Tumor removal and/or ablation is an accepted and common frontline action in most all solid tumor cancers. Usually, the tumor is removed/ablated before it can be determined whether the cancer is localized or metastatic. That, to me, is for the appararent reason to cure (where possible) or, to better control the cancer to extend the remision time and durability. Very specific "debulking" is more oriented to relieving tumor burden to enable better bodily functions, quality of life, and treatment efficacy, when it is known that it won't be curative.
It appears, nearly universally, that the men on this forum have had removal/ablation in an attempt to cure and/or control cancer even when presented with extremely high risk situations. I can remember very few that have not had surgery or radiation. Obviously in their cases the doctors decided not to debulk the primary tumor.
Following Myers, he contends that even in advanced cases, that by removing a major source of the cancer, treatment results are improved since there is, by definition, less actual cancer to fight. Logically, the least amount of cancer in the body would be a preferred situation. It would present a better ratio between the amount of cancer and the amount of treatment and it would be extracting less from the body reducing its parasitic effects and allowing the person to be relatively more healthy while being treated.
As to the original question, Debulking is a very clear reality and a common tool in cancer control. I don't see any aspect of it being a myth. I infer that the real question is whether it is effective. To answer that, one would have to understand the treatment objectives, which may vary widely among patients.
PSA 59 on 8-26-2010 age 60. Biopsy 9-8-2010 12/12 positive, 20-80% involved, PNI in 3 cores, G 3+3,3+4,and 4+3=G7, T2b.
Eligard and Jalyn started on 10-7-2010. IMRT to prostate and lymph nodes started on 11-8-2010, HDR Brachytherapy December 6 and 13, 2010.
PSA < .1 and Testosterone less than 3 since February 2011
gibson -
"Just out of interest, if they didn't have reason to believe that the cancer had broke through the capsule, why did they think radiation was a bad idea?"
Not at all the case. They were all ready to zap me immediately. But the results they quoted for guys in my situation, which were to them wonderful (in effect it boiled down to some don't die immediately), for me offered little if any encouragement that I would be around for more than a year or two.
MD Anderson was more realistic - they consulted with me, but refused to do seeds on me, I was "too far along". To be honest they did not offer a combo seeds/RT treatment. Not sure if it was that the approach was not yet mainstream, or my insurance company.
hi David, "myth" reference is really to challenge a belief that removing prostate with cancer already outside the prostate can improve outcome.
ah i get it. as in "the cancer had already escaped but at least we debulked the tumor."
age: 57
12/09 -- PSA 6.8
G7 -- 3+4
HT, BT and IGRT
9/4/12 -- 2-year post treatment PSA 0.2
(PSAs .2, .3, .2, .3, .2)
age: 57
12/09 -- PSA 6.8
G7 -- 3+4
HT, BT and IGRT
9/4/12 -- 2-year post treatment PSA 0.2
(PSAs .2, .3, .2, .3, .2)
142, such was my case back in 2008, when "seeds" were being considered for me, as it was my original treatment method i was wanting. dr. thought with my velocity issues, that the cancer was already progressing fast.
and going back to the term "debaulking", i first heard it by my own urologist back in 2008, and heard it again with my oncologist in 2011.
david
Age: 60, 56 at PC dx, PSA 16.3
3rd Biopsy: 9/8 7 of 7 Positive, 40-90%, 4+3
open RP: 11/8, Catheter in 63 days
Path Rpt: 3+4, pT2c, 42g, 20% tumor, 1 pos margin
Incont & ED: None
Surgery Failed, recurrence within 9 months
Salvage Radiation 10/9-11/9, SRT failed within 9 months, PSA 4/12 = 37.x
Spent total of 1 ½ years on 21 catheters, Ileal Conduit Surgery 9/10,
7 other PC-related surgeries
Member of Prostate Cancer & Chronic Pain HW Communities since 10/2008
“I live in the weak and the wounded” – Session Nine (Movie)
and going back to the term "debaulking", i first heard it by my own urologist back in 2008, and heard it again with my oncologist in 2011.
david
Age: 60, 56 at PC dx, PSA 16.3
3rd Biopsy: 9/8 7 of 7 Positive, 40-90%, 4+3
open RP: 11/8, Catheter in 63 days
Path Rpt: 3+4, pT2c, 42g, 20% tumor, 1 pos margin
Incont & ED: None
Surgery Failed, recurrence within 9 months
Salvage Radiation 10/9-11/9, SRT failed within 9 months, PSA 4/12 = 37.x
Spent total of 1 ½ years on 21 catheters, Ileal Conduit Surgery 9/10,
7 other PC-related surgeries
Member of Prostate Cancer & Chronic Pain HW Communities since 10/2008
“I live in the weak and the wounded” – Session Nine (Movie)
JNF, thanks for your insight, yes, the real question is whether it is effective. The logic says "yes", some studies agree, especially when lymph nodes are taken out together with prostate.
Father (69 now) diagnosed with PCs in Jan 2011:
DRE positive, PSA 7.5, biopsy Gleason 6, second expert opinion: Gleason 7 and 8.
two inconclusive bone-scintigraphies, MR scan showed 2 bone mets
Feb 2011: Started hormonal therapy (Trelstar+Casodex) in Jan 2011
Jan 2012: Added Zometa
Mar 2012: went "off" hormonal therapy after PSA reached 0.055
Father (69 now) diagnosed with PCs in Jan 2011:
DRE positive, PSA 7.5, biopsy Gleason 6, second expert opinion: Gleason 7 and 8.
two inconclusive bone-scintigraphies, MR scan showed 2 bone mets
Feb 2011: Started hormonal therapy (Trelstar+Casodex) in Jan 2011
Jan 2012: Added Zometa
Mar 2012: went "off" hormonal therapy after PSA reached 0.055
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/22934913
http://www.europeanurology.com/article/S0302-2838%2810%2900002-3/fulltext
There are more, these are two of the best and most complete and recent.
http://www.europeanurology.com/article/S0302-2838%2810%2900002-3/fulltext
There are more, these are two of the best and most complete and recent.