Test results different between labs?

I normally get an ultra sensitive PSA test with Quest Diagnostics and it has been <0.02 for the last 2 years (lowest level they can detect). I recently had a PSA test at my doctors office last week during my annual physical and he uses Primex Labs. My PSA came back at 0.03. Would there be a difference between labs and equipment that could cause that change? Primex uses Siemens and Quest uses Beckman Coulter equipment. I am now on an every 6 month PSA test regiment.
Biopsy PSA 5.2
2 of 12 cores
Bone Scan and CT Scan NEGATIVE
0.7cm Ductal Gl 4+4 = 8
1.1 cm Acinar Gl 3 + 4 = 7
EPE -, PNI -, SV -
Lymphovascuolar invasion -
Focally positive anterior margin < 2mm
pT2
3 month PSA <0.02 Quest
7 month PSA <0.02 Quest
11 months PSA <0.02 Quest
15 months PSA <0.02 Quest
19 months PSA <0.02 Quest
23 month PSA <0.02 Quest
29 month PSA 0.03 Primex

Post Edited (California Dreamer) : 9/18/2020 3:46:38 PM (GMT-6)

You can't really compare two different tests when the results are close. I don't know if this is also in play, but the two labs may be using two different PSA standards -- Hybritech* and WHO (World Health Organization). By one account this can cause a difference of 23% when testing the same sample. Did you plan on having a re-test at your doc's office in 6 months? If you are going to have a 6 month done at Quest, I would ignore you doc's test. Or a Quest retest comes back <0.02, then take a future Primex PSA result of 0.03 as being the same (unchanged).

If you are concerned, you can have a Quest test done.

Do you know if the Primex equipment is in your docs office or is sent out to them? My doc's practice has Labcorp equipment in office but using a less sensitive (0.05) Labcorp uPSA test. I don't know if in-office equipment is calibrated as often as that in the major labs (I have my blood drawn in his office sent out to a Labcorp facility).

The right-most digit of any test hold uncertainty. When there is only on significant digit in a result -- well, you get the picture. In addition, all test have a margin of error and will not usually give the exact same results when repeated multiple times on the same blood sample.

I wouldn't be too worried.

Djin
69 yr at Dx, BPH x 20 yr, 9 (!) neg. Bx
2013 TURP for BPH (90-->30 g) no PCa
6-6-17 Nodule (R) + PSA on finasteride: 3.6-->4.3
Bx #10: 2/14 cores: G10 (5+5) 50% RB, G9 (4+5) 3% RLM, nodule neg
Bone scan, CTs: neg, 8-7-17 open RP @Duke, neg frozen sections, nerves spared
SM EPE BNI LVI SVI LNI(16): neg, PNI+, pT2c pN0 R0 MX, G9 (4+5) 5%, 64 g
Decipher 0.37 Low Risk, PSA 0.010 (3m)…<0.014 (2y 10m)

Post Edited (DjinTonic) : 9/18/2020 5:50:43 PM (GMT-6)

Had the test redone today at Quest. Will let you know the result. Both tests were sent out to private labs.
Biopsy PSA 5.2
2 of 12 cores
Bone Scan and CT Scan NEGATIVE
0.7cm Ductal Gl 4+4 = 8
1.1 cm Acinar Gl 3 + 4 = 7
EPE -, PNI -, SV -
Lymphovascuolar invasion -
Focally positive anterior margin < 2mm
pT2
3 month PSA <0.02 Quest
7 month PSA <0.02 Quest
11 months PSA <0.02 Quest
15 months PSA <0.02 Quest
19 months PSA <0.02 Quest
23 month PSA <0.02 Quest
29 month PSA 0.03 Primex
Good luck CD, do keep us posted
I am not a doctor, just another guy without a prostate
Dx Age 64 Nov 2014, PSA 4.3
BX 3 of 12 cores positive original pathology G6
RALP with Dr Ash Tewari Jan 6, 2015
Post surgical pathology G7 (3+4), - ECE, - Margins, -LN, -SV (+ frozen section apex converted to negative)
PSA @ 6 weeks 2/15, .<02, remained <0.02 until January 2017, .02, repeat Feb 2017, still .02. May 2017-.033, August 2017- .033 November .046, March 2018 .060. June 2018 .068, July 2018 - .082, August 2018, .078, August 2018 - .08 Start ADT. Sept 2018 Start SRT
Sept 2018 thru November 2018 – T = 4, PSA = <.05
Decipher test, low risk, .37 score
My story.... tinyurl.com/qgyu3xq

There's not a fellow here who hasn't experienced that nagging, worrisome feeling, anytime there's an uptick in PSA.

I have a friend who says, "I wish I didn't fixate on those decimals so much, but I do! Arghhh!"

One thing that my oncologist has "coached me" through is that PSA fluctuations are normal, and that we should expect some.

He has taught me that we need to watch TRENDS, not fluctuations. I think that simple thought has helped me a great deal.

It's always important to stay vigilant, and stay on a timely PSA testing schedule.

But my oncologist's mantra of "expect fluctuations" from time-to-time has been a valued lesson for me.

I have PSA tests every month, because of my case, so I have learned to expect some little "peaks and valleys" because of frequent labwork.

Some readers here may have seen that famous post on the web --- a fellow went in for a PSA test, every day, for a solid month.

This study showed the PSA fluctuations from day-to-day --- for 30 days straight.

It was interesting how much the PSA levels could vary each consecutive day!

I always remember this, as well --- anything less than 0.10 is still considered undetectable by my doctors at Mayo Clinic!

Keep us posted --- keep ridin' the waves ---
CYCLONE ~ # Iowa State University

PSA At Diagnosis In Year 2013 : 138
Initial Diagnosis: Advanced Prostate Cancer, With Metastases In Both Lungs
Age At Diagnosis: 48 years
ADT Treatments: LUPRON, FIRMAGON, & currently ZOLADEX
Subsequent Treatments: Chemotherapy (TAXOTERE) & ZYTIGA & RADIATION
Additional Consultant - Dr. KWON - Mayo Clinic
Current PSA Level: < 0.10 - Undetectable Range - Treatments Ongoing
Hi Cyclone. Regarding <0.1 as undetectable, we should keep in mind that this is based on the standard PSA test for men with prostates after treatment. The metrics and post-treatment dynamics are different for someone whose primary treatment is ADT and/or RT vs a post-RP patient with a pT2 pathology and a very low uPSA. We in the second group would be concerned if our PSA rises from <0.02 to a value of, say, 0.09. especially several years after surgery. Labcorp calls its more sensitive PSA test "ultrasensitive." Quest chose to call its uPSA "post prostatectomy". If you put these adjectives together, you get the intended patients.

For us high-grade, post-RP guys, the decision for very early SRT is made with a rising PSA as well, but one that may be at or below 0.1. It's fine for men with prostates to be followed by the standard PSA test after treatment; however, IMO post-RP it's best suited for G6 men who are pT2 and <0.1.

An overlooked point is that RP men who are given the standard PSA tests for about the first 6 months after surgery will never know their PSA nadir, which has been shown to be a fairly accurate prognosticator of BCR risk. In addition, if faced with a PSA that starts out <0.1 and then rises while followed by this standard test, you have lost data that may point to the start and rate of the rise.

Djin
69 yr at Dx, BPH x 20 yr, 9 (!) neg. Bx
2013 TURP for BPH (90-->30 g) no PCa
6-6-17 Nodule (R) + PSA on finasteride: 3.6-->4.3
Bx #10: 2/14 cores: G10 (5+5) 50% RB, G9 (4+5) 3% RLM, nodule neg
Bone scan, CTs: neg, 8-7-17 open RP @Duke, neg frozen sections, nerves spared
SM EPE BNI LVI SVI LNI(16): neg, PNI+, pT2c pN0 R0 MX, G9 (4+5) 5%, 64 g
Decipher 0.37 Low Risk, PSA 0.010 (3m)…<0.014 (2y 10m)

Post Edited (DjinTonic) : 9/19/2020 11:55:58 AM (GMT-6)


Excellent points, from which others will learn, Djin Tonic.

The sharing of first-hand experiences here --- invaluable.

The sharing of new knowledge gleaned --- PRICELESS!

A tip of my hat, good sir --- and a handshake, from across the miles,
CYCLONE - # Iowa State University
I went to Quest Diagnostics yesterday and was retested. Will let you guys know the results when I get them.

Quest only goes down to 0.02 ng/ml. So if I was 0.019 ng/ml at Quest it would show up as <0.02 ng/ml (which it always has). If my PSA at Primex Labs was 0.025 ng/ml it would show up as 0.03 ng/ml. So theoretically we could be talking a 0.006 ng/ml difference!
Biopsy PSA 5.2
2 of 12 cores
Bone Scan and CT Scan NEGATIVE
0.7cm Ductal Gl 4+4 = 8
1.1 cm Acinar Gl 3 + 4 = 7
EPE -, PNI -, SV -
Lymphovascuolar invasion -
Focally positive anterior margin < 2mm
pT2
3 month PSA <0.02 Quest
7 month PSA <0.02 Quest
11 months PSA <0.02 Quest
15 months PSA <0.02 Quest
19 months PSA <0.02 Quest
23 month PSA <0.02 Quest
29 month PSA 0.03 Primex

DjinTonic said...

If you are concerned, you can have a Quest test done.



I wouldn't be too worried.

Djin



When changing labs, it never hurts to go back to the old lab to verify if there is a difference.

DjinTonic said...
Regarding <0.1 as undetectable, we should keep in mind that this is based on the standard PSA test for men with prostates after treatment... An overlooked point is that RP men who are given the standard PSA tests for about the first 6 months after surgery will never know their PSA nadir, which has been shown to be a fairly accurate prognosticator of BCR risk. In addition, if faced with a PSA that starts out <0.1 and then rises while followed by this standard test, you have lost data that may point to the start and rate of the rise.

The surgeon who did my RP (and I am pleased with his treatment) used the standard PSA post-RP and declared me 'undetectable' based on the <0.1 result, but urged for ART based on adverse pathology. We moved from Ohio to Florida less than two months later and my new Uro started immediately with monthly ultra sensitive PSA's, which came back as <0.02, .02, <.03, .03 etc during my time on Lupron preceding ART. Today, the same Uro tests down to <.008, so I never knew what my "true" PSA was that first month after RP. It has remained at <.008 ever since the first uPSA taken a few months after completing ART.

Getting to the point (finally) I plan to switch to LabCorp starting with my next PSA in January 2021, where my PSA's heretofore have been performed "in house" by the large uro group I've been seeing since moving to Florida four years ago. This is part of my plan to move to another urologist in Tampa next year because of the fallout from my horrible AUS experience and hopefully transition to him to perform the inevitable AUS replacement which is part of the deal with having this type of implant. (Yeah, I know... man plans, God laughs). So I'm prepared for LabCorp's results to possibly differ from what I've been seeing, but as long as it remains flat, I'm good. Fingers crossed.
2014-15: PSA's 9, 12, 20, 25, Neg DRE's, false neg TRUS biopsy
6/16: New Uro, MRI Fusion biopsy, 6 pos Rt Base 2ea 15-40-100% G8(4+4)
8/16: DaVinci RP, multifocal EPE, PNI, 11 LN-, 53g/25%, BL SVI, Grp4, pT3b
1/17: Started Lupron ADT, PSA's ~.03
5/17: AMS800 implant, revised 6/17
8/17: 39 tx RapidArc IMRT (70 Gy)
4/18: Dx Radiation Colitis & more
1/18 - 7/20: PSA's <0.008, T=20-60
Just received my Quest Diagnostics PSA results. < 0.02 ng/ml!

Just goes to show you there is a major difference between labs and machines!
Biopsy PSA 5.2
2 of 12 cores
Bone Scan and CT Scan NEGATIVE
0.7cm Ductal Gl 4+4 = 8
1.1 cm Acinar Gl 3 + 4 = 7
EPE -, PNI -, SV -
Lymphovascuolar invasion -
Focally positive anterior margin < 2mm
pT2
3 month PSA <0.02 Quest
7 month PSA <0.02 Quest
11 months PSA <0.02 Quest
15 months PSA <0.02 Quest
19 months PSA <0.02 Quest
23 month PSA <0.02 Quest
29 month PSA 0.03 Primex

Best news of the night!

Thankful for this great news, California Dreamer!

Hurray! Hurrah!
CYCLONE - # Iowa State University
I'm tested by two separate labs. One uses the ADVIA Centaur method. The other (labcorp) uses Roche ECLIA. The former always comes back PSA detectable - albeit at very low levels (for the last 3 years .01 but as high as .03). The latter is always undetectable. This has been going on for nearly 5 years. As a pT3a w/ super close margins (3+4) I was concerned at first. At this point I just chalk it up to the differences between assays. I guess it's possible there might be a ultra small amount of benign tissue hanging out that one lab picks up while the other doesn't. Who knows? I'm eternally grateful to my surgeon.
Hi TJ123,

Given those ADVIA readings, I'm curious as to which Labcorp test gives you "undetectable" results (i.e., values with a < sign ). AFAIK, there are three different Labcorp tests with a total of 4 different undetectable results: <0.1, <0.05, <0.014, and <0.006.

Djin
69 yr at Dx, BPH x 20 yr, 9 (!) neg. Bx
2013 TURP for BPH (90-->30 g) no PCa
6-6-17 Nodule (R) + PSA on finasteride: 3.6-->4.3
Bx #10: 2/14 cores: G10 (5+5) 50% RB, G9 (4+5) 3% RLM, nodule neg
Bone scan, CTs: neg, 8-7-17 open RP @Duke, neg frozen sections, nerves spared
SM EPE BNI LVI SVI LNI(16): neg, PNI+, pT2c pN0 R0 MX, G9 (4+5) 5%, 64 g
Decipher 0.37 Low Risk, PSA 0.010 (3m)…<0.014 (2y 10m)

Post Edited (DjinTonic) : 9/21/2020 5:38:47 AM (GMT-6)

Djin,

Historically I've had <.006 results from Labcorp (probably 5-6 tests) prior to my last test of <.014. I called Labcorp and asked them why the change to .014. The lab told me the manufacturer changed the lower limit of their test, which is shown on the lab reports to be the Roche ELICIA methodology for both the <.006 and <.014 lower limits. As I mentioned - all my previous tests using the ADVIA Centaur methodology over the last 4.8 years post RALP have shown scant levels of PSA - most recently in the last 3 years at .01.

TJ123 said...
Djin,

Historically I've had <.006 results from Labcorp (probably 5-6 tests) prior to my last test of <.014. I called Labcorp and asked them why the change to .014. The lab told me the manufacturer changed the lower limit of their test, which is shown on the lab reports to be the Roche ELICIA methodology for both the <.006 and <.014 lower limits. As I mentioned - all my previous tests using the ADVIA Centaur methodology over the last 4.8 years post RALP have shown scant levels of PSA - most recently in the last 3 years at .01.



That's curious about your Labcorp info, because <0.014 was their previous lower limit until about 4 years go. I was under the impression that some folks were still getting a <0.006 results and that it depended on which analyzer you got to run the same Roche assay.

I find it strange that Roche would raise the lower limit of their assay. I have a spec sheet that shows that on the most sensitive analyzers their assay can actually measure down to 0.002 or 0.003. My hunch is that this change has to do with the makers of the different analyzers.

Let's see if anyone does get (or has recently gotten) a <0.006. That will tell us much. (I too got a <0.014 reading for the first time at my last test.) I will check Labcorp results and dates in other signatures, too. Thanks!

Djin
69 yr at Dx, BPH x 20 yr, 9 (!) neg. Bx
2013 TURP for BPH (90-->30 g) no PCa
6-6-17 Nodule (R) + PSA on finasteride: 3.6-->4.3
Bx #10: 2/14 cores: G10 (5+5) 50% RB, G9 (4+5) 3% RLM, nodule neg
Bone scan, CTs: neg, 8-7-17 open RP @Duke, neg frozen sections, nerves spared
SM EPE BNI LVI SVI LNI(16): neg, PNI+, pT2c pN0 R0 MX, G9 (4+5) 5%, 64 g
Decipher 0.37 Low Risk, PSA 0.010 (3m)…<0.014 (2y 10m)

Post Edited (DjinTonic) : 9/21/2020 12:56:45 PM (GMT-6)

Djin,

All my Labcorp PSA tests were taken at the very same clinic and the samples sent to the very same regional lab for analysis. So nothing changed except for the lower limit on my very last Labcorp test in May.

I called the Labcorp regional lab for an explanation. I was told the manufacturer changed the lower limit for their test.
My experience is that the Siemens Advia Centaur is good for doing PSA testing if you have a prostate but does a poor job at ultra sensitive PSA levels if you don’t have a prostate.
Biopsy PSA 5.2
2 of 12 cores
Bone Scan and CT Scan NEGATIVE
0.7cm Ductal Gl 4+4 = 8
1.1 cm Acinar Gl 3 + 4 = 7
EPE -, PNI -, SV -
Lymphovascuolar invasion -
Focally positive anterior margin < 2mm
pT2
3 month PSA <0.02 Quest
7 month PSA <0.02 Quest
11 months PSA <0.02 Quest
15 months PSA <0.02 Quest
19 months PSA <0.02 Quest
23 month PSA <0.02 Quest
29 month PSA 0.03 Primex
Hello all. I just want to share my dad's experience regarding tests in different labs.
He is currently undetectable (PSA <0.006) almost 3 years after prostatectomy, all blood tests taken at the same lab.
One test only (april 2020) was taken at a different lab, because of his usual lab being closed due to Coronavirus (we live in Italy where at the time the entire country was in lockdown and not all health facilities were accessible).

The result of his April blood test was 0.04, up from <0.006 in January, which of course caused some anxiety. I am aware that results from different labs cannot be compared, but my dad is medium-high risk of recurrence (Gleason 4+3) and I tend to expect the worst.

Fast forward to the end of August, he returned to his usual lab for retesting and the result came back undetectable <0.006.
Not sure what is different between the 2 assays, if the machine, the procedure or the lower detection limit, but the difference between the two results was huge.