Bill's dad has come to stay with him for a few days. It's 11 PM one night, nearing dad's bedtime, but Bill notices that something's not quite right with dad this evening.
Bill says:
BILL: Dad, you seem to be moving a little slower thls evening, and I honestly believe your speech is getting a little bit slurred. Are you all right?
DAD: Huh? No, I'm fine. I'm just a little tired, that's all.
BILL: No, really, dad, I'm getting concerned that you may starting to have a serious issue here. Maybe we should take you to the ER, and get you checked out, just to be safe? I can drive you over there right now.
DAD: NO! I'm not going to any ER! I'm fine! I'm just going to go to bed now, and I'm sure I'll feel much better in the morning. LEAVE ME ALONE!
So, is dad beginning to have a stroke, or is it something less serious?
Clearly the only way to tell is for him to go into that ER now and get the tests that will answer that question for sure, one way or the other.
But if Bill's dad simply refuses to cooperate, refuses to go to the ER, what is Bill to do?
It may be tempting just to leave dad alone, as he wishes, and he goes to bed. But if it really is something serious, then of course delay could be very damaging to him or even fatal.
A web literature search reveals that there are a number of articles addressing this problem when it arises, and the advice rendered covers two areas: medical decision and legal responsibility.
But some reading I did also indicated to me that there is a common caregiver/EMT response pattern to this situation, and one that a good many localities follow, one that goes something like this:
1. As caregiver, try everything you can think of, short of physical force, to convince the person to go voluntarily to the hospital. If he does finally agree, use judgment as to whether you can drive him there safely and in a short time in your own vehicle, or whether an ambulance will need to be called.
2. Do NOT try to use physical force to compel person into your car, to be driven to the hospital by you. The resulting stress, strain and trauma that will occur to the person if you attempt to do this may actually worsen the physical impairment that he is experiencing. And even if you do manage to get him into the car and leave for the ER, he may become combative while on the way, possibly causing a seriously significant driving distraction, even a safety hazard as you drive along. And, curiously, after this is all over and hopefully calm has been restored, he could later possibly even bring charges against you for assault, if he is angry enough about it.
3. If he is still refusing to cooperate, call 911, but explain to them BOTH that he may be having a serious medical crisis, AND that he is being uncooperative. Most 911 services have contingency plans in place for this situation, and when the EMTs arrive in a few minutes, they will evaluate the situation. They will determine whether (a) emergency transport to the ER is not essential, and they will leave if the person is still uncooperative, or (b) emergency transport to the ER really IS essential. In that case, if he remains uncooperative, they will contact the local police for assistance in authorizing emergency medical transport of the person.
4, When the police arrive, they will assess whether existing legal authority governing emergency transport of noncompliant persons for medical reasons applies, and then put it into action if the decision is made that it does. On this matter, from a legal website:
"The truth is that a person who is of sound mind has the right to refuse medical treatment. If a senior is competent and capable of informed decision-making, they can manage their own health in any way they choose, so long as they do not pose an immediate threat to their community. This means that family caregivers cannot force their loved ones to seek out or receive medical treatments, even if doing so would improve their health and quality of life. Seniors who have their mental faculties have the right to make decisions about their own medical care, even if we'd consider those decisions to be poor ones."
But also, from another legal site:
"In general, a patient is permitted to refuse medical assistance and if they do, providers cannot force the patient to accept any services. However, there are exceptions to this rule such as when the patient is unconscious, a minor, intoxicated or mentally incompetent. In those situations the patient cannot legally refuse medical assistance so the decision of whether to treat or provide services belongs to the EMTs and/or the police." (Boldface mine).
5. Several sites noted that if noncompliant emergency transport, now authorized by the police, is seen as warranted, this is frequently accomplished by administering a strong sedative to the person, who is then taken gently and carefully to the ambulance and transported to the hospital for diagnosis and observation.
NOTE: the above multi-step procedure is a general model formed from reading on their websites what various places do. Local procedures, as where you are for example, may of course vary.
But if you do have concerns that there is even a chance that the above awful scenario might occur someday with a loved one under your roof, it could be helpful now to investigate how to deal with it in your community if it ever does come up.
Perhaps contacting local agencies such as hospitals, local health departments, EMT services, and the like, would be a good move. Describe the above situation as a hypothetical, and learn what they have in place to deal with it.
While you're at it, it would also be good to review your loved one's medical insurance, to make sure things like ambulance service are covered, for example.
One final question I found asked a number of times on sites during my reading: some people were concerned about the possibility of being looked at for a possible charge of neglect for failing to take action, if they gave in and agreed to the person's refusal to go to the ER, let them go to bed, but then the person died later that night.
A couple of legal websites I saw stated that the odds were that it was unlikely that an eventual prosecution for some kind of neglect would occur in this kind of situation, unless there were some very unusual circumstances. The doctrine that, generally, a person has the right to refuse medical treatment was held up as pretty strong, and one the courts were likely to respect in most cases.
But of course there would always be an easy way to avoid this possible legal dilemma. Just call 911. When the EMTs arrive, the responsibility of making that decision becomes theirs.
But it's important to remember that if the authorities determine that the person is legally capable of making his own decision in this matter, then he cannot be forced to receive medical treatment, even if the consequences of not doing so may likely be dire.
Hopefully none of us will ever have to face such a crisis as we have been talking about above, but if we ever do, thinking about it now, ahead of time, could give us an edge if it ever does, unfortunately, happen to us.
Age: 76
Chronic prostatitis (age 60 on)
BPH w/ urinary obstruction, 6/2011
TURP, 7/2011
Ongoing high PSA, 7/2011-12/2011
Biopsy, 12/2011: positive 3/12 (90%, 70%, 5%)
Gleason 6(3+3), T1c
No mets, PCa likely still organ contained
IMRT w/ HT (Lupron), 4/2012-6/2012
PSAs (since post-IMRT): 0.1 to 0.3 range
Post Edited (81GyGuy) : 6/13/2022 7:50:16 AM (GMT-6)