My first post - PCa diagnosed - looking for advice on HDR BT

What a great forum! I'm looking forward to getting to know some of you good men on this forum as time moves forward.

I have a family history of PCa, both my father and his older brother were diagnosed and treated for PCa. My father's brother was diagnosed when he mustered out of the Navy in the late 1990's at age 48 and had LDR BT and EBRT back then. He is still alive and kicking today. My father was diagnosed at age 60 in 2010 (GS7) and chose open RP at Johns Hopkins with Alan Partin.

Due to my family history I started getting my PSA checked in year 2000, and way back then it was 4.4. Went through the obligatory antibiotics and it was still 3.8. Had my first random 12 core biopsy 5/2000, all negative. Have been tracking PSA and had repeat biopsies over the years. Had a MRI in 11/13 at Johns Hopkins, found a couple of areas of suspicion. MRI guided biopsy found 1/12 core with less than 5% cancer. Started active surveillance.

Went to NIH last November seeking possible focal ablation clinical trials, had endo rectal coil MRI and fusion biopsy, 6/18 cores positive, all GS6, negative DRE. One of the 6 cores was not seen on the MRI, which means I'm not a good candidate for focal ablation trials. I don't have the exact scores in front of me at the moment, I'll get them into my signature soon enough, but it's now time to seek treatment.

Fast forward to now, I'm age 44, and I've had consults at JH (robotic RP), NIH (robotic RP), Penn (PBRT), and Fox Chase (HDR BT, IMRT, IGRT). I was really leaning toward PBRT all along, but the chair of RO at Fox Chase made me think twice about HDR BT monotherapy. Has anyone on here been treated at Fox Chase using HDR BT? Any other locations that I should consider for HDR BT in the NYC-Philly-D.C. metro area? As a general rule I know the doctor with the most experience is usually the best bet for the best outcome.

Any/all advice would be most appreciated!
Best Regards,

CJ

Diagnosed at 42, 11/13, PSA 5.8, DRE negative, GS 6, 1 of 12 cores positive, <5%. MRI guided biopsy at Johns Hopkins. Active surveillance chosen.

NIH T3 endo-rectal MRI 11/14, PSA 6.5, fusion MRI guided biopsy 5/15. 6/18 cores positive for G6. DRE negative.

Consults at NIH, JH, Penn, Fox Chase. Pursuing HBR BT tentatively scheduled for 2/16.
CJ, it sounds like you've been doing everything you needed to do so far. I can't speak to practioners in your area, but I"d like to offer my welcome and know that we're with you wherever your journey takes you. I'm coming up on 9 months since RALP and doing great.
Age at Diagnosis: 56
Biopsy: 3 of 12, G3+3, all on LT side, 20%, 5%, 3%
Clinical Stage T1C
Bone Scan, CT scan negative for spread
RALP on 2/17/15, BJC St. Louis, Dr. Figenshau
No EPE, 20% organ involvement, g3+4 final
PSA 3/10/15: 0.10
5/18/15: <.04
8/24/15: <.04
My Story: www.healingwell.com/community/default.aspx?f=35&m=3300024
Welcome to HW, sorry you need to be here.

I can't speak to providers in your area, but have you considered SBRT? I hear good things about that. I went the IMRT route since my health plan covered it and there was a great RO and treatment center very close to home.

The HDR BT is a good choice too.

Hang in there and keep us updated on your progress,
Andrew
I'll be in the shop.
Age 55, 52 at DX
PSA 4.2 10/11, 1.9 6/12, 1.2 12/12, 1.0 5/13, .6 11/13, .7 5/14, .5 10/14, .5 4/15, .3 10/15
G 3+4
Stage T1C
2 out of 14 cores positive
Treatment IGRT - 2/2012
My latest blog post
Hi Hitch.... My first post too, but you can pretty much see my journey in my signature. Dr. Carter at JH performed my 'open' RRP surgery and so far, I'm doing pretty well nearly 3 months out. I was 51 when diagnosed, and since I was 'bilateral' I wasn't a candidate for the AS program at JH, even though my other numbers seemed to fit the bill. As Dr. Carter is in charge of the program at JH, as well as the director of adult urology, I went with his recommendation for surgery. When I asked about radiation treatments rather than surgery at our post-biopsy meeting, he stated that I was a bit on the young side for that treatment, as there's the potential for other side effects that, if I were older, I'd probably outlive. I believe he mentioned urethral and bladder cancers, and others, as possibilities. I know of the whole 'surgeons recommend surgery' thing, but I, and even more so my wife, wanted it out.

To each his own, and I understand that, but I'm OK with my decision---well, now that it's over, LOL!. My incontinence is minimal. Actually, mostly only a 'squirt' when doing something stressful and forgetting to take it slowly and prepare, and my ED issues seem to be coming along pretty well too (thankfully, my nerves were spared). I just have to get my wife on board, LOL!!!

Good luck!
51 yoa at Dx--Some family history of PCa
From 9/2013 to 3/2015 PSAs from 4.85 to 6.7, TRUS Bx-neg 12/2013, 12/2014 PCA3:38, 3/2015 switched from local urology group to Johns Hopkins, PSA 5.8/FPSA 17.4/PHI 28.4, 3/2015 mp3T MRI & Fusion-Guided Bx @ Johns Hopkins, 2/14 cores pos, Bilateral, <5% involvement, GL=6, RRP: 8/2015 @ Hopkins

Post surgical pathology – Upstaged to G7 (3+4), confined throughout, Negative margins, lymphnodes (11), and seminal vesicle involvement. Additional findings: HGPIN, pT2C pNO

PSA 11/2015 <0.1
A welcome to both HitchHiker and MD Native! MD, I'm very glad to hear you're doing well in the early innings! I was also 51 when I was diagnosed.

HitchHiker, I'm not familiar with HDR brachy programs on the east coast, although others here probably are. A member named JNF, one of the HDR brachy pioneers here had his done in Atlanta, so not quite where you're looking for. For my part, I had mine at UCLA and I'm doing very well 2+ years out as a G9.

Good luck to you and let us know how we can help!
Age 54, Diagnosed at 51
PSA 9.6, Gleason: 9 (5+4), three 7s (3+4)
Chose triple play of HDR brachy, IMRT and HT (Casodex, Lupron and Zytiga)
Completed HT (18 months) in April 2014
9/15: T = 209, PSA = 0.14
can't offer advice on your tx, but do want to extend a warm welcome to HW and best wishes for successful tx to both Hitch Hiker and MD native!
Beth n Gary
Husband age 56
Dx: PC w/ widespread mets to bones & nodes 11/2010
PSA @ dx 1983 Gleason 4+5 stage IV
Docetaxel, Zytiga 2012 Smarium, Xtandi 2013 xofigo 2014
Cabazitaxel, Zytiga rerun 2014
Ongoing: denosomab and Lupron
Begin RT to sacrum X 10 PSA 1/15 100 +
2/15End Zytiga
Pilot study DRibbles 3/15
liver mets
Psa 900.6/15 End study/ start docetaxil
PSA 7/15:1054 9/15:921 10/15:854!
Pleased to meet you both. No advice as you seem to have things under control. :-)
65 yo, 2012 PSA 11, "bump" with DRE, biopsy 11/12 12/12 cores with acinar adenocarcinoma, Da Vinci RP 12/27/2012. 35 gram tumor, 2 EC ext., 1 sem. ves. + marg T3b N0 M0, G7(4+3). 2 week post-RP PSA 0.2, started Firmagon ADT, catheter removed. Pads for 3 months, then done. 3 months post-op EBRT prostate bed and interior pelvic lymph nodes ~ 80 Gy/40 ses. Last Eligard 10/14, therapy ended 4/30/2015
Welcome hitchHiker. Sounds like you've got a lot of the decision making done and just need the right Dr.
If you don't get any names in response to this thread, I would suggest you look for a post, any post, by Tall Allen, and click on the envelope under his name. That will allow you to email him directly, he's usually quite active here but is off the forum more or less for the month of November. He'll likely have some good suggestions.
Dx Age 64 Nov 2014, 4.3
BX 3 of 12 cores positive original pathologyG6, G6, G8 (3+5)
downgraded to 3+3=6 by Dr Epstein, JH
RALP with Dr Ash Tewari Jan 6, 2015
Post surgical pathology – G7 (3+4), ECE, Margins, LN, SV all negative
PSA @ 6 weeks 2/15, .<02, 4/15 <.02 7/15 <.02, 10/15 0.00 (new lab)
My Story: tinyurl.com/oo9x4aq
HitchHiker,

There are relatively few centers known for their mono HDR programs, none that I had found in the Philly to NYC area when I was researching the procedure. I had not seen references to Fox Chase and their program when I was doing my research a year ago. For all I know their program is very experienced and great, but I didn't come across it.

My health insurance carrier was willing to cover the cost of the procedure for me wherever, if I was willing to travel, which I was, and I was treated at UCLA. The other main HDR centers you will find referenced on this site are in Detroit and Atlanta. I also recall someone else being treated in Chicago.

I also gave serious consideration to SBRT, but was told my insurance carrier would likely not approve me for this procedure without a fight, and even with a fight, there was no guarantee of approval. Not wanting to delay my treatment further I followed through on the HDR.

Post treatment follow up for you would certainly be simplified if you were treated locally.

Good luck,
Age 61, Fit
-DX Jan 2015
-PSA (Finasteride reduced) 2/15 - 3.46, 9/14 - 3.38, 8/14 - 2.5, 2/14 - 2.1, 9/13 - 1.7, 12/12 - 1.4

HDR Brachytherapy at UCLA 4/30 and 5/7

-2 cores positive - 30-40%
-Gleason 7 (3+4)
Hitchhiker, I've done a lot of research into HDR monotherapy. A lot. I've also spoken with Martinez and Ghilezan in the Detroit area and Dr. Kamrava at UCLA, all HDR experts. I'm not aware of any renowned HDR treatment centers in your neck of the woods. You may need to travel to get it, so Detroit might be your best bet.

I don't know how to make links turn blue here but here is the link you can copy and paste to find the contact info for Martinez & Ghilezan: http://www.21stcenturyoncology.com/physicians/martinez-alvaro-a

Here is the link to Dr. Mitchell Kamrava, who will do a free phone consult with you after getting all your medical records: https://www.uclahealth.org/provider/mitchell-kamrava-md There's a link on the UCLA website to initiate the phone consult procedure. See the link in the far lower right hand corner: http://radonc.ucla.edu/site.cfm?id=418

After doing my due diligence with HDR, I learned that the permanent side effects associated with it are about the same as with SBRT. So I'm now investigating SBRT as it is less invasive and available in my area, unlike HDR.

Good luck!!
60 yrs old
PCa Dx: 8/1/15 T1c
PSA increased from 1.6 to 2.7 in last year
Random biopsy: 5/12 positive cores; all 6s; bilat; volume 10-45%
Bone scan and CT negative
Strong family history of PCa (identical twin & father)
IIRC, Memorial Sloan Kettering in New York does HDR Brachy. Am uncertain as to how much history there is.

Duke in Durham NC also lists HDR brachy on their web site. Have seen few references to their program so am uncertain as to how long they have had the program.

I see a lot of references about UCLA here at HW. I'm guessing that many times if someone is having to pay flights and travel anyhow, they elect to go to UCLA if they don't have something nearby.
See location and occupation for email
Upstate SC, halfway between Atlanta and Charlotte

DOB 1946

PCA 3 score 49
PHI score 43.9
3T enhanced MRI - negative reading. However, not mp, so of questionable value,

PSA 6.1 8/13/15
PSA 6.79 7/14/15
PSA 1.9 8/xx/11
PSA 2.2 5/04/11
PSA 2.0 7/28/05
Ken said...
IIRC, Memorial Sloan Kettering in New York does HDR Brachy. Am uncertain as to how much history there is.


I had a consult at MSK. They do HDR Monotherapy, infrequently. More frequently, when they do HDR it is part of a combination therapy. Maybe relevant, maybe not, and I am not trying to say they are not capable, but if you're looking for a center that specializes in HDR Monotherapy then MSK is probably not the choice.
Age 61, Fit
-DX Jan 2015
-PSA (Finasteride reduced) 2/15 - 3.46, 9/14 - 3.38, 8/14 - 2.5, 2/14 - 2.1, 9/13 - 1.7, 12/12 - 1.4

HDR Brachytherapy at UCLA 4/30 and 5/7

-2 cores positive - 30-40%
-Gleason 7 (3+4)
Hello Hitchhiker and MDNative!

Nothing useful to add to the sage advice already given but I did want to say 'hello' since I'm kinda slip-streaming you guys in the mid-Atlantic. I'm about to have my Fusion biopsy with Dr Schaeffer at Johns Hopkins, praying for a negative but prepared (well you know what I mean) for a positive...

It might be useful to share information, contacts, thoughts and of course moral support going forward!

As others have said, sorry you have to be here, but of all the places to be, here is the best.

yeah
7/6/14 PSA: 1.07
7/6/15 PSA: 4.3 DRE: Negative (PCP)
7/17/15 PSA: 2.56
8/10/15 PSA 8.41
8/14/15 PSA: 8.5 PHI 47.5 DRE: Enlarged but no nodule (URO)
9/18/15 3TMRI: 1xPIRADS 3/5 9mm lesion
Next: 11/10/15 UroNav Fusion biopsy (Hopkins)
Travel assistance - www.healingwell.com/community/default.aspx?f=35&m=3514920
Works Out said...
More frequently, when they do HDR it is part of a combination therapy. Maybe relevant, maybe not, and I am not trying to say they are not capable, but if you're looking for a center that specializes in HDR Monotherapy then MSK is probably not the choice.


Thanks for your input, I have been beginning to wonder that about Duke. My consult there for intitial diagnosis is about two weeks away.
Thought of another thing. Different centers have different protocol schedules with how many separate days you are treated and how many times per day. Sometimes they will offer choices. And studies are not yet showing one protocol as necessarily better than others.

Some centers now offer all treatments to be done in a single day as an option, though it's not necessarily their only option. Based on limited data I did read all treatments in a single day did seem more likely to lead to requiring going home with a catheter. I decided against that, but believe that was the only protocol being offered at MSK.
Age 61, Fit
-DX Jan 2015
-PSA (Finasteride reduced) 2/15 - 3.46, 9/14 - 3.38, 8/14 - 2.5, 2/14 - 2.1, 9/13 - 1.7, 12/12 - 1.4

HDR Brachytherapy at UCLA 4/30 and 5/7

-2 cores positive - 30-40%
-Gleason 7 (3+4)
It'll be one year next month that I had HDR mono. Two sessions, two weeks apart. All is fine except for reduced semen output during sex. And it's pretty significant. It doesn't bother my wife and my nurse said it was preferable (she just said that during my checkup 😜). That's something to get used to though. I have some mild ED, but take a half of Levitra.

My next PSA is in a month.
Age: 49
Father - prostate, colon, intestinal, bladder, brain, and melonoma cancer. died a month before 82nd BD 'with' lung cancer.
PSA: '13 - 2.5, '14 - 4.5, Jan. '15: 1.7, May '15: 1.4, Sept. '15: 2.1
Dx'd 10/2014
3+3=6 (<5% of core), 3+4=7 (10% of one core), 3+4=7 (40% and 50%) Left base, mid and apex.
Hobbies: Pickup basketball 3x/week, crossfit 2x/week.
HDR Brachy 12/2 & 12/16 Atlanta
Dewayne, did you have Dr. Rossi do your HDR? I'm scheduled for 2 sessions this month so wanted to see what you can tell about the procedure and short-term side effects and discomfort/pain. I also see that you had a problem with an anal fissure; was that following the HDR?
Regards,
Steve in Atlanta
Thanks for all of the great info so far gents! I've been dealing with an elder care issue for part of this weekend so I apologize for not being near a keyboard as a result.

InTheShop, yes I'm considering SBRT. HDR-BT is basically the first iteration of hypofractionated prostate cancer treatment, which is what SBRT is modeled on. SBRT, or "cyberknife" as it is affectionately called, still uses photons for treatment, as opposed to PBRT which uses protons. I'm an engineer so the theoretical aspects of protons interest me. I do like the less invasive aspects of SBRT or SRT, but the limitations of photon based RT and the damage to surrounding tissue always concern me. HDR BT, while a bit more invasive, does not introduce as much radiation since it does not pass through other tissue. At least this is my current assessment. :-) There are certainly trade-offs no matter which option we choose, it's really "the best of the worst" when it comes to choosing any one treatment plan.

NativeMD, glad to share in our mutual introduction to HW! :-) I'm glad you are well on the road to recovery. I've also heard the same info from urologists (surgeons) about longer term secondary cancer risks, and this was indeed true many years ago prior to the advent of much more targeted RT options. More recent 10-20 year stats for more targeted RT shows very little statistical differences in bladder or rectal cancer rates for RT patients as opposed to general population cancer stats. At least this is what my research has shown me over the past few years.

Fox Chase is one of the few centers in the Northeast known for HDR BT and for RT in general. FCCC was the first to do HDR BT in the Northeast region actually. FCCC has been doing HDR BT, IMRT, IGRT, SRT, SBRT for many years now. Dr. Horwitz, Chair of RO, is who I've been speaking with. Anyone in the northeast and in particular, in the Philly metro area who is looking for a center that has good prostate cancer experience, here's a link:

https://www.fccc.edu/cancer/types/prostate/index.html

Here's a link to Dr. Horwitz:

https://www.fccc.edu/physicians/team/rad-onc/horwitz.html

WorksOut and DCD55 thanks for all of the info and links, I will check them all out and let you guys know what I find. I'm not opposed to traveling anywhere if it's the right thing to do, the way I look at my situation is, once and done, and I want it done right by those who have done it so many times it's almost second nature.

Horwitz at FCCC has been doing HDR monotherapy since Y2K, and has several hundred under his belt from what info I have gathered - waiting on actual stats to be delivered to me now to be sure. Basically FCCC moved from LDR to HDR in Y2K and only does LDR under certain specific cases where HDR is not a good match. I'll get more info on stats and share them with you all here. FCCC has an entire dedicated suite only for HDR BT, which has MRI, ultrasound and CT dedicated all in the same small space specific to HDR BT procedures. I saw the suite when I last visited - so they have made the investment over time. More to come as I learn more. Scheduling for HDR-BT is 3-4 months out at FCCC right now - to give at least a possinle indicator of the volume.

Paul65, thanks for chiming in! I had my fusion biopsy at NIH just last May, with Dr. Pinto, who trained the entire staff at JH on the fusion software and procedure. If you have any questions, I have firsthand experience with the fusion biopsy procedure.

WorksOut, specific to FCCC HDR-BT, it was two procedures, seven days apart, two fraction RT treatments each day - so four total fractions over a seven day stretch. I believe there were other fractions available - but this is what FCCC recommended for my specific case data.

Dewayne and WorksOut, thanks for the HDR specific treatment experience data. This is what I'm looking for most of all, folks who have had HDR-BT and their outcomes and experiences. So thanks again.

Keep the great info coming! I will keep sharing what I learn under this thread as well.
Best Regards,

CJ

Diagnosed at 42, 11/13, PSA 5.8, DRE negative, GS 6, 1 of 12 cores positive, <5%. MRI guided biopsy at Johns Hopkins. Active surveillance chosen.

NIH T3 endo-rectal MRI 11/14, PSA 6.5, fusion MRI guided biopsy 5/15. 6/18 cores positive for G6. DRE negative.

Consults at NIH, JH, Penn, Fox Chase. Pursuing HBR BT tentatively scheduled for 2/16.
HH, sounds like you have definitely done your homework. And that's critical.

There's another terrific PCa forum (in case you haven't yet discovered it) and here's a link to a thread I started there on HDR for what it's worth. Lots of fine people there, too, with some crossover here. A guy there named Tall Allen is VERY knowledgeable and helpful and has a great website full of info (the second link below):

/www.inspire.com/groups/us-too-prostate-cancer/discussion/side-effects-hdr-monotherapy-seems-to-have-the-least/

http://prostatecancerinfolink.net/
60 yrs old
PCa Dx: 8/1/15 T1c
PSA increased from 1.6 to 2.7 in last year
Random biopsy: 5/12 positive cores; all 6s; bilat; volume 10-45%
Bone scan and CT negative
Strong family history of PCa (identical twin & father)
HH, that first link doesn't work. I'll try again.....

https://www.inspire.com/groups/us-too-prostate-cancer/discussion/side-effects-hdr-monotherapy-seems-to-have-the-least/[url]
60 yrs old
PCa Dx: 8/1/15 T1c
PSA increased from 1.6 to 2.7 in last year
Random biopsy: 5/12 positive cores; all 6s; bilat; volume 10-45%
Bone scan and CT negative
Strong family history of PCa (identical twin & father)