Casodex, Lupron and Zytiga)
Completed ADT (18 months) in April 2014
9/20: PSA = 0.03
Requested appointments at Dana Farber (DFCI) and Mass General Prostate Centers (MGH) and waiting to hear back. Also, coordinating with Dr. Epstein's lab and my local hospital to get the slides down to him.
Researching doctors at these two centers while waiting on the appointments. Several folks mentioned DFCI in their responses,. If you went to either of these places, which Drs. did you work with? Any you rejected?
Also, aside from the biopsy, should i be seeking any other diagnostic tests before making a treatment decision?
Thanks!
PC DX 4/5/21, Age 69 (born 1951)
PSA 3.74 3/9/21
Biopsy - 4/12 positive - 2 cores 3+3; 20% and 50%; 2 cores 3+4 40% and 50%; right lateral and base
Djin
69 yr at Dx, BPH x 20 yr, 9 (!) neg. Bx
2013 TURP for BPH (90-->30 g) no PCa
6-6-17 Nodule (R) + PSA on finasteride: 3.6-->4.3
Bx #10: 2/14 cores: G10 (5+5) 50% RB, G9 (4+5) 3% RLM, nodule neg
Bone scan, CTs: neg, 8-7-17 open RP @Duke, neg frozen sections, nerves spared
SM EPE BNI LVI SVI LNI(16): neg, PNI+, pT2c pN0 R0 MX, G9 (4+5) 5%, 64 g
Decipher 0.37 Low Risk, PSA 0.010 (3m)…0.020 (3y 7m)
No treatment is without some issues for some (or many) people. I like the above suggestions for SBRT or HDR brachy for your pathology. But, the best scenario for you at this time is the multi-disciplinary consultation.
DOB: May 1944
In Active Surveillance program at Johns Hopkins
Strict protocol of tests, including PHI, DRE, MRI, and biopsy.
Seven biopsies from 2009 to 2021. Numbers 1, 2, 5, and 7 were negative. Numbers 3,4, and 6 were positive with 5% Gleason(3+3) found. Last one was Precision Point transperineal.
PSA has varied over the years. Is 5.2 as of March 2021.
Hopefully, I can remain treatment free.
JoeBos said...
@Michael_T - thanks. I am reading Scholtz second book and given it has sections by different experts, it does provide different perspectives on the issues.
Requested appointments at Dana Farber (DFCI) and Mass General Prostate Centers (MGH) and waiting to hear back. Also, coordinating with Dr. Epstein's lab and my local hospital to get the slides down to him.
Researching doctors at these two centers while waiting on the appointments. Several folks mentioned DFCI in their responses,. If you went to either of these places, which Drs. did you work with? Any you rejected?
Also, aside from the biopsy, should i be seeking any other diagnostic tests before making a treatment decision?
Thanks!
Joe, here's who I met with--all of whom I had plenty of confidence in and good to great degrees of comfort:
DFCI: Paul Nguyen, RO; Hmisha Beltran, MO; Adam Kibel, Uro
MGH: Jason Efstathiou, RO; Matthew Smith, MO; Francis McGovern, Uro
Once I decided on surgery, I ended up having my RALP done by Dr Kibel, and he was excellent -- absolutely no regrets at all -- though I might have gone with Dr. McGovern if Covid hadn't been a scheduling factor, as McGovern felt like a warm, old school, top notch doc that I clicked with. That said, Kibel (urology chief at the Brigham) was fantastic and similarly well-experienced in doing these surgeries (which as you know is critical). The others I met with with were similarly all top notch in my estimation and as per my research.
One surprising find, for me, was that I could begin to develop a sense of some of these folks by searching them out on YouTube. Weird to conduct important medical research on YouTube, but I searched out information wherever I could. For instance, I found some long symposium videos put out by DFCI to be really helpful -- e.g., their 2019 sympsosium at Brigham & Women's. If you're interested, to find it try search terms like: DFCI prostate cancer Kibel, D'amico, and Pomerantz. I would love to meet Drs. D'Amico and Pomerantz.
53 @ Dx 1/24/20
PSA: 13.3 12/19, 12.2 10/19 (first ever test)
MpMRI 1/20: Pirads4, EPE/SVI- (not seen), prostate volume 23cc
Biopsy 1/16/20: G4+3, 10/14 cores all left side, up to 100% involvement (with 90% G4), PNI+
Bone/CT Scans 2/20: inconclusive
Axumin PET scan 2/20: clear
RALP 4/20 (~peak Covid)
Post-RP Path: G 4+3 (90% Pattern 4), EPE-, SVI-, margins-, pT2 N0
PSA 5/20:<0.04
PSA 11/20:<0.04