Now it’s my time to sweat it I suppose

I can’t believe I’m actually ending up posting here for information on detectable PSA since I was one of those overtreated Gleason 6s whose PSA went to undetectable after surgery 11 years ago. I just found out that my annual PSA came in at .05. After seeing the post on the man in his 70s and your opinions on his options I wonder if there is anything else you can add. Many of those years of undetectable PSA were with the old test that registered at <.1 but the last few years was at the .00 scale. This test also was done this year by the urologist not the endocrinologist who converted to the .00 scale for the first time. Again I was told by urologist the past 2 years it was psa <.1
As you can see below I was Gleason 6+6 in 2 cores on right , < 5 and <15% respectively. Should I stop TRT which is maintaining my T levels in low normal range? I use to think guys with small upticks in psa were overreacting, I’m not sure anymore, repeat psa in 6 months?
My age= 52 at time of diagnosis
DRE=negative,
PSA went from 1.9 to 2.85 in one year, biopsy ordered,
2 cores positive, one 5%,one 25% G=6
Bilateral nerve sparing robotic surgery on 09/11/08, pathological stage T2A,
No signs of spread, organ confined,
all PSA'S 0 since surgery, diagnosed with low T, doing TRT now, still using trimix for ED
it's easy to call it "overreacting" till it happens to you. my gut feeling is you wont need further treatment but I think testing every six months is wise and maybe seeing an RO. good luck and sorry you are in this situation (which is my greatest fear).
age - 64
12/09 - PSA 6.8
G7 - 3+4 - all 12 cores pos
HT, BT, IGRT
6/18 - 8-year post treatment PSA .1!
PSAs .2, .3, .2, .3, .2, .1, .2, .2, .1, .1, .1, .1, .1

"..You get braver as your options dwindle.." -- Fairwind

https://instagram.com/edraderphotography/

mspt98 said...
Should I stop TRT which is maintaining my T levels in low normal range?



First, a confirmatory uPSA in the next month or so would be good. Your .05 all of a sudden seems unusual.

That aside...this is a tough one, because if you are only in low normal T range *with* TRT, then won't you go way down almost into castrate T range *without* TRT? And that will be tough to take.

Morgentaler's saturation theory says that PSA is exquisitely sensitive to T levels in the castrate range, but not at all above that range. So I guess if you did stop TRT, within a few months you would probably see your PSA stabilize or start down. If during that time, your uPSAs still trended up fast, you should probably start talking to a good RO and making plans. You should run all this by your doc.

I can tell you what has happened with me, twice, though it does not follow the "theory". While on T-cyp injections, my uPSA rose to .05 in Dec. I stopped the shots, and my monthly uPSAs started falling and have leveled at .036, .035 and .035 the last three months. I did this type of "trial" in 2017, too, with same results.

Here is my chart:

https://imgur.com/vaqv1hh

I have run across a couple other guys on different PCa boards that seem to have the same response as I have. We are all left wondering "what's going on?"

Might run it by your doctor. But, yeah, if you really are now in the .05 range, I would stop the TRT for a few months, maybe three or four, and watch your uPSAs at monthly intervals. But that's just the opinion of a non-medical person in the same boat as you.

For me, though, I am at the point of being too scared to continue TRT. Forever, I guess.

Robert
69 now
Jan '08-'11 PSAs 2.2 2.5 2.7 2.6, DREs-
Jan '12: PSA 3.6, DRE+
Jan '12: MRI inconclusive
Feb '12: PCaDx pT2a, 4/12+ (3 @ 3+3, 1 @ 4+3); 3% tot cores; bone scan-
Apr '12: RALP; 3+4=7; pT2c pN0 pMx; 30%; 3mm r lat margin of 3+3=6 so pT2+; EPE-; PNI+; 8 LN-; SV-
TRT 03/'14- uPSAs: <.015 til 02/17; mostly .020-.030 then .048 on 12/1/18; off TRT since 12/2018 and uPSA settling in mid .030s

Post Edited (Bobbiesan) : 4/24/2019 12:37:57 PM (GMT-6)

Sorry...but what's the problem?

Are you asking about a PSA value of 0.05 ng/mL? Maybe I read something wrong, but that's a great post-surgery score (immediately after surgery, or years later).

Again, maybe I missed something, but I don't see any reason to do anything different (except the old rule-of-thumb to have PSA tests done consistently by the same lab, because otherwise a little up-and-down is quite predictable).

Post Edited (Blackjack) : 4/24/2019 12:29:28 PM (GMT-6)

Another question -- even if the T is moving your PSA up to a detectable level, why stop the T? You would have to get your T down to somewhere less than 20 ng/Mmol (right measure?) in order for it to be effective. Your body might still produce that much T, and if it did, your cessation of the external T would be for naught.

Another way to look at it is that you don't need to stop your external T unless your PCa gets to a point where ADT is standard of care. Until then, neither your body nor your PCa can tell the difference between the T made by your body and that which you buy at the pharmacy.
Age 68 at Dx
PSA history: 2000-2012 0.9-1.2; 06/2012 started T replacement
2013-2015 3.0-3.3 (new normal); 11/2015 4.6; 05/2016 5.7
Biopsy: 12-core biopsy 07/2016; 3 cores G3+3, 5% or less; 1 core 3+4, 15%; 1 core HGPIN; 2% of gland involved. Summary G3+4.
CyberKnife SBRT with Dr. Hirsch; start 11/15/16, finish 11/23
F8, thanks for the encouraging words, 11 years after a Gleason 6 with negative margins and now detectable psa?

Bobbesian, good point about the low T without TRT, my recent total T and free T was 252/47, certainly at bottom of normal even with supplementation

Blackjack, Yes I may be overreacting, I have a history of that,

Paxton, another good point my nadir without T was a total T of 176, what would a little more T matter if receptors saturated already

I guess I’ll call up endocrinologist and see what he says, he said everything was fine over the phone but I didn’t get the actual number from mychart until today
My age= 52 at time of diagnosis
DRE=negative,
PSA went from 1.9 to 2.85 in one year, biopsy ordered,
2 cores positive, one 5%,one 25% G=6
Bilateral nerve sparing robotic surgery on 09/11/08, pathological stage T2A,
No signs of spread, organ confined,
all PSA'S 0 since surgery, diagnosed with low T, doing TRT now, still using trimix for ED