Patient Visit Summaries: what your doctor writes up after your appointments with him

Your appointment with your doctor is over. You both smile and shake hands, he says he looks forward to seeing you the next time, and you exit the exam room and head for the checkout station.

At that point maybe you aren't thinking all that much more about the appointment you just had, but it's likely your doctor is. He's heading towards his office to sit down at his desktop and type up and save a summary of what the two of you just talked about and did at the appointment.

"Patient Visit Summary" (PVS) seems to be a common online term I found for what he will type up and save (although there are other names for it, such as After Visit Summary, or simply Clinical Summary), and it will obviously be a short-but-complete write-up of the important points covered and procedures that were done. When completed, it will most likely be added to an online folder with all of the other patient visit summaries that your doctor has typed up for you for your previous appointments.

So just how is this patient visit summary prepared? Is there a medical standard for doing it? Is certain information required to be in it? Or can it be just the doctor's more-or-less freeform personal notes on what he felt were the important matters of the appointment?

After a little websearching, this seems to be the most relevant government guideline I found, which also provides a link to a more detailed document:

https://www.healthit.gov/resource/providing-clinical-summaries-patients-after-each-office-visit-technical-guide

And from another relevant document, these points are recommended for inclusion:

The PVS should include:

1. information and instructions containing the patient name, provider’s office contact information, date, location of visit.

2. an updated medication list, updated vitals, reason(s) for visit.

3. instructions based on clinical discussions that took place during the office visit.

4. any updates to a problem list, immunizations or medications administered during visit.

5. summary of topics covered/considered during visit.

6. time and location of next appointment/testing if scheduled, or a recommended appointment time if not scheduled.

7. list of other appointments and tests that the patient needs to schedule, with contact information, recommended patient decision aids, laboratory and other diagnostic test orders, test/laboratory results (if received before 24 hours after visit), and symptoms.


from:

https://www.cms.gov/regulations-and-guidance/legislation/ehrincentiveprograms/downloads/13_clinical_summaries.pdf#:~:text=clinical%20summary%20%e2%80%93%20an%20after-visit%20summary%20that%20provides,received%20before%2024%20hours%20after%20visit%29%2c%20and%20symptoms.

But I also found that the above are presented as guidelines, and not as mandatory, so it seems that the note-recording doctor does have some liberty in writing up his notes.

Another recommendation I noted stressed that the PVS needs to be as close to 100% objective as possible, with any subjective observations on the part of the doctor minimized or preferably absent. Added was that the PVS should be written by the doctor with the thought that the patient might actually be reading it someday, certainly possible, with patient access to medical records much supported these days, and there should be nothing in the PVS that might lead to doctor-patient misunderstanding. "I think this patient is a total hypochondriac!" is an observation probably best left out of a PVS.

Incidentally, my own general health care clinic here in Gainesville:

https://ufhealth.org/uf-health-family-medicine-main

does allow access to patients' past PVS reports on their personal account page. I have looked at mine, as they are posted and accessible a day or two following an appointment, and I have been satisfied that my family doctor has been objective and thorough in writing them.

Do any of you have access to your own PVS reports, if you are seen at a facility that allows such access, presumably online? If unsure, you might want to check and see if earlier PVS write-ups of your appointments are available to you.

If access is available, it just might be a good idea to call up and review what your doctor wrote up about one or more of your past appointments with him. To confirm that you and he are on the same page about things, and perhaps to remind yourself of something that was said or done at a past appointment that may have slipped your mind, but is recorded there in the PVS for you to see.

Another tool in our relationship with our doctor, and one we might get into the habit of regularly reviewing, if it is possible for us to do so.
Age: 77
Chronic prostatitis (age 60 on)
BPH w/ urinary obstruction, 6/2011
TURP, 7/2011
Ongoing high PSA, 7/2011-12/2011
Biopsy, 12/2011: positive 3/12 (90%, 70%, 5%)
Gleason 6(3+3), T1c
No mets, PCa likely still organ contained
IMRT w/ HT (Lupron), 4/2012-6/2012
PSAs (since post-IMRT): < 1.0
LoL, I have access to my after visit summary. What a joke, my annual visit consist of my PCP asking questions. He never touches me unless I state I have a problem. However, on the summary he puts down my ear canals are clear, heart rate is fine and numerous other systems are within normal range for my age. All of my specialists go into great detail what they found during an extensive examination. The required annual is just pencilled whipped to meet the requirement. My best to all,
Jack
Age 70
DX 2017
5/16 BLOOD IN SEMEN FOR OVER A YEAR CHANGED URO
6/17 PSA 2.1 10/17 PSA 6.1 TURP GL-6 3+3 WATCH
BX 7/18 GL 7 3+4 WATCH, CHANGED URO
PSA-11/18 4.6 12/19 1.6 6/20 1.41 12/20 1.89 6/21 1.99 12/21 1.21
1/22 0.17 03/22 0.13 6/22 0.06 9/22 0.04 12/22 0.04 3/23 0.01
BX-8/21 GL 8 -1 CORE 20% PNI 10/21 ADT FIRMAGON, 11/21 IMRT 28 FRAC 70GY. ADT Orgovyx
I will second what Jack said. I don't bother to read visit summaries anymore. For ALL of my doctors the notes seemed to be canned -- usually just a copy of the previous note. Conversations that never took place and omissions of conversations that did take place. I think the notes are mainly for CYA purposes.
Part I 2015, Age 54. Age now 63
PSA: 20.8 Bx: All cores G7 (4+3)
RALP & Adjuvant RT
Pathology: G8 (4+4)+5
PSA nadir: 0.1, steady increase

Part II 2019
Lupron/Xtandi, PSA: <0.01
2021: Reclast (annual infusion)
Same for me. “Discussed with patient….bla blah blah , “ yet these are discussions that never happened. It’s all boilerplate cut and paste from what I’ve seen.

I even felt that way after reading my surgical summary
I am not a doctor, just a guy without a prostate
Dx Age 64 Nov 2014, PSA 4.3
BX 3 of 12 cores positive original pathology G6
RALP Jan 6, 2015
Post surgical pathology G7 (3+4), - ECE, - Margins, -LN, -SV
PSA @ 6 weeks 2/15, <02, remained <0.02 until 1/2017, .02, repeat 2/2017, still .02. 5/2017-.033, 8/August 2017- .033 8/17 .046, 3/2018 .060. 6/2018 .068, July 2018 - .08, 8/ 2018, .078, Start ADT+SRT.
Sept 2018 thru May 2022 –PSA = <.05
Decipher test, low risk, .37 score
My story.... https://tinyurl.com/45w7789x
Every day’s a bonus – Sonny3
I hear you my brothers ...

My oncologist types up the summary, right as we are wrapping things up.

As I check in, my care nurse types in updated data on my vitals. I'm working on dropping some "winter weight" and I am able to look back and track my progress ~ at present, I have dropped 20 pounds since February.

My lab work results from the past 10 years are also on my online patient account. It's interesting to occasionally look back and see the impact that ZYTIGA, chemotherapy, and radiation had.

One thing to add ~ I have my oncologist add bits of information that I feel is important to note in my record, for future reference.

We note dates of vaccine boosters, PROLIA injections, dates when treatments were given ~ things that I occasionally look up.

At the top of my appointment summaries, it is stated that my case is co-managed with Dr. Kwon at Mayo Clinic. When I have visited Mayo, they have instant access to my summaries.

Some time ago, my main oncologist moved away to a distant state. I will say his summaries were nicely detailed.

When my newer oncologist took over my case, he had memorized the salient points of my case, in remarkable ways, for our first appointment.

That made a huge impression on me. My newer oncologist has carried on the tradition of adding nicely detailed notes. I really value my doctor. He looks after me like a brother.

Some experiences to share today ~

CYCLONE ~ # Iowa State University
PSA At Diagnosis In Year 2013 : 138
Initial Diagnosis: Advanced Prostate Cancer, With Metastases In Both Lungs
Age At Diagnosis: 48 years
ADT Treatments: LUPRON, FIRMAGON, & currently ZOLADEX
Subsequent Treatments: Chemotherapy (TAXOTERE) & ZYTIGA & RADIATION
Additional Consultant - Dr. KWON - Mayo Clinic
Current PSA Level: < 0.10 - Undetectable Range - Treatments Ongoing
Interesting.

Is it the case that some doctors, such as family physicians like mine, take the PVS seriously, and complete it in some detail, while others may have a more dismissive attitude toward it?

If that's what the latter group of doctors does, then it makes me wonder how they prepare to see us when they look at their appointment schedules for the day, and observe that they will be seeing us at 10 AM.

If they have no PVS's from previous appointments to guide them, then how do they know what to check us for, when they do see us at the appointment?

If they have been running annual lab tests on us ("panels," such as Lipid, CBC Autodiff, Comprehensive Metabolic, for example, the ones my doc runs on me) then perhaps they consult past ones of those on their desktops just before coming to the exam room to see us, looking especially for an "H" or an "L" (abnormally high or low reading) next to the various lab test results, and base whatever exam they will do on that.

Some of you suggest that doctors you have seen have done virtually no physical exam during your appointments, but have entered only a general "okay" in whatever PVS they did create. Curious indeed.

And granted that the physical exam that they do perform can seem a bit perfunctory. But maybe they get more from it than we realize.


"Perfunctory" being the exam I myself annually get (and this probably sounds familiar) :

1. Nurse gets height, weight, blood pressure, temperature, pulse,oxygen level. Writes these up for doctor to read.
2. After discussing a few issues, I'm with the doctor and up on the exam table, shirtless, with the doctor moving his stethoscope around my chest and then back, telling me all the while to breathe in and out slowly.
3. He shines the opthalmoscope into my eyes.
4. He shines the otoscope into my ears.
5. A quick look in the mouth with flashlight and tongue depressor.
6. He observes as I reach my arms out in front of me and wiggle my fingers.
7. He presses his fingers up against various points of my abdomen and asks if it hurts (it doesn't).
8. He examines my ankles.

I admit that I for one had always thought that the above steps seemed fewer than I might have thought were necessary to conduct a thorough physical exam. But maybe the doctors still get a lot more information than we know from doing even just those.

And throw in the annual lab test panels (it's amazing what they can learn from even a small blood draw) and maybe they do collect enough information to make reasonable assessments of our health situations.

But to do next to nothing, as some of you have suggested, and scribble just a few general comments in the PVS? Hmmm ... I don't know about that.

In such a case, maybe we should be using all of this to evaluate the doctor as much as he is supposedly evaluating us at that moment.
Age: 77
Chronic prostatitis (age 60 on)
BPH w/ urinary obstruction, 6/2011
TURP, 7/2011
Ongoing high PSA, 7/2011-12/2011
Biopsy, 12/2011: positive 3/12 (90%, 70%, 5%)
Gleason 6(3+3), T1c
No mets, PCa likely still organ contained
IMRT w/ HT (Lupron), 4/2012-6/2012
PSAs (since post-IMRT): < 1.0

Post Edited (81GyGuy) : 6/13/2023 8:33:49 AM (GMT-8)

All interesting points ...

At the large Mayo Clinic in Rochester, Minnesota, I have noticed Dr. Kwon (a friend of mine famously called him "The Mighty Kwon" ) records oral statements, in between consultations, which are then transcribed into detailed patient summaries by his assistants.

At my local clinic, where I see my oncologist, there's a small team of very hard-working and very dedicated oncologists.

I see the seemingly never-ending "flurry" of patients they see, each time I am there, every month. It reminds me of the parent-teacher conference nights I have hosted for years in my classroom, seeing one set of parents right after another.

That schedule is almost dizzying ... so, I an mindful of that when I see my oncologist.

When one of the oncologists at my treatment center is gone or on vacation, the rest of them cover those bases. Hectic, without a doubt ...

As retirements occur, they cover those bases, too ~ until a new oncologist joins the team.

This is when those patient summaries can become critical and vital ... as was the case when my original oncologist moved to a different state, to be reunited with his family from Kenya.

My new oncologist did a REMARKABLE job of "jumping in" and mastering the details of my treatment history from past summary notes.

That did not go unnoticed by me & I knew my new oncologist was the perfect doctor for me, going forward.

CYCLONE ~ # Iowa State University
I forgot to add that my PCP called me to say that I should come in because my T level was seriously low. That was after 6 months out of 18 months of ADT. I do my lab tests at his office and we had previously discussed what ADT does to the PSA and T levels.
Cyclone, you are truly blessed with the doctors treating you.🙏
OT, I can now say that I miss the Arizona heat. I have sweat through all of my clothes visiting Florida.
My best to all,
Jack
Age 70
DX 2017
5/16 BLOOD IN SEMEN FOR OVER A YEAR CHANGED URO
6/17 PSA 2.1 10/17 PSA 6.1 TURP GL-6 3+3 WATCH
BX 7/18 GL 7 3+4 WATCH, CHANGED URO
PSA-11/18 4.6 12/19 1.6 6/20 1.41 12/20 1.89 6/21 1.99 12/21 1.21
1/22 0.17 03/22 0.13 6/22 0.06 9/22 0.04 12/22 0.04 3/23 0.01
BX-8/21 GL 8 -1 CORE 20% PNI 10/21 ADT FIRMAGON, 11/21 IMRT 28 FRAC 70GY. ADT Orgovyx
Don’t sweat it guys, when AI kicks in I am sure that it will be more verbose than the docs.
Dx Feb 18, 2018, 65 years old, PSA 4.4
3+3 and 4+3
RALP Mar 14, 2018, Cleveland Clinic, Dr. Haber
All clear surgical pathology, 4+3 changed to 3+4
Continence an issue. AUS installed June '19
ED, well, it works, kind of
6 week post-op PSA < 0.01 ng/mL
11 month post-op PSA < 0.01 ng
5-tear PSA < .004
23 month PSA < 0.0 ng/mL
36 month PSA < 0.04 ng/mL
Different experience for me - though I use the teaching hospital's family medicine group and see an Advanced Practice Nurse. The APN consults with the physicians if needed.
I must admit that a young resident who picked up my case in 2017 insisted that I needed to get a PSA done as I hadn't had one in awhile - that insistence paid off with a high PSA and the referral to the urology group's surgeons/radiologists.
I find the AVS to be good with the group - easy access via MyChart and they chart my lab results both in and out of the hospital system as I use LabCorp for CMPs and PSA tests. I did get some glucose / insulin tests done and needed to make some changes there through their metabolic center.
One suggestion from Ms GG (RN), is definitely get the surgeon's notes from hospital or outpatient med recs office and keep a copy. Very informative and can be consulted as you move through any medical journey.
63 now, 58 DX, PSA = 16. 8/18 DiVinci RALP Morristown, NJ- Post Op Surgical Path 3+4, margin -, ECE+, 1 SVI+, bladder -, LN - (0/12), pT3b,N0; 1st post op PSA 11/18 <0.006; Decipher 0.7 (high); ART (IMRT) completed 3/19, uPSA 6/19 - 4/20 <0.006; 7/20 (Assay change Labcorp - 4/21 <0.014; 7/21 lost the less than, 0.009; 11/21 up to 0.014; 3/22 - 0.018, 8/22 0.014, 2/23 0.013