Prostate Cancer Forum is second most active here on Healingwell

One of the more interesting features here on Healingwell is the list of all the different diseases and medical conditions forums that are available on this website for viewing and posting.

If you go to the PCa forum index screen, and then click on "Support Forums" at top of the screen, you are taken to a list of 32 "Diseases and Conditions" followed by the number of posts that people have made to them so far, effective today.

Out of curiosity, I did copy-and-paste on the screen, put it on a Wordpad screen, and then rearranged the diseases and conditions below by number of posts made to them, which shows that the PCa forum is second only to Ulcerative Colitis in posting activity.

Not that this is a contest, but it is interesting to see the distribution of participation here, and just how much difference in posting (and I would also assume participation) there is among the 32 diseases and conditions. So far our PCa forum is, as noted, the second most active among the 32 diseases and conditions.

I was especially surprised to see that posting on the Breast Cancer forum is only 25183 (16th out of the 32) compared to PCa's second place of 467431 posts. As to why that may be, I'm going to hazard a guess that the women prefer personal, face-to-face interactions when discussing BC, and do not find the anonymity and objectivity of the keyboard-driven forums here on Healingwell appealing.

But, still, I remain a bit suprised that we are almost leading the pack in terms of forum participation for our particular ailment. Maybe it's because we find the format useful, faceless as it is, easy to use, and our fellow posters generally cordial?

If you have any other theories as to why our PCa forum is so active compared to the others, feel free to post them below.

As for the number one forum, Ulcerative Colitis, which outnumbers our PCa forum by almost 65000 posts, there is obviously a need among a good number of people for information on that disease, and we certainly hope they find it here as well as we have found out good information on PCa.

Current standings, by number of posts:

Ulcerative Colitis 532109
Prostate Cancer 467431
Lyme Disease 442291
Crohn's Disease 273591
Anxiety & Panic Disorders 225311
Depression 161378
Chronic Pain 159889
Fibromyalgia 151610
GERD & Acid Reflux 118914
Ostomies 111166
Hepatitis 68333
Lupus 58369
Bipolar Disorder 48485
Irritable Bowel Syndrome 40374
Rheumatoid Arthritis 37441
Breast Cancer 25183
Diabetes 24243
Heart & Cardiovascular Disease 23879
Migraines & Headaches 22515
Multiple Sclerosis 22328
Allergies & Asthma 18679
Alzheimer's Disease 8673
Chronic Fatigue Syndrome 8480
Epilepsy 8404
Thyroid Disorders 6779
Parkinson's Disease 6293
Osteoarthritis 4968
Cystic Fibrosis 3430
Kidney Diseases & Disorders 2529
Celiac Disease 2200
Sjogren's Syndrome 2032
Psoriasis 1408
Age: 73
Chronic prostatitis (age 60 on)
BPH w/ urinary obstruction, 6/2011
TURP, 7/2011
Ongoing high PSA, 7/2011-12/2011
Biopsy, 12/2011: positive 3/12 (90%, 70%, 5%)
Gleason 6(3+3), T1c
No mets, PCa likely still organ contained
IMRT w/ HT (Lupron), 4/2012-6/2012
PSAs (since post-IMRT): 0.1 to 0.3 range

Post Edited (81GyGuy) : 10/28/2019 10:56:57 AM (GMT-6)

I have also commented in the past my surprise for low number of breast cancer posts, as well as the large participation with Lyme disease. I didn't know that Lyme disease is apparently so common.
Part I
2015 (Age 54) PSA: 20.8
Bx: All cores G7 (4+3)
RALP & Adjuvant RT
Pathology: G8 (4+4)+5
PSA nadir: 0.1, steady increase until 2019: 64.13

Part II
2019, March: Lupron/Xtandi, PSA: 1 month: 0.126; 3 months: 0.036; 6 months: <0.02
Wow, last place. The heartbreak of psoriasis.
I'm betting that the reason BC has so few is that in general, women have other women to talk with.

They will talk to their BFFs without need for a forum, but I'll be darned if I talk to my best buds about such intimate stuff.

GoBucks said...
Wow, last place. The heartbreak of psoriasis.



LOL!!!!!!!!!!!

My Biopsy
My PSA Curve
Previous PSA
Curve

Treatment Path
My Story
You're probably right Alepnull. Guys, including me, want to talk about guy stuff with other guys. In person, I don't want to talk about PCa with guys who don't have PCa. I'm grateful for the anonymity of the internet, or I wouldn't be talking about PCa at all. Talking is second only to humor as the best medicine. Even on this forum we're probably reserved about exposing our "feelings." But hey, we're guys, we don't really do that. So what?

HW members are probably in the great minority of men, most of whom wouldn't dream of participating in a support forum.

Like Clint E disgustingly said, "What is this, an encounter group?" Lol
Part I
2015 (Age 54) PSA: 20.8
Bx: All cores G7 (4+3)
RALP & Adjuvant RT
Pathology: G8 (4+4)+5
PSA nadir: 0.1, steady increase until 2019: 64.13

Part II
2019, March: Lupron/Xtandi, PSA: 1 month: 0.126; 3 months: 0.036; 6 months: <0.02

Post Edited (mattam) : 10/28/2019 1:51:11 PM (GMT-6)

10,000 + of those posts are mine.

You're welcome ...
I'll be in the shop.
Age 59, 52 at DX
PSA:
4.2 10/11, 1.9 6/12, 1.2 12/12, 1.0 5/13, .6 11/13,
.7 5/14, .5 10/14, .5 4/15, .3 10/15, .3 4/16, .4 10/16, .4 5/17, .3 10/17 .3 4/18, .4 11/18
G 3+4
Stage T1C
2 out of 14 cores positive
Treatment IGRT - 2/2012
ITS,
You have more posts than 11 of the forums. I don't know what that means - if anything. Too much time on your hands? πŸ˜‰πŸ˜

mattam said...
ITS,
You have more posts than 11 of the forums. I don't know what that means - if anything. Too much time on your hands? πŸ˜‰πŸ˜



πŸ˜‚πŸ˜‚πŸ˜‚

What has always amazed me is a relatively few posts and how little activity there is on the heart disease forum.
I am not a doctor, just another guy without a prostate
Dx Age 64 Nov 2014, PSA 4.3
BX 3 of 12 cores positive original pathology G6
RALP with Dr Ash Tewari Jan 6, 2015
Post surgical pathology G7 (3+4), - ECE, - Margins, -LN, -SV (+ frozen section apex converted to negative)
PSA @ 6 weeks 2/15, .<02, remained <0.02 until January 2017, .02, repeat Feb 2017, still .02. May 2017-.033, August 2017- .033 November .046, March 2018 .060. June 2018 .068, July 2018 - .082, August 2018, .078, August 2018 - .08 Start ADT. Sept 2018 Start SRT
Sept 2018 thru November 2018 – T = 4, PSA = <.05
Decipher test, low risk, .37 score
My story.... tinyurl.com/qgyu3xq

mattam said...
ITS,
You have more posts than 11 of the forums. I don't know what that means - if anything. Too much time on your hands? πŸ˜‰πŸ˜



That's glue on my hands, not time ... ;)
Remember that the stats you grabbed reflect the summation of activity over the years since 2003 or so, which almost renders them useless. Some of these (like Sjogren's) were only added about 6 years ago, so putting them in a list that includes those that existed at the beginning isn't fair. You'd have to chart activity by year in order to draw any meaningful conclusions.

In the past, many of the forums that are mostly inactive the last 5-6 years were WAY ahead of PC in activity. Healing Well was among the first online forums of it's kind, diseases like Lupus and Lyme were not really mentioned much anywhere else. Heart disease at HW never had much activity, probably because it was so well supported elsewhere.
Lynnwood, Dx: 2000, Found HW 2005, HW Lupus/Sjogren's Moderator May 2006-May 2018
DIAGNOSING LUPUS & HW's LUPUS 101

"Life is far too important to be taken seriously." - Oscar Wilde
My ex wife, who has a recurrence of breast cancer had the hardest time finding any worthwhile forums on the subject. You would think that some of the bigger names in the treatment or research of breast cancer, like Susan B. Komen, would have a great website or forum. Any forums she did find were usually barely used, with very little activity or members.
Age at Dx. 63. PSA 12/16 12.4
GS 9 (4+5)
1/17 CT Scan & bone scan, negative
2/2/17 prostate MRI.
2/27/17 pelvic bone biopsy done. No mets
3/7/17 Triple play w/HT. Degarelix, 4/17 lupron (18 months)
7/7/17 LDR Brachy (Zelefsky MSK)
8/25/17 SHARP (SBRT) MSK
7/18/18 last lupron
PSA 1/08 1.4, 12/16 12.4, 4/17 3.8 (HT), 7/17 1.05 (HT), 10/17 <.05 (HT), 1/18 <0.05 (HT), 4/18 <.05 (HT) T=7, 7/18 <.05 (HT) T=6, (off lupron), 10/18 <.05 T=6, 2/19 <.05 T=57, 6/19 <.05 T=156
Lynnwood -

Yeah, I kinda wondered as I was starting this thread whether there were some factors such as the ones you mention that might effect the significance of these figures. Thank you for your clarifications.

But I would still suppose that, being what the figures are, there must be some reason(s) why there is such a sharp disparity between the ones at the top of the list (hundreds of thousands of posts) and 20-something thousands of posts or fewer for those in the middle of the list or lower. I mean, for example, if we were to graph the forums, there would be such a sharp drop-off after the first few at the top.

I'm certainly no statistician, but even if we do allow for adjustment of the data to allow for "timing," shall we call it, that is, as you suggest, how long forums have been active on Healingwell, and over what time periods, is the controlling factor, I'm still surprised at the large postings differences apparent in the list.

And it would also seem to be some factor other than frequency of the diseases/conditions themselves in life. As mattam points out, why did Lyme Disease have so many posts, or Crohn's Disease for that matter, when surely things such as Heart Disease (as Pratoman points out) and Depression are much more common, but had distinctly fewer posts?

Do people with Lyme Disease or Crohn's Disease make special efforts, more than others, to learn about their disease? It wouldn't seem so.

Is there a way we can determine more precisely what's going on here? Would timing alone make for such differences? I know we have some mathematics and statistics types here on the forum, so perhaps one of them could offer some insight as to what it all means?

But, again, thank you for your observations.
Age: 73
Chronic prostatitis (age 60 on)
BPH w/ urinary obstruction, 6/2011
TURP, 7/2011
Ongoing high PSA, 7/2011-12/2011
Biopsy, 12/2011: positive 3/12 (90%, 70%, 5%)
Gleason 6(3+3), T1c
No mets, PCa likely still organ contained
IMRT w/ HT (Lupron), 4/2012-6/2012
PSAs (since post-IMRT): 0.1 to 0.3 range
A possible contributing factor?

No subject (Part 5)
View Page : 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10
All HW forums should take note of our novel and highly beneficial "nothing" thread. πŸ˜‰
Part I
2015 (Age 54) PSA: 20.8
Bx: All cores G7 (4+3)
RALP & Adjuvant RT
Pathology: G8 (4+4)+5
PSA nadir: 0.1, steady increase until 2019: 64.13

Part II
2019, March: Lupron/Xtandi, PSA: 1 month: 0.126; 3 months: 0.036; 6 months: <0.02
I would strongly suggest that the number of posts is less statistically significant than the number of people posting. People who are home-bound tend to post multiple times a day; people with ill-defined diseases post more about alternate therapies. Even as the only active moderator in Lupus for 12 years, my number-of-posts is low compared to many people. In the early days at HW, many of the back-and-forth posts you see today occurred in the chat rooms, thus isn't getting counted in your tally.

In general, I don't think these numbers relate to anything except how much space is in use on the server!
Lynnwood, Dx: 2000, Found HW 2005, HW Lupus/Sjogren's Moderator May 2006-May 2018
DIAGNOSING LUPUS & HW's LUPUS 101

"Life is far too important to be taken seriously." - Oscar Wilde
I wonder if there are other discussion boards available for some of the other chronic diseases. There are many, many people with diabetes, and it seems like a confusing topic that people would want to share information about. Perhaps there is another discussion board that absorbs most of the energy.
Age: 64
Diagnosed in July 2016 with G7 (4+3) & PNI
Surgery at Lenox Hill Hospital in NYC, 9/12/2016
Post-surgery pathology: G7 (3+4), with +SVI, +PSM, +EPE, and -LNI
Post-surgery PSA, 10/16: <.008; 12/16: 0.01; 6/17: 0.05
IMRT begun: July 18, 2017 (35 fractions)
Post-SRT PSA, 11/17: <.008; 1/18: <.008; 07/18: <.008; 11/18: <.01; 4/19: <.008; 8/19: <.008
"I didn't know that Lyme disease is apparently so common."

I would guess that is more a feature of the Internet than it being common.
Right prostate: Benign tissue
Left prostate: Prostatic adenocarcinoma, Gleason score 7 (4+3), 2 of 10 cores, 5% of total tissue sampled, Stage T1c, positive for PNI
66 Pd-103 seeds 3/13
PSAs: 4.76 5/12 - 4.23 8/12 - 3.98 10/12 - 4.9 2/13 - 2.9 6/13 - 2.7 11/13 - 1.31 3/14 - 1.07 7/14 - 0.69 10/14 - 1.6 3/15 - 2.0 6/15 - 0.64 8/15 - 0.68 4/16 - 0.16 11/16 - 0.12 6/17 - 0.12 6/18 - 0.04 6/19