Steven,
I hope you're right but I'll settle with a new screening test that helps prevent over-reaction and over treatment.
All:
As far as screening events like this these they are typically poorly operated. Like Allen says there is no educational process at them and the likelihood is more over treatment.
But I have mixed feelings about these events. At our Catholic Charities office once a year screening is offered for indigent folks. They otherwise could not afford co-pays or insurance so it is the only way to get a screening is at one of these events.
Also at the hospital where I hold our UsTOO meetings they offer $10.00 screenings once a month. Any individual can come in and pay 10 bucks and get a PSA. There is no limit on the number of times a person can come in so even a person without insurance can at least afford to monitor their PCa.
The part that concerns me there is that even with an UsTOO chapter right down the hall, per se, they don't send us any patients they find. Sad but true...
Tony
Advanced Prostate Cancer Survivor
Patient Advocate and Support Group Leader
Not a medical professional!!!
Allen - I don't think I implied indoctrination was at play in this thread.
As far as education goes, nobody is against it. What I'm against is "education" designed to provide your specific desired outcome (AS where you think it is qualified).
For me education is exactly how my urologist started me off:
"David, you're going to be okay. It's very early and we can cure it with surgery or radiation and you could even consider AS even though at your age (40) I wouldn't. Now let me tell you about surgery, radiation and AS"
That's how my consult started and it was a good place to start. I wasn't looking for an academic approach that would take months.
As far as education goes, nobody is against it. What I'm against is "education" designed to provide your specific desired outcome (AS where you think it is qualified).
For me education is exactly how my urologist started me off:
"David, you're going to be okay. It's very early and we can cure it with surgery or radiation and you could even consider AS even though at your age (40) I wouldn't. Now let me tell you about surgery, radiation and AS"
That's how my consult started and it was a good place to start. I wasn't looking for an academic approach that would take months.
Tony,
The people I see suffer the most from the event cutbacks are exactly the ones you mention. Those who can't afford an office visit (my PSAs bill out at $175 retail).
Why don't you get your volunteers to staff a booth to talk to the folks on the days they do the screenings? They can get reference materials and meeting information into the hands of the guys getting their tests. One of my hospitals has a variation of that approach - every guy getting tested gets the local support group information, and an invite.
Let me quote myself: "I started my journey with one of these free health screenings for men."
I have a feeling some people have never been to a group health screening or it's been a long time. I've been to 4 in the past six years. They've been the only gathering I've been too where I can talk to a dozen different doctors.... They have doctors speak of various medical issues etc....
Worse case is yes, it's a marketing ploy to drum up more business. But getting to meet some docs face to face is a lot better than picking one out of the phonebook....or from a google search.
I have a feeling some people have never been to a group health screening or it's been a long time. I've been to 4 in the past six years. They've been the only gathering I've been too where I can talk to a dozen different doctors.... They have doctors speak of various medical issues etc....
Worse case is yes, it's a marketing ploy to drum up more business. But getting to meet some docs face to face is a lot better than picking one out of the phonebook....or from a google search.
142,
We do that when we are made aware of the event and the organizers let us. I even received a 11 grand grant from the CDC to host one of these events four years ago. What we could not do with that grant was screen them. As it turns out the grant could only be used for educational material and the facility, we had to find a doctors office to come and do the screening on their dime. Which they were happy to do because "it's good for business" they told me.
We have already a full plate for the group. I work with Ed Randall's Bat for the Cure group for baseball games ~ awareness night. And we also try to do the health shows but again we don't screen or sponsor a screening. It's too costly and we aren't geared for the liabilities.
It's typically a process put on by hospitals. And they don't call us typically...
Tony
Advanced Prostate Cancer Survivor
Patient Advocate and Support Group Leader
Not a medical professional!!!
We do that when we are made aware of the event and the organizers let us. I even received a 11 grand grant from the CDC to host one of these events four years ago. What we could not do with that grant was screen them. As it turns out the grant could only be used for educational material and the facility, we had to find a doctors office to come and do the screening on their dime. Which they were happy to do because "it's good for business" they told me.
We have already a full plate for the group. I work with Ed Randall's Bat for the Cure group for baseball games ~ awareness night. And we also try to do the health shows but again we don't screen or sponsor a screening. It's too costly and we aren't geared for the liabilities.
It's typically a process put on by hospitals. And they don't call us typically...
Tony
Advanced Prostate Cancer Survivor
Patient Advocate and Support Group Leader
Not a medical professional!!!
Yoop--Thanks for being an advocate! Tall Allen--Your post has me "steaming" so I felt that I had to reply. Most, not all, members here had their PC detected by screening prior to the disease progressing to an "advanced stage" where cure was not possible. I live in the "sticks" and rely on 2 medical institutions for my care. In contrast to the task force which recommends against any screening, the largest medical system in the country-the VA-recommends against "routine" screening. My facility strongly recommends against any testing but it's at the doctor's call. My Veterans Service Officer (VSO) receives a psa test and dre annually by his psp while mine doesn't offer the test to anyone and refuses to discuss the issue.
There is a task force member who practices in Minneapolis at a VA facility and is on record as advising his patients against the test: I would assume that education and informed decision making is lacking given his views or prejudices. In contrast, my civilian medical facility subscribes to the AUA guidelines and provides each patient with a 2 page handout as education prior to the test. My pcp's short discussion consists of telling the patient that they may die if they don't get the test (benefit) or possibly suffer ED or/and incontinence if they do (harms)..Both approaches are faulty in my opinion and I believe that "informed decision making" and "education" of the patient is a "cop-out" by medical experts and institutions.
A recent article from either Yoop or the Lieutenant captured my attention. The UK article mentioned that 1 in 8 men would be diagnosed and 40,000 would have PC annually with 30% having advanced disease and 70% of those would die within 5 years. Very sobering in a country whose NHS has no national screening guidelines..I feel that we are heading there fast. Tony mentioned that 240,000 men would be diagnosed this year and in the absence of psa screening up to 50,000 would possibly die. I don't know if this was a SWAG estimate or merely a "for instance". I guess that the increase in deaths that are sure to occur are for the "good" of society: I can't buy into this concept!
Bill
Age 71--a "well seasoned" vet
Dx'd Sept 2010 by symptoms at age68--PSA 4.89--5 G8's and 4 G7's out of 10 cores.t3ahigh risk-High volume with extra capular extension present..79.2Gys IMRT completed in Feb 2011 with 6 months casodex and 3 years lupron--.06 psa after radiation and <.03 April 2013..Last 6-month lupron shot due in Oct 2013..Side Effects--fatigue and emotional highs and lows
There is a task force member who practices in Minneapolis at a VA facility and is on record as advising his patients against the test: I would assume that education and informed decision making is lacking given his views or prejudices. In contrast, my civilian medical facility subscribes to the AUA guidelines and provides each patient with a 2 page handout as education prior to the test. My pcp's short discussion consists of telling the patient that they may die if they don't get the test (benefit) or possibly suffer ED or/and incontinence if they do (harms)..Both approaches are faulty in my opinion and I believe that "informed decision making" and "education" of the patient is a "cop-out" by medical experts and institutions.
A recent article from either Yoop or the Lieutenant captured my attention. The UK article mentioned that 1 in 8 men would be diagnosed and 40,000 would have PC annually with 30% having advanced disease and 70% of those would die within 5 years. Very sobering in a country whose NHS has no national screening guidelines..I feel that we are heading there fast. Tony mentioned that 240,000 men would be diagnosed this year and in the absence of psa screening up to 50,000 would possibly die. I don't know if this was a SWAG estimate or merely a "for instance". I guess that the increase in deaths that are sure to occur are for the "good" of society: I can't buy into this concept!
Bill
Age 71--a "well seasoned" vet
Dx'd Sept 2010 by symptoms at age68--PSA 4.89--5 G8's and 4 G7's out of 10 cores.t3ahigh risk-High volume with extra capular extension present..79.2Gys IMRT completed in Feb 2011 with 6 months casodex and 3 years lupron--.06 psa after radiation and <.03 April 2013..Last 6-month lupron shot due in Oct 2013..Side Effects--fatigue and emotional highs and lows
Wow, I get tied up in a FDA medical validation audit with a customer all day and this post gets lit up. . . .
I don't have time to reply much as we're still meeting - but I do have one comment:
TA - I am thoroughly disappointed in your comments, not what I expected out of you, at all. Without the benefit of knowing WHO is putting this on you take to slamming it like it's some kind of travelling circus. I've never seen you post without the benefit of knowledge and data - until today. . . .
The facility that is putting this on is world class, experts in the field. By HW rules I am not allowed to post WHO is putting this on, but as my original post states send an e-mail to me and I can provide more details.
Allen, while I am fully aware of your stance on OD, I am floored by your posts today. . . .
56 yrs old, excellent health - DX'd with PCa July '12
PSA 5.8
Biopsy 6/27/12
9 of 12 Gleason: 3+3 and 3+4 (All neg PNI)
Negative DRE’s / NO / MO / T1C / Gland size 40gm / Vol. 22gm
Volume Study 8/14/12
Casodex 50mg daily 5 wks prior 2 wks post BT
LDR BT 9/21/12 – no issues
3 mo PSA 12/20 0.48!
6 mo PSA 3/14 0.21!
9 mo PSA 6/18/13 0.30!
56 yrs old, excellent health - DX'd with PCa July '12
PSA 5.8
Biopsy 6/27/12
9 of 12 Gleason: 3+3 and 3+4 (All neg PNI)
Negative DRE’s / NO / MO / T1C / Gland size 40gm / Vol. 22gm
Volume Study 8/14/12
Casodex 50mg daily 5 wks prior 2 wks post BT
LDR BT 9/21/12 – no issues
3 mo PSA 12/20 0.48!
6 mo PSA 3/14 0.21!
9 mo PSA 6/18/13 0.30!
Tall Allen: reading through the thread, I see that you claim I advocate a "caveat emptor" approach to PSA screening. Really? Hey, I've studied Latin, and know what that means, but I have no idea why "let the buyer beware" would describe my thoughts on prostate cancer screening. ,
What I wrote about in this thread is that I was appalled when I read your comments regarding this screening event that Yooper referenced, describing it as "An event that will do more harm than good." "Disgusting."
Seriously?
davidg said...
Allen - I don't think I implied indoctrination was at play in this thread. As far as education goes, nobody is against it. What I'm against is "education" designed to provide your specific desired outcome (AS where you think it is qualified).
Allen - I don't think I implied indoctrination was at play in this thread. As far as education goes, nobody is against it. What I'm against is "education" designed to provide your specific desired outcome (AS where you think it is qualified).
Indoctrination or propaganda would be involved if a point of view were presented biased to a specific outcome. In what way does the patient decision aid I linked do that?
These fairs could have been a great educational opportunity. It would be so easy to have someone sit down and go through that PDA before deciding whether to take a PSA test. Sadly, this doesn't happen.
Whether its $10 or free, it's way too steep a cost for something that may do more harm than good. Without prior education, the odds of doing harm go way up.
Allen, I simply do not agree with you and I'm not sure what context you are taking the "indoctrination" theme out of. I didn't read the patient decision aid you linked. Parallel lines will never converge.
I know you mean well, but I just cannot agree with anything you posted in this particular thread.
If Frank Zappa had attended this fair he'd probably be alive today. And Frank didn't need any education.
40 years old - Diagnosed at 40
Robotic Surgery Mount Sinai with Dr. Samadi Jan, 2011
complete urinary control and good erections with and without meds
Prostate was small, 34 grams.
Final Gleason score 7 (3+4)
Less than 5% of slides involved tumor
Tumor measured 5 mm in greatest dimension and was located in the right lobe near the apex.
Tumor was confined to prostate.
The apical, basal, pseudocapsular and soft tissue resection margins were free of tumor.
Seminal vesicles were free of tumor.
Right pelvic node - benign fibroadiopse tissue. no lymph node is identified.
Left pelvic node - one small lymph node, negative for tumor (0/1)
AJCC stage: pT2 NO MX
I know you mean well, but I just cannot agree with anything you posted in this particular thread.
If Frank Zappa had attended this fair he'd probably be alive today. And Frank didn't need any education.
40 years old - Diagnosed at 40
Robotic Surgery Mount Sinai with Dr. Samadi Jan, 2011
complete urinary control and good erections with and without meds
Prostate was small, 34 grams.
Final Gleason score 7 (3+4)
Less than 5% of slides involved tumor
Tumor measured 5 mm in greatest dimension and was located in the right lobe near the apex.
Tumor was confined to prostate.
The apical, basal, pseudocapsular and soft tissue resection margins were free of tumor.
Seminal vesicles were free of tumor.
Right pelvic node - benign fibroadiopse tissue. no lymph node is identified.
Left pelvic node - one small lymph node, negative for tumor (0/1)
AJCC stage: pT2 NO MX
clocknut, what you said was that we ought to respect an individual's ability to make a decision, without respecting his right to be fully informed, as I am advocating. In economics, we call your position caveat emptor. It doesn't work in economics (a recent Nobel prize was on the subject of decisions made with imperfect knowledge) and it's certainly not a good basis for medical decision making. I think doctors have an ethical responsibility to assure to the extent they can, that my brothers are as informed as practicable.
Tall Allen, that's just a completely wrong interpretation of what I was saying. I did not say we anything about not "respecting his right to be fully informed." (although I'm not sure there is such a "right," but then everything is a "right" these days.
More correctly we all have every right to become informed. It is no one's "right" to force information on us, though some of us may feel it's our duty to force information even when it isn't sought. Clearly, the intelligent man will seek to inform himself, and my opinion of men is high enough to believe that they will generally do that without interference from those of us who might consider ourselves more enlightened. As I said in my earlier post, there are those among us who think they possess more wisdom than the average guy: they know what brand of shoes he should buy, what make of car, what kind of sweetener, and they feel compelled to force their wisdom on the unenlightened. I don't see it that way. Nor am I saying that you are that kind of person.
More correctly we all have every right to become informed. It is no one's "right" to force information on us, though some of us may feel it's our duty to force information even when it isn't sought. Clearly, the intelligent man will seek to inform himself, and my opinion of men is high enough to believe that they will generally do that without interference from those of us who might consider ourselves more enlightened. As I said in my earlier post, there are those among us who think they possess more wisdom than the average guy: they know what brand of shoes he should buy, what make of car, what kind of sweetener, and they feel compelled to force their wisdom on the unenlightened. I don't see it that way. Nor am I saying that you are that kind of person.
Also, in an earlier comment you mentioned several types of screenings which you say differ from the PSA screening, in that they are not associated with "harms": cholesterol, blood cells, blood glucose, EKGs
As is the case with the PSA test, the tests themselves are not "harmful," but if that EKG reveals arterial blockage, the remedy could result in death; the glucose results could lead to daily injections of insulin, severe changes in diet. A high number on the PSA test only suggests further study. It's the biopsy, and how the results of the biopsy are interpreted that should be of concern.
BTW, the President's annual physical includes a PSA test. Do you think that if it's important enough for the President to be screened (or tested, if you prefer), then perhaps it's also important for the rest of us schmucks?
BTW, the President's annual physical includes a PSA test. Do you think that if it's important enough for the President to be screened (or tested, if you prefer), then perhaps it's also important for the rest of us schmucks?
Post Edited (clocknut) : 8/7/2013 5:22:13 PM (GMT-6)
Clock--+1..You forgot to mention that Romney had his last September--if anyone cares--lol
Bill
Age 71--a "well seasoned" vet
Dx'd Sept 2010 by symptoms at age68--PSA 4.89--5 G8's and 4 G7's out of 10 cores.t3ahigh risk-High volume with extra capular extension present..79.2Gys IMRT completed in Feb 2011 with 6 months casodex and 3 years lupron--.06 psa after radiation and <.03 April 2013..Last 6-month lupron shot due in Oct 2013..Side Effects--fatigue and emotional highs and lows
Bill
Age 71--a "well seasoned" vet
Dx'd Sept 2010 by symptoms at age68--PSA 4.89--5 G8's and 4 G7's out of 10 cores.t3ahigh risk-High volume with extra capular extension present..79.2Gys IMRT completed in Feb 2011 with 6 months casodex and 3 years lupron--.06 psa after radiation and <.03 April 2013..Last 6-month lupron shot due in Oct 2013..Side Effects--fatigue and emotional highs and lows
yes, outstanding posts by Clocknut in this thread. Fully agree with all he has said.
Allen, I am your brother too, right? There are a lot of things I need from you as an advocate, just not the ones you're advocating here in all honesty.
40 years old - Diagnosed at 40
Robotic Surgery Mount Sinai with Dr. Samadi Jan, 2011
complete urinary control and good erections with and without meds
Prostate was small, 34 grams.
Final Gleason score 7 (3+4)
Less than 5% of slides involved tumor
Tumor measured 5 mm in greatest dimension and was located in the right lobe near the apex.
Tumor was confined to prostate.
The apical, basal, pseudocapsular and soft tissue resection margins were free of tumor.
Seminal vesicles were free of tumor.
Right pelvic node - benign fibroadiopse tissue. no lymph node is identified.
Left pelvic node - one small lymph node, negative for tumor (0/1)
AJCC stage: pT2 NO MX
Allen, I am your brother too, right? There are a lot of things I need from you as an advocate, just not the ones you're advocating here in all honesty.
40 years old - Diagnosed at 40
Robotic Surgery Mount Sinai with Dr. Samadi Jan, 2011
complete urinary control and good erections with and without meds
Prostate was small, 34 grams.
Final Gleason score 7 (3+4)
Less than 5% of slides involved tumor
Tumor measured 5 mm in greatest dimension and was located in the right lobe near the apex.
Tumor was confined to prostate.
The apical, basal, pseudocapsular and soft tissue resection margins were free of tumor.
Seminal vesicles were free of tumor.
Right pelvic node - benign fibroadiopse tissue. no lymph node is identified.
Left pelvic node - one small lymph node, negative for tumor (0/1)
AJCC stage: pT2 NO MX
Gunfighter - No one has a crystal ball about what would have been. In my case, I had two unnecessary (in hindsight) biopsies before I had some urinary symptoms that led to a PSA test... I know that we all don't have early symptoms. Even in the sticks, prostate cancer is not invisible and most men are aware of it.mI am not against screening -- in fact, I think its probably a great idea for men in the 55-69 age range to get screened. I'm only against routine screening. In my opinion, it should always be part of a well-considered decision.
A Yooper - Perhaps this event is being done with an educational component. If so, I think there should be a two-step process. The education at the event, and the blood draw on a separate day at the doctor's office or lab. That would give the man an unpressured breather in which to decide if screening is right for him. Having a fair where men jump on the bandwagon to get free screening (limited time offer - get yours now!) runs counter to the respect that should be given to his decision.
A Yooper - Perhaps this event is being done with an educational component. If so, I think there should be a two-step process. The education at the event, and the blood draw on a separate day at the doctor's office or lab. That would give the man an unpressured breather in which to decide if screening is right for him. Having a fair where men jump on the bandwagon to get free screening (limited time offer - get yours now!) runs counter to the respect that should be given to his decision.
Allen - you turn screening into an educational course with mandatory sessions and nobody will come. Ain't nobody got time for that. And I disagree that most men are aware of prostate cancer and prostate cancer screening.
I was screened at 40 and a G7 was found. So glad it was found at 40 and not at 54/55. I'll never know for sure, but my "so far" perfect recovery is, in my opinion, a direct result of finding it and treating it so early in my life. Not that I wouldn't have preferred to to find an aggressive variation at 75/80 to be honest.
40 years old - Diagnosed at 40
Robotic Surgery Mount Sinai with Dr. Samadi Jan, 2011
complete urinary control and good erections with and without meds
Prostate was small, 34 grams.
Final Gleason score 7 (3+4)
Less than 5% of slides involved tumor
Tumor measured 5 mm in greatest dimension and was located in the right lobe near the apex.
Tumor was confined to prostate.
The apical, basal, pseudocapsular and soft tissue resection margins were free of tumor.
Seminal vesicles were free of tumor.
Right pelvic node - benign fibroadiopse tissue. no lymph node is identified.
Left pelvic node - one small lymph node, negative for tumor (0/1)
AJCC stage: pT2 NO MX
I was screened at 40 and a G7 was found. So glad it was found at 40 and not at 54/55. I'll never know for sure, but my "so far" perfect recovery is, in my opinion, a direct result of finding it and treating it so early in my life. Not that I wouldn't have preferred to to find an aggressive variation at 75/80 to be honest.
40 years old - Diagnosed at 40
Robotic Surgery Mount Sinai with Dr. Samadi Jan, 2011
complete urinary control and good erections with and without meds
Prostate was small, 34 grams.
Final Gleason score 7 (3+4)
Less than 5% of slides involved tumor
Tumor measured 5 mm in greatest dimension and was located in the right lobe near the apex.
Tumor was confined to prostate.
The apical, basal, pseudocapsular and soft tissue resection margins were free of tumor.
Seminal vesicles were free of tumor.
Right pelvic node - benign fibroadiopse tissue. no lymph node is identified.
Left pelvic node - one small lymph node, negative for tumor (0/1)
AJCC stage: pT2 NO MX
clocknut said...
It is no one's "right" to force information on us, though some of us may feel it's our duty to force information even when it isn't sought.
It is no one's "right" to force information on us, though some of us may feel it's our duty to force information even when it isn't sought.
I would call it an obligation rather than a right -- in my opinion, the doctor does indeed have the obligation to "force" that information on the consumer/patient even when it isn't sought. In my worldview, it would be unethical to leave him in the dark. Full disclosure is necessary. "Let the patient beware," just doesn't cut it when so much is at stake.
davidg said...
Allen - you turn screening into an educational course with mandatory sessions and nobody will come. Ain't nobody got time for that. And I disagree that most men are aware of prostate cancer and prostate cancer screening.
Allen - you turn screening into an educational course with mandatory sessions and nobody will come. Ain't nobody got time for that. And I disagree that most men are aware of prostate cancer and prostate cancer screening.
In fact, my blood draws are almost always at a separate place and time from my doctor visits.
With 1 in 6 men getting a diagnosis of prostate cancer in their lifetime, it would be very hard to be unaware of it.
I have absolutely no doubt that education about prostate cancer is usually lacking at the time men are first screened. And these events, similar to the ones I have attended, are always lacking in information unless I bring it. I think that it's the screening organization's obligation to bring better material for whom they screen.
In 2009, baseball had it's winter meetings in Las Vegas. Ed Randall got a hold of me and recruited my UsTOO guys to come and help him with a screening event for the baseball meeting attendees. Skip Lockwood was there from ZERO complete with the converted bus that was a lab and screening center. I managed to keep one of the forms we had to have who ever was being screened fill out. That's it. They got the typical statistic sheet and stuck in the arm. I won't mention which baseball executive passed out from the blood test but that happened.
My point is that no information was truly given, even with ZERO there, Ed's Bat for the Cure was there, and our brochure.
This shouldn't happen. I learned from that experience. If I'm at a screening event, I'm well armed with information and will assume no one else was bringing it.
Ed's doing better with it too. He's got much better documentation. I've been handing them out ever since at the 51's games.
Tony
In 2009, baseball had it's winter meetings in Las Vegas. Ed Randall got a hold of me and recruited my UsTOO guys to come and help him with a screening event for the baseball meeting attendees. Skip Lockwood was there from ZERO complete with the converted bus that was a lab and screening center. I managed to keep one of the forms we had to have who ever was being screened fill out. That's it. They got the typical statistic sheet and stuck in the arm. I won't mention which baseball executive passed out from the blood test but that happened.
My point is that no information was truly given, even with ZERO there, Ed's Bat for the Cure was there, and our brochure.
This shouldn't happen. I learned from that experience. If I'm at a screening event, I'm well armed with information and will assume no one else was bringing it.
Ed's doing better with it too. He's got much better documentation. I've been handing them out ever since at the 51's games.
Tony
Tall Allen,
Maybe we're going in circles here. Of course it's a doctor's obligation to inform a patient about the possible consequences of a procedure. I personally don't think a routine PSA test rises to that level or that it requires a day of thinking it over or an hour-long lecture, but to each his own on that. That's why we choose our doctors carefully and find those who know what to tell us and when to tell it, and with whom we have good communication.
During my annual physicals, each of which used to include a PSA test among the blood work, the doctor certainly didn't have the luxury of time to explain the PSA test, the ramifications of a high reading, the function of the prostate, the possible complications involved in the various therapies, the conflicting points of view on various courses of action and so forth. That's where MY obligation as a patient came in. If anything adverse were to be revealed, THEN I would expect my doctor to talk to me about risks and to guide me in the decision-making process based on his broad experience and expertise.
The ONE thing I expect from my physician is that he be on the lookout for conditions that might kill me. Thankfully, he did that by including a PSA test in my annual physical exam. No ASCO-approved patient education tool required. Had he failed to that, if he had been among those who see harm in the PSA test and who don't insist on it, I would be an extremely unhappy individual.