Sourdough experiment

I decided to take the plunge and try some true sourdough bread today after a year of GF eating. I have done a lot if reading about sourdough and gluten intolerance.
There is a local bakery that makes only sourdough breads from local, organic wheat and they make bagels! So after I are my usual breakfast I had an eighth of a sourdough bagel (and some coffee too). I hope I don't regret eating this because it was delicious!
38 yrs old diagnosed with proctosigmoiditis 6/13/13
meds- 2 Lialda supplements: probiotics (1 GOL raw 100 billion 1 culturelle and 1 reuteri) 1 gram krill Oil, 5-500mg tabs psyllium husks and 1 tsp l-glutamine. Zyrtec for seasonal allergies as needed. Allergic to sulfites. Currently gluten/dairy free (except yogurt) and eating lots of RS (potato starch, green banana smoothie and various beans).
while I never have a problem finding enough things to eat, I wouldn't mind having some real bread once in a while - keep us up to speed on how it goes -

have fun and good eating :-)
This is another example of how I think some people's (not everyone's) gluten intolerance is actually a histamine intolerance. The symptoms often mimmick each other but they are actually two completely different things. Items high in histamines can lead to gluten intolerance symptoms, making a UC'rs UC worse. Any foods high in histamines can do this. Yeast is high in histamines so any product that has high yeast content will be high in histamines. The more yeast, the more histamines. Again, some people truly are gluten intolerant but some percentage of those who think they are gluten intolerant may actually be reacting to the histamines and not the actual gluten itself. For people where this is actually the real problem and want to address it by just going gluten free then that is their choice but for those that may want to investigate further you might be surprised that you may be able to eat a more expanded diet while taking DAO instead of following a very restrictive diet. If histamines actually are your problem then you will have a slightly different set of foods to be careful of, which could be beneficial information for your UC condition.
Pentasa(500mg) 2 pillsX2; VSL 1 pillX2; Prescrip Assist Probiotic 1 pill X 2;Vitamin D3;Grape seed extract 400mg X 2; Canasa as needed; DAO as needed due to dietary histamine intolerance

Gave me trouble: Robinul; Zymactive, Renew Life Probiotic 80 billion, Florastor
Soy- I will keep you guys updated. That crusty bagel was so good!
Gary- I have also thought about histamine issues, especially since I have had allergies my whole life (I even went through 6 years of allergy shots). The strange thing is that I use yeast when I make GF bread and it doesn't seem to bother me at all. I do have some DAO and I take it before eating strawberries for sure. Some high histamine foods do bother me if I don't take dao before I eat them. My allergist suggested eating high histamine foods along with tea to help lower the effects of the histamines.
39 yrs old diagnosed with proctosigmoiditis 6/13/13
meds- 2 Lialda supplements: probiotics (1 VSL3 cap, 1 culturelle and 1 reuteri) 1 gram krill Oil, 5-500mg tabs psyllium husks and 3/4 tsp l-glutamine. Zyrtec for seasonal allergies as needed. Allergic to sulfites. Currently gluten/dairy free (except yogurt) and eating lots of RS (potato starch, green banana smoothie and various beans).
I love fresh fruit. That may be the hardest thing I have had to adjust to since having UC, other than maybe having to cut down on nuts and high fiber breads. I love most all fruits and nuts and used to eat a lot of high fiber breads. I'm getting better this year at taking DAO before eating fruits. Even though I take DAO before all meals I usually didn't eat fruits with meals. They were always either a snack or a later dessert and I would never remember to take the DAO and would have immediate problems. This year I have eaten fresh fruits a few times and taken the DAO and I haven't had any problems. I love most all breads but sourdough is not one I have ever been fond of. My wife is from the San Francisco area where sourdough breads are like a religion. I hope it works out for you. I feel sorry for those that have such limited diets. UC sucks.
Pentasa(500mg) 2 pillsX2; VSL 1 pillX2; Prescrip Assist Probiotic 1 pill X 2;Vitamin D3;Grape seed extract 400mg X 2; Canasa as needed; DAO as needed due to dietary histamine intolerance

Gave me trouble: Robinul; Zymactive, Renew Life Probiotic 80 billion, Florastor
You feel sorry for those with limited diets? What an offensive and insensitive comment, but that is expecting coming from you.

I can eat whatever I want. Sugar, candy, sweets... you name it.

I can also eat all the pizza or sourdough bread in the world without any consequences, but I choose not to because of what the science says about them. I feel so much better omitting certain foods from my diet. I have more mental clarity, better physical fitness and many things that I wish I had when I ate like crap.

Sorry, but some people choose NOT to succumb to diabetes, cancer or other autoimmune diseases because of poor diets. A lot of this is on doctors for giving us fraudulent advice as well. I've seen people go the "eat what I want" route and suffer the consequences. Eat healthy now or pay the consequences later on in life. It's a simple choice for me to make.

There's nothing wrong with a few pieces of fermented bread here and there, but most kinds of wheat are problematic and inflammatory according to the recent clinical trials. I guess you just have to find a manufacturer that actually sources organic and fresh ingredients.
"After six eleven years in a place like this, you either learn to laugh...or you go insane."
yes gary, everyone should be able to eat more than expected - why eat sensibly when you can take a handful of pills and eat everything !
Guardian7 said...
You feel sorry for those with limited diets? What an offensive and insensitive comment, but that is expecting coming from you.

I can eat whatever I want. Sugar, candy, sweets... you name it.

I can also eat all the pizza or sourdough bread in the world without any consequences, but I choose not to because of what the science says about them. I feel so much better omitting certain foods from my diet. I have more mental clarity, better physical fitness and many things that I wish I had when I ate like crap.

Sorry, but some people choose NOT to succumb to diabetes, cancer or other autoimmune diseases because of poor diets. A lot of this is on doctors for giving us fraudulent advice as well. I've seen people go the "eat what I want" route and suffer the consequences. Eat healthy now or pay the consequences later on in life. It's a simple choice for me to make.

There's nothing wrong with a few pieces of fermented bread here and there, but most kinds of wheat are problematic and inflammatory according to the recent clinical trials. I guess you just have to find a manufacturer that actually sources organic and fresh ingredients.




Exactly what I mean by being a member of the cult. This doesn't have anything to do with UC at all. For some it is just about spreading the cult and nothing more. There are other forums devoted to these lifestyles but I guess there the only people you are dealing with are the believers and there wouldn't be anyone to convert so you have to come to forums such as this where you can spread the good word. I prefer using this forum as a UC forum devoted to UC.

I'm sorry mom. I hope we can get this thread back on topic.
Pentasa(500mg) 2 pillsX2; VSL 1 pillX2; Prescrip Assist Probiotic 1 pill X 2;Vitamin D3;Grape seed extract 400mg X 2; Canasa as needed; DAO as needed due to dietary histamine intolerance

Gave me trouble: Robinul; Zymactive, Renew Life Probiotic 80 billion, Florastor

Post Edited (garylouisville) : 6/21/2014 12:05:23 PM (GMT-6)

I don't mind the discussions, and while I try to stay out of them I have learned a lot from them. I am a big believer in food as medicine, but I have to admit that I really missed eating the occasional bagel and I have yet to make or find GF version that tastes good and has ingredients in it that I want to put into my body!
39 yrs old diagnosed with proctosigmoiditis 6/13/13
meds- 2 Lialda supplements: probiotics (1 VSL3 cap, 1 culturelle and 1 reuteri) 1 gram krill Oil, 5-500mg tabs psyllium husks and 3/4 tsp l-glutamine. Zyrtec for seasonal allergies as needed. Allergic to sulfites. Currently gluten/dairy free (except yogurt) and eating lots of RS (potato starch, green banana smoothie and various beans).
I could be wrong as I tend not to follow or care about this stuff, but wasnt it recently shown that there is no such thing as gluten intolerance?

Keep in mind I have not had the chance to locate or read the study, and I know how unreliable/inaccurate newpaper articles can be at summarizing scientific literature, but its still relevant in my opinion:

http://www.huffingtonpost.ca/2014/05/14/gluten-intolerance-fake_n_5327420.html
Pancolitis (UC) since Sept 2009
Therapy
Prednisone - 40 mg
Imuran/Azathioprine - 50 mg
Salofalk/5-ASA (table) - 500 mg
Salofalk/5-ASA (enema) - 4g
Failed Therapies
Remicade - 400 ml
Nicotine patches - 21 mg
I can fully assure you that the scientists doing the recent clinical trials on modern wheat and other inflammatory foods are not part of any "cult". If the data shows it's inflammatory, then it's inflammatory, and my main goal is to reduce the inflammation in my body as much as possible. As if UC alone isn't enough to deal with... No one is forcing you not to eat wheat, but don't feel sorry for me or others if I choose to omit wheat as a health-conscious decision.
"After six eleven years in a place like this, you either learn to laugh...or you go insane."
Marauder93 said...
I could be wrong as I tend not to follow or care about this stuff, but wasnt it recently shown that there is no such thing as gluten intolerance?

Keep in mind I have not had the chance to locate or read the study, and I know how unreliable/inaccurate newpaper articles can be at summarizing scientific literature, but its still relevant in my opinion:

http://www.huffingtonpost.ca/2014/05/14/gluten-intolerance-fake_n_5327420.html


I don't believe it's the gluten either. I believe it's the lectins which are ruined by the modern processing/hybridizing methods. This seems to be why people show less inflammation by switching to ancient wheat such as einkorn (or eliminating it completely) in the clinical setting.
Marauder93 said...
I could be wrong as I tend not to follow or care about this stuff, but wasnt it recently shown that there is no such thing as gluten intolerance?

Keep in mind I have not had the chance to locate or read the study, and I know how unreliable/inaccurate newpaper articles can be at summarizing scientific literature, but its still relevant in my opinion:

http://www.huffingtonpost.ca/2014/05/14/gluten-intolerance-fake_n_5327420.html


It does state in the article that it contradicts a recent study which just tells me that nobody knows yet.

I think it is entirely possible that going no gluten(ie no wheat) helps most people because in practice doing so improves their diet. Tossing donuts, American style pizza, most bread, and most pasta will help almost anyone. I think the currently demonized diet recommended by mainstream nutritionists is good but has failed and resulted in little health benefits because the population has continued to consume increasing calories(fat, protein and carbs), isn't really eating less of anything but eggs and butter, and have doubled down on white bread, soda and pasta. They didn't follow the main purpose of the diet..reducing calories.

This only covers 1950-2000 but the actual diet of Americans simply is not what the media reports or what mainstream experts have suggested we eat.

http://www.usda.gov/factbook/chapter2.pdf

By the way being thin doesn't mean you aren't eating too much and harming your health.

Post Edited (AZYooper) : 6/21/2014 1:33:26 PM (GMT-6)

Back to the original subject, I am a little puzzled why eating sourdough over normal yeast bread would make any difference if the rest of the ingredients are the same.

I have made a lot of sourdough bread and it is basically just a using a soured sponge of yeast, water and flour instead of a package of yeast. I like the taste better. It will accept more flour and not get heavy and it keeps longer. The count of dead yeast is probably higher along with their acidic waste.
Diagnosed with proctosigmoiditis as my 50th birthday present Dec 2009
4.8 grams Asacol HD plus 1000mg canasa daily for 8 weeks. Went to 1.6 gr Asacol for 8 months. Tried sulfasalzine for a month got adverse reactions

On generic Colazal all the time. Use loperamide and rowasa for symptoms.
Guardian7 said...
I don't believe it's the gluten either. I believe it's the lectins which are ruined by the modern processing/hybridizing methods. This seems to be why people show less inflammation by switching to ancient wheat such as einkorn (or eliminating it completely) in the clinical setting.


Interesting, Ill have to look into that more!
AZYooper said...
Back to the original subject, I am a little puzzled why eating sourdough over normal yeast bread would make any difference if the rest of the ingredients are the same.

I have made a lot of sourdough bread and it is basically just a using a soured sponge of yeast, water and flour instead of a package of yeast. I like the taste better. It will accept more flour and not get heavy and it keeps longer. The count of dead yeast is probably higher along with their acidic waste.


Fermented breads such as sourdough have significantly less phytates and more bioavailable nutrients. Study here. Whole wheat causes numerous issues because phytate (anti-nutrient) levels are so high - these bind to minerals like iodine, magnesium, etc.

I don't think fermented bread is bad. The ingredients just have to be non-trash.
Stuff from my old thead.
By the way sourdough starter is not just yeast,contains bacteria,which kill molds.
It also ferments/digests flour differently than just yeast.
The reason it is sour is from the bacteria.
This bread is also very dangerous,shattered my front tooth due to the hard crust.
When I was a kid,got hit with a back swing from a golf club,chipped my front tooth.
So now the bottom of my front tooth is plastic,bit into a piece of bread and bam,trip to the dentist for
new plastic.
Old Mike
 
http://www.scientificamerican.com/podcast/episode/sourdough-bacteria-pump-out-mold-ki-13-02-27/
 
more on bacteria fermentation
http://www.thefreshloaf.com/node/10375/lactic-acid-fermentation-sourdough
 
 
Here is a blog written by a baker, gives a little history on what is going on with our bread.
This is a sourdough site,quite interesting if you are into baking bread,explore the site.
Some of our digestive problems may be related to the way they now make bread and the grains used,
and the junk they put into it,and the bad cheap flour.
It is also interesting that around 1900 before a high UC incidence,the average person ate twice the bread
as we do today,of course most did not sit around all day at a desk.
This is a little something different than one of my normal posts.
I may even take sourdough baking up myself in the future.
Old Mike
http://www.sourdoughhome.com/foodphilosophy.html#breadmatters
 
 
I bake my own,super bread. I use this one. Norwich
Post from my old thread on sourdough.
Just like to say I gave up on my own starter,ordered the 250 year old starter from King Arthur flour,it works great,that was about 3 weeks or so ago.
Anyhow easy to get it going and I have made 3 batches of the most wonderfull tasting
sourdough that I could imagine.  One friends comment was the best bread he ever ate.
Well I will not go that far,but it is very good.
I normally work with this recipie,I kind of like it without the rye flour.
Top it with the seeds of your choice,spritz with water or brush on
slash and bake with steam at 450,for 30 minutes or so,leave in oven
with door open at least 5 minutes.
Old Mike
http://www.wildyeastblog.com/2007/07/08/my-new-favorite-sourdough/
Experiment with longer autolyse time like two hours.
I really did not think it was this easy,but better than many you may have tasted from a store.
 
 

Post Edited (Old Mike) : 6/21/2014 3:52:07 PM (GMT-6)

I love sourdough. I hope you have good luck with it. I seriously eat it every day.lets try to keep this on topic. I do not know whether sourdough would be any easier on you if you're gluten intolerant. I do agree with the others about the general quality of the food and production being terrible. I try to eat local, small farm products from the market when I can.
Co-moderator: Ulcerative Colitis
Diagnosed with Pancolitis, Laryngopharyngeal Reflux & Migraines. Battling Extreme Exhaustion.
Currently: 6mp (25mg) + Lialda (2400mg) + Canasa (1g PM)
I ate sourdough when i was in San Francisco (for me, the most wonderful place on earth) and it was delicious, i'm wondering if it is possible to bake it at home. I also used to eat clam chowder there (in bread) which i remember as something divine
Ewa, 24 yrs old from Warsaw
Left-sided colitis, diagnosed in September 2012
Current meds: 2x2 Asamax (500 mg) and Salofalk enemas (twice a week)
Mutaflor or VSL#3
My husband has been baking sourdough bread for a while, but with commercially produced organic flour. He has enjoyed the process, I actually used to make nearly all of our bread pre-colitis and I miss the process of baking. I opted for a bagel because the wheat this bakery uses is an heirloom variety. They also soak their grains and grind thir own flour to make it more digest able.
39 yrs old diagnosed with proctosigmoiditis 6/13/13
meds- 2 Lialda supplements: probiotics (1 VSL3 cap, 1 culturelle and 1 reuteri) 1 gram krill Oil, 5-500mg tabs psyllium husks and 3/4 tsp l-glutamine. Zyrtec for seasonal allergies as needed. Allergic to sulfites. Currently gluten/dairy free (except yogurt) and eating lots of RS (potato starch, green banana smoothie and various beans).