Treating liver mets?

I am so confused about how to think about treatment options once PCa has metastasized to the liver.

Do you treat with chemo and sometimes radiation etc., because it can work and buy you time, or no, it generally doesn't buy you time but it improves quality of life, or do people who treat it do so because they don't want to give up, they'll fight, go through anything because where there is life there is hope?

edit -- I hope I didn't word that in an insensitive way; absolutely not my intent. But I can't think of a more positive way to ask how much hope I should have

thanks in advance




Optional background: We're not faced with an immediate decision because we're still awaiting appointments and tests and results, but I know we will be soon, and have been trying to get prepared. And of course there's also the issue that it's hard to think about anything else.

So my husband was for a time the luckiest G-9 guy, in that HT quickly cleared his extensive bone mets with minimal physical side effects. But now it seems he has liver mets and apparently an entirely independent cancer (gall bladder). Seeing the liver mets in the radiologist report was a punch in the gut, but our onc says the gall bladder is the bigger concern because it blocks the liver from draining and causes liver failure. His bilirubin doubled over the past five weeks and the CT report notes ducts are starting to distend from pressure.

Pre-biopsy, it's not known if the liver mets are PCa or gallbladder cancer cells. I think PCa is considered slightly more likely.

Meanwhile the march through the bones has accelerated greatly: spine, pelvis, ribs, sternum, legs. PSA at 275, increasing by about 235% every month. He is in a ton of pain, wearing a fentanyl patch and taking Percocet but still suffering.

It's hard for me to imagine him doing chemo. It hurts him to breath. It's so stressful to drive him anywhere because the smallest bump at the slowest speed can bring tears to his eyes. I can't imagine what it would be like to throw up from chemo while his bones feel this way.

Google is tremendously depressing (as in a very short average survival time), but I don't know if that's accurate. I know when he was initially diagnosed, google was depressing then too and then as I learned more, it seemed there were far better options and outcomes today than during the time frames even the recent-ish research online referred to.

Stuff I should have in a signature: he was diagnosed about 3 years ago, G9 (5+4), extensive mets to bones and lymph node involvement at diagnosis, went on hormone therapy and some other stuff (Lupron, Zytiga, Avodart, Sprycel, Leukine, those estrogen patches, more recently metformin and xofigo (four treatments), tons of supplements). He went to undetectable soon after starting HT and stayed that way until about 6 months ago. Bone mets cleared for a while, the lymph nodes never did.

Post Edited (Infohound2) : 8/13/2015 10:01:11 AM (GMT-6)

I'm sorry to hear about these developments - the last thing he needed was a second cancer to deal with!

Chemo and radiation are both palliative, and hopefully will enhance his quality of life. Chemo also extends survival. Is there a reason his oncologist has not used them before now - bloodwork? performance status? They may want to use a different chemo combination based on the gall bladder cancer, but the earlier, the bigger benefit.

- Allen
Even though palliative used to be the word I hated to see (I read it as "resigned to terminal" back then), I'm happy to see yes, chemo could actually be a QOL improvement. I guess my worry is that we make things worse in an effort to buy more time -- a good deal if you buy a year with that extra suffering, not so good if you buy four extra weeks of feeling awful. But taking a chance for some near-term relief feels much better.

I guess I'm asking dumb questions because I can't or don't want to believe what I've read.

I'm not sure about the non-use of chemo. We have two oncs (one far away and a local); my impression is both see chemo as something to be used only when other "easier" options have failed. And both doctors had thought he was doing great. Even when PSA started going wild in recent months, the local onc told us that was fantastic news indicative of a great response, and that the pain and PSA were likely the results of rapid cancer death; he was opposed to any scans as unnecessary. Fortunately the other oncologist wrote us an order for scans, so at least we now know what we're up against. We've heard that "PSA increase can be a good sign" repeatedly from two oncs and I think we wanted to believe it so we did. Now that I look back I regret not forcing the issue sooner.

Do you think surgery is still an option? I keep seeing that you don't do surgery when the cancer exists other places but I'm not sure why. If it said surgery won't cure you if the cancer is other places, I'd get it, but if we're willing to settle for less than a cure, wouldn't removing it still help? It seems to me prostate cancer in the bones makes you miserable but doesn't kill you, whereas prostate cancer in the liver is lethal. So shouldn't still help to take out the lethal cancer?


thanks for your response -- I'm really grateful people are willing to read sad posts and share their knowledge
The thinking about use of chemo has changed radically in the last couple of years because of the CHAARTED study, which early results of the STAMPEDE study are now confirming. What CHAARTED found was when there are multiple mets that docetaxel, when used at the time ADT begins, adds a median of 17 months survival. But if one waits until near the end, there are only about 4 months added. As I said, docetaxel improves QOL, so there is no reason to wait - as long as the patient isn't otherwise a candidate for it.

PSA does temporarily increase from some interventions, and some, like immune therapy, may not affect PSA at all. But if they are working, most interventions will lower PSA. If not, there are other biochemical markers like ALP that can be useful for monitoring.

I'm a bit confused by your asking about prostate surgery. You just expressed concerns that he would have a hard time going through chemo - so how can he possibly go through a surgery like that? Debulking, either with surgery or radiation, may have some survival benefit. But there will be a trade-off with QOL.

Advanced prostate cancer anywhere is a lethal disease. Advanced cancer spreads easily to bones typically first and distant soft tissue typically later. Organ involvement compromises the functioning of those organs and can lead to organ failure. You should tell your oncologist if you are interested in clinical trials - they don't always volunteer that info if you don't ask.

- Allen
I'm sorry I wasn't clear. I didn't mean prostate surgery, I meant removing the liver mets (and potentially the gallbladder mass).

It feels like progression to the liver is the big game changer. Up until now, he's had cancer, but I was thinking of it as being like diabetes -- something he'd always have to manage, but he could still live a long time. But liver mets seems like it changes the realistic time frame. I guess I am just trying to turn the clock back to when it was "only" in his bones and lymph nodes, and thinking, hey the liver is huge. And it regenerates. Just cut some out!

I probably have an outdated view of the chemo experience. I think of chemo as worse than surgery, but maybe because I've seen intensely miserable chemo from years ago (my mom died 10 years ago, soon after starting a chemo regimen she probably shouldn't have, since she was already in very bad shape).

I will ask about docetaxel and clinical trials in our appointment tomorrow.

thanks very much
My Pca is mCRPC now......I had SRT in 2004, then as a result of that ended up with colorectal cancer in 2012.
Last year it spread to my liver.....I had several masses removed by a very good liver surgeon and my liver remains clear, now I have 2 spots in my lungs that will probably be removed this fall. The point is liver surgery (resection) is frequency done with excellent results....liver tumors can be also ablated with RFA, results can be improved with chemo.......this is applicable in my case since the mets were colorectal...not sure if the same holds true with prostate cancer, but it is worth seeking out a very qualified liver surgeon.
Dx 8/2002 PSA 4.7 Gleason 3+4 Age: 55
RP 10/2002 upgraded Gleason4+4,micro mets 1 lymph node, seminal vesicles
rising PSA ...SRT 6/2004 36 IMRT +ADT2
rising PSA 6/2009 ADT3 ,
rising PSA while on ADT3 up to .52 3/2012
Apr 2012 Clinical Trial ARN-509
PSA 9/12 .12 10/2012 <0.05 12/2012 Stage 3a Rectal Cancer
ColoRectal Resection Colostomy Chemo , out of trial for ARN509
Liver Mets 7/14
Infohound, liver resection has been tried in colorectal cancer, because liver is usually the first site of metastatic disease for CRC and if the lesions are few, they can be successfully resected. I highly doubt that your hubby would be a candidate for a major liver surgery though. Having said that, one can certainly radiate the individual metastatic sites in liver (stereotactic body radiation technique or SBRT), it has been tried in breast cancer, however, once liver is affected in BC (and prostate cancer has many parallels) it is assumed that there are many other metastatic sites, and that liver resection or SBRT would not be curative only palliative. Try talking to a radiation oncologist and see if this would help your hubby. Btw, chemo for PC patients is (from what people reported here) not that bad. There are chemo combos for other cancers that have much worse side-effects than the dosis of Taxotere given to PC patients.
Father diagnosed in Jan2011 (at age 68):
DRE positive, PSA 7.5, biopsy Gleason 7 and 8.
Bone scan positive: VL5 and pubic bone
Feb2011: Started hormonal therapy (Trelstar+Casodex)
Jan2012: 0.055
Feb2012: last Trelstar injection
trimonthly PSA: 0.078, 0.138, 1.08, 1.15, 4.17, 5.71, 4.40, 5.08, 7.08
after 2yrs in the OFF phase and a new spot on sacrum, restarts HT May2014
trimonthly: 0.493, 0.207
Ziggy mentions RFA (radiofrequency ablation) that is also a technique that is worth looking into...
Father diagnosed in Jan2011 (at age 68):
DRE positive, PSA 7.5, biopsy Gleason 7 and 8.
Bone scan positive: VL5 and pubic bone
Feb2011: Started hormonal therapy (Trelstar+Casodex)
Jan2012: 0.055
Feb2012: last Trelstar injection
trimonthly PSA: 0.078, 0.138, 1.08, 1.15, 4.17, 5.71, 4.40, 5.08, 7.08
after 2yrs in the OFF phase and a new spot on sacrum, restarts HT May2014
trimonthly: 0.493, 0.207
Thanks again everyone for your suggestions....I'm armed for our appointment today and will update with any takeaways from that that could be helpful to others
Dx 5/12 Metastatic PCa, lymph nodes & extensive bone mets
G9 (5+4), 12 of 12 cores positive, 100% involvement in all cores, PSA 61.1
Undetectable from 9/12 to 11/13 but only picked up in earnest around 12/14
Lupron, Zytiga, Avodart, Sprycel, Leukine, xofigo, metformin
Liver mets and apparent gallbladder cancer found 8/15
Hi will you read "sue saddened wife" in this forum  it has helped me alot to read what other are going through and I am sure it will help you. Join the conversation if you want.  Carol
Steve age 55 and wife Carol
2009 psa 322-lupron, casodex, radiation zytiga/ xtandi/ xofigo /provenge/ taxotere/ Jevtana/ Carboplatin
7/2015 psa 556
bone mets and liver mets
My husband has had very close to the same disease progression with the difference being chemo treatments. He has had good results with few side effects. My suggestions be to lobby for cabazitaxil, but I don't know if that would help with the other cancer.
By the way, welcome to the forum. I know that it is easy to look back, but you are here now getting good info from very knowledgeable guys like Allen, and support from the group.
Check out caregivers corner too.
Beth n Gary
Husband age 56
Dx: PC with widespread Mets to bones and nodes 11/2010
PSA @ dx 1983 Gleason 4+5 stage IV
Docetaxel 1/12
Zytiga7/12
Smarium 5/13
Xtandi 9/13 xofigo 1/14
Cabazitaxel 2/14
Zytiga 10/14
Ongoing s dx: denosomab and Lupron
Begin RT to sacrum X 10 1/15 PSA 1/15 100 +
2/15End Zytiga
Pilot study DRibbles vaccine 3/15
CT shows liver lesions now
Current psa 900. docetaxil 5/15.end study.